I don't know who Simon Cowell thinks he is, not putting Caitlyn Koch in his top 4 girls on The X Factor and then choosing Melanie Amaro instead of Caitlyn for the extra spot. Caitlyn even said that if she didn't make it, she'd go straight back to coaching rugby and singing for nobody except in bars! Now some serious action needs to be taken here to get her a recording contract. I love her to death and don't want her to go back into total obscurity. In fact, if we're lucky, Simon will call her and tell her he wants her on his label. If this petition doesn't work, then he better sign her. In the meantime, everybody PLEASE sign this and spread it around to everybody you know and get them to spread it around further. Caitlyn is the rightful winner! She's got 10 billion times more X Factor than anybody who's in the Top 17.