To Whom It May Concern at LifeTime Club Management,

We, the undersigned members of LifeTime Club in Charlotte, NC, are writing to express our strong support for Art Calabretta and to urgently request the reversal of his three-month suspension following an incident on September 5th.

Art has been a cornerstone of our pickleball community, contributing immensely to its growth and fostering a positive environment for all members. His reputation for kindness, respect, and integrity is well-established among those who regularly interact with him. The allegations leading to his suspension are both surprising and inconsistent with the character we have consistently observed in him.

We respectfully request that you reconsider this decision for the following reasons:

1. Eyewitness Testimony:Several eyewitnesses present during the incident have provided clear and consistent testimony affirming that Art was not the aggressor in his interaction with the court monitor, Lucia. They report that Art remained calm and did not initiate any physical confrontation. These critical witness statements have been submitted to club management, yet the suspension remains in place.
2. Video Evidence: There are two cameras on either side of the court that, if reviewed, would support these testimonies and clarify the situation.
3. Art's Exemplary Record: Art's long-standing positive behavior and contributions to the club should be taken into account. He has always demonstrated a commitment to fostering a welcoming environment and upholding the standards of conduct that LifeTime values.
4. Concerns about the Court Monitor: It is widely acknowledged within the LT pickleball community that Lucia has displayed unprofessional and aggressive behavior towards members on multiple occasions. While we do not seek her dismissal, we strongly advocate for immediate training and corrective action to address these concerns.

Given Art's exemplary record and the new evidence provided by eyewitnesses, we firmly believe that the suspension is unjust. We respectfully but urgently request that you:

1. Thoroughly review the eyewitness testimonies and video evidence.
2. Consider Art's history of positive contributions to the club.
3. Overturn the suspension decision and reinstate Art's membership immediately.
4. Address the concerns regarding Lucia's behavior through appropriate training and corrective action. According to LifeTime Fitness's Code of Business Conduct and Ethics, aggressive or hostile behavior that creates a reasonable fear of injury or subjects another individual to emotional distress is grounds for disciplinary action, up to and including termination. She initiated the aggressive behavior and violated the code and therefore should be subject to disciplinary action.

Art deserves to continue participating in and contributing to our vibrant community without the burden of an unjust suspension. His dedication to the sport and the community has been invaluable, and we believe his presence enhances the LifeTime Club experience for all members.

Thank you for your immediate attention to this matter. We trust that a thorough and fair review will lead to the reinstatement of Art's membership, restoring him to his valued role within the club.

Sincerely,

The Lifetime Pickleball Community