Petitioning the "RFH Reading Assignments, Rumson NJ 07760" Petition
302 Comments
M
Melissa Rassas Bortnick
10 years ago
Featured
If we want our kids to change the world, they need to understand it. Censorship is the quickest way to cultivate a generation of ignorant adults. Instead, let's support the teachers at RFH, who are well-equipped to help students grow into engaged and thoughtful adults.
J
Jill Healey
10 years ago
Not all parents feel this way- not even most. We live in a town where people want their high school students doing college level work & this is what that entails . I'd much rather my child read one if these books and discuss its greater themes with one of the excellent teachers on staff at RFH then watch most of the garbage that passes for entertainment on TV/movies/media these days.
Q
Quinn McKean
10 years ago
A dangerous and close-minded, paranoid idea! Banning books in not in keeping with an open society.
N
Nancy Kelly
10 years ago
As an RFH graduate I am appalled that the censorship of books is rearing its ugly head. have far too many comments to make here, but I know others will do so about freedom is speech.
As a practical matter, who will be making decisions regarding the "banned list"? Will the BOE be forced to approve a resolution and appoint a committee to oversee its implementation? Of course, any such ban would include books allegedly promoting violence, bullying, racism and sexism, right?
Right?
A
Anonymous
10 years ago
Class of 72
A
Anonymous
10 years ago
Adults with no or limited experience of the world around them are nothing but bigger children.
Favorite Book: Exodus
favorite Once-Banned Book: Red Badge of Courage
I
Idy Lanier
10 years ago
This is a horrifying action. Attempting to control what can be read is the first step toward attempting to control what is thought.
C
Cathy Hawn
10 years ago
Proud of the many former Forrestdale students who have spoken out for literature in context, their teachers and the power of books in their own lives. One of my favorite once-banned books? Brave New World.
J
Julia
10 years ago
Don't restrain the students from enhancing their knowledge
A
Anonymous
10 years ago
Is this an early April fool joke or has this neighborhood bubble become even more disconnected from the reality of the world we live in ?
M
Maria Puryear
10 years ago
Banning books is never a good idea.
A
Anonymous
10 years ago
This is ridiculous that high school students cannot be exposed to challenging and thought-provoking classic literature. The previously "banned books" from my high school have influenced my life and education beyond what I could have even imagined at the time. What a shame that some parents will "shelter" their kids so much that it ends up closing their minds. Disappointing and stupid to say the least.
R
Rina Hanna Carrolli
10 years ago
I really enjoy discussing these books with my kids. Sometimes I even buy the book myself and read it with them. Their views are so interesting and they appreciate mine, as well. An open mind creates independent thinkers! Don't change a thing!!!!
M
Matthew Hartman
10 years ago
Words are only way that we as a society are able to read the thoughts of others. Censorship of any kind is a bad idea. There are no bad words.
M
Michelle Green
10 years ago
Featured
We don't have to agree with or like every book to learn something from reading. How will we know what we believe and value without hearing multiple points of view, considering alternate ones, and being open to new truths? Books expand minds and should not be banned.
B
Bobbi Mcgettigan
10 years ago
Books should never be banned
J
John Esposito
10 years ago
Shhh shhh. Puts hand over eyes* Books won't hurt you I promise. Now go to bed you crazy Rumson parent.
If we want our kids to change the world, they need to understand it. Censorship is the quickest way to cultivate a generation of ignorant adults. Instead, let's support the teachers at RFH, who are well-equipped to help students grow into engaged and thoughtful adults.
Not all parents feel this way- not even most. We live in a town where people want their high school students doing college level work & this is what that entails . I'd much rather my child read one if these books and discuss its greater themes with one of the excellent teachers on staff at RFH then watch most of the garbage that passes for entertainment on TV/movies/media these days.
A dangerous and close-minded, paranoid idea! Banning books in not in keeping with an open society.
As an RFH graduate I am appalled that the censorship of books is rearing its ugly head. have far too many comments to make here, but I know others will do so about freedom is speech. As a practical matter, who will be making decisions regarding the "banned list"? Will the BOE be forced to approve a resolution and appoint a committee to oversee its implementation? Of course, any such ban would include books allegedly promoting violence, bullying, racism and sexism, right? Right?
Class of 72
Adults with no or limited experience of the world around them are nothing but bigger children. Favorite Book: Exodus favorite Once-Banned Book: Red Badge of Courage
This is a horrifying action. Attempting to control what can be read is the first step toward attempting to control what is thought.
Proud of the many former Forrestdale students who have spoken out for literature in context, their teachers and the power of books in their own lives. One of my favorite once-banned books? Brave New World.
Don't restrain the students from enhancing their knowledge
Is this an early April fool joke or has this neighborhood bubble become even more disconnected from the reality of the world we live in ?
Banning books is never a good idea.
This is ridiculous that high school students cannot be exposed to challenging and thought-provoking classic literature. The previously "banned books" from my high school have influenced my life and education beyond what I could have even imagined at the time. What a shame that some parents will "shelter" their kids so much that it ends up closing their minds. Disappointing and stupid to say the least.
I really enjoy discussing these books with my kids. Sometimes I even buy the book myself and read it with them. Their views are so interesting and they appreciate mine, as well. An open mind creates independent thinkers! Don't change a thing!!!!
Words are only way that we as a society are able to read the thoughts of others. Censorship of any kind is a bad idea. There are no bad words.
We don't have to agree with or like every book to learn something from reading. How will we know what we believe and value without hearing multiple points of view, considering alternate ones, and being open to new truths? Books expand minds and should not be banned.
Books should never be banned
Shhh shhh. Puts hand over eyes* Books won't hurt you I promise. Now go to bed you crazy Rumson parent.
they will never learn if you limit their reach.
This is why we can't have nice things.
No book should ever be banned.