In December 2008, ICView published an article by '08 alumna, Emily McNeil. In the essay, entitled "The Violence Must End", Emily provides a scholarly, first-hand account of the atrocities she witnessed last summer working in the occupied West Bank with the humanitarian organization, Christian Peacemaker Teams. The story is both emotionally moving and well written.
Without any substantive explanation, President Rochon hastily committed to implement a heightened "editorial review policy" and "editorial board" to effectively censor an Ithaca College publication. This unilateral action does not appear to be representative of the desires of the Ithaca College community. In fact, President Rochon has not yet responded to the overwhelming public defense of Emily's piece and the decision to publish it. We perceive this to be an inappropriate use of his power as president.
In addition to writing his own response, President Rochon evidently demanded that ICView editor of twelve years, Maura Stephens, publish an apology for running the personal essay. This is despite the fact that the decision to publish the article was consistent with both the stated mission of ICView and the founding principles of higher education.
As students at an institution of higher education, we find these actions to be immensely troubling. They are nothing less than attempts to undermine the very principle that is essential to free society and intellectual progress: the principle of academic freedom.
The Student Coalition for Academic Rights demands that President Rochon:
1. Make transparent all motivations for his apology for the publication of Emily McNeil's article, and for the proposed implementation of a censorship board under the auspices of an "editorial review policy" for ICView.
2. Commit in writing not to implement proposed "stronger internal editorial review policy" and "editorial board" for ICView or any other Ithaca College publication.
3. Acknowledge that controversial dialogue should not be stifled and that the stated mission of ICView should be adhered to in all cases. The mission includes commitment to "offer a candid, accurate, thoughtful, and lively view of College events and people and to stimulate discussion of issues of interest to the College community and the broader readership."
4. Acknowledge that the concept of academic freedom at Ithaca College must be respected in all instances.
5. A public statement responding to these demands should be published in both The Ithacan and ICView.
We, the undersigned, are committed to the fulfillment of the above stated demands:
The volume of support has secured us a meeting with the administration office later this week. I am currently drafting a formal brief outlining the specific breaches of academic freedom to present during that discussion.
Reached 100 supporters
February 19, 2009
6 Comments
T
Tom Doyle
17 years ago
Featured
So disappointing to see the president undermine the mission of the school. really sad.
J
Jessica Santana
17 years ago
Featured
This whole editorial board thing is just a way to shut people up. very unprofessional.
M
Mike Stone
17 years ago
Featured
Ridiculous to censor a piece like this. Let the students and staff write what they need to write!
E
Emily Cho
17 years ago
Featured
Free speech matters! Stop acting like a dictator and let the publication do its job.
J
Jason Ryan
17 years ago
Featured
Maura has been doing a great job for years. This is clearly an abuse of power.
S
Sarah Greer
17 years ago
Featured
academic freedom should be the bedrock of this college. silencing alumni is a bad look for rochon.
Help this petition grow
Share it with friends to help reach
250 signatures.
Sign Petition
We never post to your account. Social sign-in is used only to verify your signature.
or sign with Email
Add a comment?
Your signature will be added via
.
Tell others why you're signing — it's optional.
In December 2008, ICView published an article by '08 alumna, Emily McNeil. In the essay, entitled "The Violence Must End", Emily provides a scholarly, first-hand account of the atrocities she witnessed last summer working in the occupied West Bank with the humanitarian organization, Christian Peacemaker Teams. The story is both emotionally moving and well written.
Without any substantive explanation, President Rochon hastily committed to implement a heightened "editorial review policy" and "editorial board" to effectively censor an Ithaca College publication. This unilateral action does not appear to be representative of the desires of the Ithaca College community. In fact, President Rochon has not yet responded to the overwhelming public defense of Emily's piece and the decision to publish it. We perceive this to be an inappropriate use of his power as president.
In addition to writing his own response, President Rochon evidently demanded that ICView editor of twelve years, Maura Stephens, publish an apology for running the personal essay. This is despite the fact that the decision to publish the article was consistent with both the stated mission of ICView and the founding principles of higher education.
As students at an institution of higher education, we find these actions to be immensely troubling. They are nothing less than attempts to undermine the very principle that is essential to free society and intellectual progress: the principle of academic freedom.
The Student Coalition for Academic Rights demands that President Rochon:
1. Make transparent all motivations for his apology for the publication of Emily McNeil's article, and for the proposed implementation of a censorship board under the auspices of an "editorial review policy" for ICView.
2. Commit in writing not to implement proposed "stronger internal editorial review policy" and "editorial board" for ICView or any other Ithaca College publication.
3. Acknowledge that controversial dialogue should not be stifled and that the stated mission of ICView should be adhered to in all cases. The mission includes commitment to "offer a candid, accurate, thoughtful, and lively view of College events and people and to stimulate discussion of issues of interest to the College community and the broader readership."
4. Acknowledge that the concept of academic freedom at Ithaca College must be respected in all instances.
5. A public statement responding to these demands should be published in both The Ithacan and ICView.
We, the undersigned, are committed to the fulfillment of the above stated demands:
The volume of support has secured us a meeting with the administration office later this week. I am currently drafting a formal brief outlining the specific breaches of academic freedom to present during that discussion.
Reached 100 supporters
February 19, 2009
6 Comments
T
Tom Doyle
17 years ago
Featured
So disappointing to see the president undermine the mission of the school. really sad.
J
Jessica Santana
17 years ago
Featured
This whole editorial board thing is just a way to shut people up. very unprofessional.
M
Mike Stone
17 years ago
Featured
Ridiculous to censor a piece like this. Let the students and staff write what they need to write!
E
Emily Cho
17 years ago
Featured
Free speech matters! Stop acting like a dictator and let the publication do its job.
J
Jason Ryan
17 years ago
Featured
Maura has been doing a great job for years. This is clearly an abuse of power.
S
Sarah Greer
17 years ago
Featured
academic freedom should be the bedrock of this college. silencing alumni is a bad look for rochon.
Help this petition grow
Share it with friends to help reach
250 signatures.
Sign Petition
We never post to your account. Social sign-in is used only to verify your signature.
or sign with Email
Add a comment?
Your signature will be added via . Tell others why you're signing — it's optional.
Signing with Google or Facebook verifies your signature instantly — no email needed.
So disappointing to see the president undermine the mission of the school. really sad.