Skip to main content

The hospital management finally confirmed they are removing the bollards and restoring proper motorcycle parking access. Seeing one of us get hurt was the breaking point for all of us and I am relieved that safety is finally being put back at the forefront. I will stay in touch with …

June 26, 2006

Inadequate provisions for motorcyclists at Ninewells Hospital

Inadequate provisions for motorcyclists at Ninewells Hospital

🏆 Won — 144 supporters Verified

Final supporters

P
Professor P.
L
Lorraine W.
G
Gary A.
I
Ian F.
R
roderick c.
W
William W.
R
Ryan
W
WILD H.
G
Gordon R.
A
Allan M.
+134 more
Started by Anonymous 20 years, 4 months ago
At Ninewells Hospital we have seen an increase in the number of motorcycles using the parking facilities. However recently we have seen a decline in the provisions for motorcycles: A frequently used parking area has been closed off with no communicaton parking management resulting in finanacial penalties for motorcyclists. \"I got a ticket today for parking outside the toilet (where I parked last week, and got no ticket). I will appeal on the grounds that I have parked there often over the past 8 years, and that 2 attendants watched me walk away and didnt advise me that it was not allowed\". There is a small free area adjacent to the hospital front door which quickly becomes full and is frequqntly shut off to allow for maintenance in the adjacant areas. The consequence of the above is that motorcyclists are now being forced to use the multistorey carparks at a cost and the actions of parking management to enforce this have already resulted in an injury to one pedestrian. \"There was an incident yesterday at the barrier outside the multi storey car park where a pedestrian was knocked down by the barrier.This was a direct result of the VINCI guys putting up plastic bollards to prevent motorcycles exiting the car park without paying(or using their fob which I have).This has also blocked pedestrian access/exit.She ended up in A&E.Needless to say the bollards are still there today\". Also in this mutlistorey carpark we are being forced to park 2 to 4 bikes in a space desiganted for one car or, possibly a small car will be squeezed into the space beside one bike. This is unacceptable due to the possible damage which may occur to both cars and bikes. Motorcyles are ,the government tells us, more beneficial to the enviroment than cars. The Government believes that motorcycles should be encouraged where they replace car use, especially for commuting purposes. This is because of the lower environmental impact and the reduced congestion of travelling, particularly commuting, by motorcycle instead of by car. The Government also believes that smaller motorcycles can provide an affordable alternative to the car, and could be useful to some people without access to other forms of transport, particularly in areas where public transport is limited. This is one of the reasons that motorcycles have been afforded a lower excise duty than cars. It is our belief then, that motorcyles should be encouraged by Ninewells hospital as an alternative form of transport to the car and that the actions of the car parking management, Vinci Park, are detrimental to this. We believe they should provide adequate parking facilities and security and a reinstatement of the no parking charge for motorcylists.

Updates

May 19, 2006

I have been gathering photos of the dangerous new barriers and the absurd parking arrangements to present to hospital management. It is heartbreaking to hear that someone was already injured because of these poor choices and I am determined to ensure our parking area is safe for everyone.

May 19, 2006

Seeing the momentum grow reminds me of how dangerous these barriers have become for both of us on two wheels and the pedestrians navigating the same space. Your stories about the unfair fines and the recent injury show that we are not imagining the chaos. This is about our basic safety when we arrive for shifts or appointments.

Reached 100 supporters

May 19, 2006

17 Comments

L
Lorraine Wilson
7 years ago Featured

Because there is no place for me to park my motorcycle, I have had to leave it at my place of work (Technology Park) and walk to the hospital to visit a loved one who was taken to the hospital in an emergency. My motorcycle is my only mode of transport and there is no where safe to park at the hospital.

W
William Waldron
8 years ago Featured

There are quite a few spaces in the open air car parks where it is sensible, practical and poses no risk for bikers to park their machines. Parking management object, for reasons we can only guess at. Time for Ninewells to make adequate provisions for bikers.

W
WILD HOG
9 years ago Featured

Its hard enough to find parking at ninewells with a car. So taking a motorcycle would be more space saving. there used to be spaces and its not because we bikers dont want to pay

S
Shaun Fallon
9 years ago Featured

There needs to be more adequate parking for motorcycles. Charging is fine but where are we supposed to store the ticket. We also take up less room than cars.

M
Mark Johnston
10 years ago Featured

Adequate motorcycle parking that is clearly signposted needs to be provided. We do not want or need to take a full car space and should not be expected to pay a full car charge.

A
Anonymous
10 years ago Featured

We need parking facilities made available for motorcycles , ive seen 25 motorcycles on a warm day visiting and all trying to work out where to park and what to do regarding payment costs for a motorcycle . In this day and age surely someone in this huge staffed car parking company would have have had a bit common sense to think this through and provide bays and signage and costs .

P
Professor Paul Harris
7 years ago

It is outrageous to discriminate against motorcyclists in such pathetic and subversive way. It is time that all of Ninewells’ car and motorcycle parking was managed by an ethically driven company.

G
Gordon Rodger
9 years ago

More free spaces required for motorcycles.