Status: Closed — this petition is no longer accepting signatures.
Final supporters
This morning, while I was sitting on my couch drinking hot tea and watching television, I saw a very insulting Esurance commercial come on. In "Sorta Construction Queen," there is a pageant queen (in her sash, crown, and a formal dress holding a bouquet of flowers) driving a bulldozer. One of the actual construction workers says to her "You're not Marge." The pageant queen then says she's "sorta Marge," and proceeds to talk, as if she was asked a question for a pageant. Her answer is very unintelligent. This is the gist of the commercial. The link to the full video is below.
http://www.ispot.tv/ad/7c8u/esurance-sorta-marge
This is very demeaning. I thought to myself: how rude to pageant queens, for I am one myself. It is also very insensitive, for Esurance continues to run the commercial, even after the issue with NBC pulling Miss USA.
However, upon further research, I found several other commercials by Esurance that portray woman as unintellectual. All you have to do is go on YouTube to Esurance's channel, and you can see all of their videos. Beatrice, for instance, shows up in these commercials several times; each time, she is cast as dull-witted. She even has her own mini series titled "Tech Savvy with Beatrice" (Beatrice is NOT tech savvy). This shows that Esurance is degrading women, and has a history of doing so! There are other women portrayed as feebleminded that appear in these videos as well. These are just a few examples.
Before I came to the conclusion that Esurance's commercials are targeted toward women, I watched some of the videos featuring men. In most of these videos, the men get a role that screams power and confidence. I will use the valet stunt driver commercial to illustrate. In this scene, it is a stunt car driver doing a valet parking job. He gets in the car, and when asked if he's not the valet parking guy, he talks about the "sorta" idea behind a handful of the Esurance commercials before racing off at full speed and ending with a trick on two wheels. All the while, he is portrayed confident and talented. Link is below.
http://www.ispot.tv/ad/7iSo/esurance-sorta-valet-d...
This is not the only video with a powerful male role. Once again, a trip to their YouTube channel
To sum up, Esurance has a history of demeaning women and playing up men. Commercials such as these are the reason stereotypes are hard to crush. They continue to assure people that it is okay to offend others because of what they do or enjoy. Esurance has at the top of their YouTube channel the title "Equal Dreams." How about we work on equal representation first? I am a women as well as a pageant girl. I recently won a pageant and get to represent my entire state for the next year as queen. I am also moving on to the international pageant. Aside from pageantry, I am also very intelligent. I am in the top 10 GPA of my class, a member of the National Honor Society, a productive robotics team member, and I will be taking multiple college courses in the fall as a junior in high school. One day, I want to be a lawyer. I would NOT classify myself as dumb. Commercials such as this are the reason that pageant queens as well as women have to live with certain labels; it's time to stand up to the stereotype. I will be writing an email explaining my concerns and sending it to Esurance. I will also be attaching this electronic petition so the company see that it is bigger than one person - these commercials are offensive to many. All you have to do is click sign petition, and it will display a place for your name and email as well as a box to type a comment in, if you wish to add anything. You may also choose to hide your name. This electronic petition also works on mobile.
Let us make it known that we will not tolerate stereotypes anymore!
Link to Esurance's channel:
More like this
Stop Gender Stereotypes!
Women Not Objects
3 Comments
Stereotyping is wrong. It is true, society does try to portray pageant girls as unintelligent. I for one, have actually participated in pageants, yes I may not hold a title, but this is still offensive. I will be signing your petition to rid of Esurance's Stereotypical Commercials. I encourage all to do so as well. This is why we have Queens, to stand up for what we believe in, even though it may not be the most popular view. To stand up for what is right. I fully stand behind the pageant systems, and the beautiful and brilliant young women who compete in them. As former Miss Michigan Teen USA 2014, Iris Robare has always said "you not only need to be confidently beautiful, but confidently brilliant."
