they cleared up the confusion and confirmed the real policy so we can finally call off the boycott. its wild what happens when we just ask for some straight answers. thanks to everyone who helped get to the bottom of this.
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
August 10, 2003
CONTACT:
Dagonet Dewr, Managing Editor, newWitch Magazine
317.916.9115
HOT TOPIC CLARIFIES POSITION ON RELIGION; NEWWITCH MAGAZINE LIFTS BOYCOTT
In a phone conversation on August 3, Hot Topic Chief Operating Officer Betsy McLaughlin spoke to Dagonet Dewr, Managing Editor of newWitch Magazine, in reference to an alleged policy of religious discrimination in Hot Topic\'s merchandise selection. At that time, it became apparent that Anne Newkirk Niven, newWitch\'s Editor-in-Chief, had been given wrong information by one of Hot Topic\'s merchandising buyers. After that conversation, Ms McLaughlin sent a formal statement to Dewr, the text of which is reproduced below.
\"Dagonet,
Thank you for allowing us the chance to clarify our item selection.
\"It is my understanding that you were given incomplete information from one of our buyers so I appreciate the opportunity to articulate our policy. About 7 years ago, we made a company decision not to carry any products that contain a religious symbol. These include crucifixes, rosaries, pictures of Jesus, stars of David, pentagrams, etc. We felt that unless we could do justice to all religions, it was not appropriate for us to selectively decide which symbols were important. We also changed our employee dress code. This decision was based on input we received from customers, employees and mall developers. The overwhelming feeling was that we market to teenagers and unless we could offer a full selection of products (as a bookstore is able to do), we could possibly give the appearance of favoring one religion over the next. The only exception is music, which we will not censor. So, you will find religious symbols and references on our music licensed products (rock tees, CD\'s, and music stickers).
\"I hope this helps you to understand our assortment choices. Most importantly, we are not excluding any one particular religion. We have many Wiccans working for Hot Topic (and Catholics, Jews, Buddhists, etc.) so I can assure you that as an organization, we are supportive of all religious preferences.
Sincerely,
Betsy McLaughlin
CEO & President
Hot Topic, Inc.\"
At this time, newWitch Magazine is satisfied with this response. It was never for us a question of whether or not Hot Topic chose to carry our particular merchandise; it was the appearance of a specific policy against Pagan and Wiccan materials that we objected to. With that policy clarified and corrected, we once again encourage the Pagan community to shop wherever their personal tastes say works for them. To the over 1400 people who signed our online petition -- not counting the many emails Hot Topic received -- we thank you for standing up for the Pagan right to choose not to support policies of disenfranchisement, even if in this case, we were thankfully misinformed.
We have changed the format of our online petition, located at http://www.ipetitions.com/campaigns/hottopicandreligion/, to reflect this information. We are encouraging people to sign the petition to thank Hot Topic and Ms McLaughlin for their speedy and helpful response.
we just hit 1,000 signatures on this. honestly didnt expect so many people to care about this clarification but i guess we were all wanting some real answers.
Reached 1,000 supporters
August 10, 2003
Reached 100 supporters
August 10, 2003
August 7, 2003
we are almost at 100 signatures and i want to see that number climb before we finish this. tell someone you know to hop on and sign this right now so we can wrap this up strong.
August 7, 2003
we are almost at a thousand signatures which will really show how much people care about this clarification. lets push to hit that number by tonight so we can show them how many of us are paying attention.
30 Comments
R
Raven Ferguson
23 years ago
Featured
bout time they sorted this mess out because i got tired of being hassled over my jewelry
T
Tyler Santana
23 years ago
Featured
who cares what they sell just give me my nirvana shirt and let me leave.
S
Sarah Gibson
23 years ago
Featured
it was so dumb that they were pulling stuff off shelves for no reason anyway. glad they actually talked to someone.
K
Kevin Holt
23 years ago
Featured
does this mean i can actually find a decent pentagram necklace again or are they still banning everything fun
J
Jessica Liu
23 years ago
Featured
Finally. The mall staff were acting super weird about my necklace last month when I was just trying to buy some new band tees.
they cleared up the confusion and confirmed the real policy so we can finally call off the boycott. its wild what happens when we just ask for some straight answers. thanks to everyone who helped get to the bottom of this.
