Skip to main content

Petition: Alternatives to Removal of the Giving Tree

39 Comments

L
Leah
12 years ago

I loved the tree I was sad when they said they were changing the tradition .

T
Treemonster22
12 years ago

Yeah, trees bitch!!!!

R
Ryan Paddock
12 years ago

I loved that tree, 100% support!

R
Rhoda
12 years ago

Supporting.

S
Sophia Silver
12 years ago

I support this 100% that is just studied that they got rid of it.

B
Brandon
12 years ago

We got 200!

J
Jonathan Lingle
12 years ago

i support this 100%

D
denise kuebel
12 years ago

This is a perfect example of political correctness run amuck Let's be reasonable about this. Those that complain have way too much time on their hands.

C
Charles Arena
12 years ago

The parents that are getting upset have no right doing so considering we honor every tradition that derives from the holiday season. If a tree that has been sitting in the Harley lobby year after year is making people insecure, someone should send them a invitation to candle light so they can see Harley goes out of its way to be as equal as possible during the holiday season. This is beyond saddening and we hope their is a come promise reached of some sort. Looks like elf day's days are becoming numbered.

H
Henry Smith
12 years ago Featured

There's no justification for removing the poor Giving Tree that would not also take away the other religious opportunities at Harley, like the very kind Buddhist monk who comes in the spring. Besides, the Giving Tree gets its name from a very nice children's book and its meaning is only charity; Christianity is merely a shade of influence on it. Besides, the Christmas Tree and the Giving Tree have very distinct nuances from each other.

D
Devon Cunningham
12 years ago

*of

D
Devon Cunningham
12 years ago Featured

The tree was not a symbol of Christianity to me. The tree was always a symbol of the amazing energy and happiness people get around the holiday. It was a symbol go the community coming together and giving back to the community. It was a reminder to the students how they should be humble, and have sympathy, and how there are people who have needs in this world far greater than ours. I loved seeing those tags disappear from the branches with each passing day, seeing the community interacting and trying to give instead of take. I'm sad to see that a good thing is going to waste because we are afraid of supporting ALL religions.

A
Anonymous
12 years ago

There are other ways to make it less Christian oriented!

K
Katerina Nunez
12 years ago

The holidays are about giving no matter what religion you are!

L
Lena Aliyeva
12 years ago

tree please

M
MR CHOW
12 years ago

GO

M
Mariah Palumbo
12 years ago

Myself, many other students, faculty, and parents feel very strongly about this issue. Please give it your consideration.

A
Aliza Light
12 years ago

People should be tolerant of religious traditions instead of taking them away. Keep the tree!