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
August 10, 2003
CONTACT:
Dagonet Dewr, Managing Editor, newWitch Magazine
317.916.9115
HOT TOPIC CLARIFIES POSITION ON RELIGION; NEWWITCH MAGAZINE LIFTS BOYCOTT
In a phone conversation on August 3, Hot Topic Chief Operating Officer Betsy McLaughlin spoke to Dagonet Dewr, Managing Editor of newWitch Magazine, in reference to an alleged policy of religious discrimination in Hot Topic\'s merchandise selection. At that time, it became apparent that Anne Newkirk Niven, newWitch\'s Editor-in-Chief, had been given wrong information by one of Hot Topic\'s merchandising buyers. After that conversation, Ms McLaughlin sent a formal statement to Dewr, the text of which is reproduced below.
\"Dagonet,
Thank you for allowing us the chance to clarify our item selection.
\"It is my understanding that you were given incomplete information from one of our buyers so I appreciate the opportunity to articulate our policy. About 7 years ago, we made a company decision not to carry any products that contain a religious symbol. These include crucifixes, rosaries, pictures of Jesus, stars of David, pentagrams, etc. We felt that unless we could do justice to all religions, it was not appropriate for us to selectively decide which symbols were important. We also changed our employee dress code. This decision was based on input we received from customers, employees and mall developers. The overwhelming feeling was that we market to teenagers and unless we could offer a full selection of products (as a bookstore is able to do), we could possibly give the appearance of favoring one religion over the next. The only exception is music, which we will not censor. So, you will find religious symbols and references on our music licensed products (rock tees, CD\'s, and music stickers).
\"I hope this helps you to understand our assortment choices. Most importantly, we are not excluding any one particular religion. We have many Wiccans working for Hot Topic (and Catholics, Jews, Buddhists, etc.) so I can assure you that as an organization, we are supportive of all religious preferences.
Sincerely,
Betsy McLaughlin
CEO & President
Hot Topic, Inc.\"
At this time, newWitch Magazine is satisfied with this response. It was never for us a question of whether or not Hot Topic chose to carry our particular merchandise; it was the appearance of a specific policy against Pagan and Wiccan materials that we objected to. With that policy clarified and corrected, we once again encourage the Pagan community to shop wherever their personal tastes say works for them. To the over 1400 people who signed our online petition -- not counting the many emails Hot Topic received -- we thank you for standing up for the Pagan right to choose not to support policies of disenfranchisement, even if in this case, we were thankfully misinformed.
We have changed the format of our online petition, located at http://www.ipetitions.com/campaigns/hottopicandreligion/, to reflect this information. We are encouraging people to sign the petition to thank Hot Topic and Ms McLaughlin for their speedy and helpful response.
we just hit 1,000 signatures on this. honestly didnt expect so many people to care about this clarification but i guess we were all wanting some real answers.
Reached 1,000 supporters
August 10, 2003
Reached 100 supporters
August 10, 2003
August 7, 2003
we are almost at 100 signatures and i want to see that number climb before we finish this. tell someone you know to hop on and sign this right now so we can wrap this up strong.
August 7, 2003
we are almost at a thousand signatures which will really show how much people care about this clarification. lets push to hit that number by tonight so we can show them how many of us are paying attention.
30 Comments
R
Raven Ferguson
23 years ago
Featured
bout time they sorted this mess out because i got tired of being hassled over my jewelry
T
Tyler Santana
23 years ago
Featured
who cares what they sell just give me my nirvana shirt and let me leave.
S
Sarah Gibson
23 years ago
Featured
it was so dumb that they were pulling stuff off shelves for no reason anyway. glad they actually talked to someone.
K
Kevin Holt
23 years ago
Featured
does this mean i can actually find a decent pentagram necklace again or are they still banning everything fun
J
Jessica Liu
23 years ago
Featured
Finally. The mall staff were acting super weird about my necklace last month when I was just trying to buy some new band tees.
bout time they sorted this mess out because i got tired of being hassled over my jewelry