I agree Ashley. Stereotyping by definition is a standardized mental picture that is held in common by members of a group and that represents an oversimplified opinion, prejudiced attitude, or uncritical judgment. I can find no humor in this type of generalization
Share Petition
Don't stop at signing, share the petition link with friends to multiply our impact
Copy link or share directly
Status: Closed — this petition is no longer accepting signatures.
Final supporters
This morning, while I was sitting on my couch drinking hot tea and watching television, I saw a very insulting Esurance commercial come on. In "Sorta Construction Queen," there is a pageant queen (in her sash, crown, and a formal dress holding a bouquet of flowers) driving a bulldozer. One of the actual construction workers says to her "You're not Marge." The pageant queen then says she's "sorta Marge," and proceeds to talk, as if she was asked a question for a pageant. Her answer is very unintelligent. This is the gist of the commercial. The link to the full video is below.
http://www.ispot.tv/ad/7c8u/esurance-sorta-marge
This is very demeaning. I thought to myself: how rude to pageant queens, for I am one myself. It is also very insensitive, for Esurance continues to run the commercial, even after the issue with NBC pulling Miss USA.
However, upon further research, I found several other commercials by Esurance that portray woman as unintellectual. All you have to do is go on YouTube to Esurance's channel, and you can see all of their videos. Beatrice, for instance, shows up in these commercials several times; each time, she is cast as dull-witted. She even has her own mini series titled "Tech Savvy with Beatrice" (Beatrice is NOT tech savvy). This shows that Esurance is degrading women, and has a history of doing so! There are other women portrayed as feebleminded that appear in these videos as well. These are just a few examples.
Before I came to the conclusion that Esurance's commercials are targeted toward women, I watched some of the videos featuring men. In most of these videos, the men get a role that screams power and confidence. I will use the valet stunt driver commercial to illustrate. In this scene, it is a stunt car driver doing a valet parking job. He gets in the car, and when asked if he's not the valet parking guy, he talks about the "sorta" idea behind a handful of the Esurance commercials before racing off at full speed and ending with a trick on two wheels. All the while, he is portrayed confident and talented. Link is below.
http://www.ispot.tv/ad/7iSo/esurance-sorta-valet-d...
This is not the only video with a powerful male role. Once again, a trip to their YouTube channel
To sum up, Esurance has a history of demeaning women and playing up men. Commercials such as these are the reason stereotypes are hard to crush. They continue to assure people that it is okay to offend others because of what they do or enjoy. Esurance has at the top of their YouTube channel the title "Equal Dreams." How about we work on equal representation first? I am a women as well as a pageant girl. I recently won a pageant and get to represent my entire state for the next year as queen. I am also moving on to the international pageant. Aside from pageantry, I am also very intelligent. I am in the top 10 GPA of my class, a member of the National Honor Society, a productive robotics team member, and I will be taking multiple college courses in the fall as a junior in high school. One day, I want to be a lawyer. I would NOT classify myself as dumb. Commercials such as this are the reason that pageant queens as well as women have to live with certain labels; it's time to stand up to the stereotype. I will be writing an email explaining my concerns and sending it to Esurance. I will also be attaching this electronic petition so the company see that it is bigger than one person - these commercials are offensive to many. All you have to do is click sign petition, and it will display a place for your name and email as well as a box to type a comment in, if you wish to add anything. You may also choose to hide your name. This electronic petition also works on mobile.
Let us make it known that we will not tolerate stereotypes anymore!
Link to Esurance's channel:
3 Comments
Right on girl! I saw this commercial and I was so hurt and angry. Of all the girls I've met in pageantry I would not consider a single one of them dumb. Shame on Esurance.
Stereotyping is wrong. It is true, society does try to portray pageant girls as unintelligent. I for one, have actually participated in pageants, yes I may not hold a title, but this is still offensive. I will be signing your petition to rid of Esurance's Stereotypical Commercials. I encourage all to do so as well. This is why we have Queens, to stand up for what we believe in, even though it may not be the most popular view. To stand up for what is right. I fully stand behind the pageant systems, and the beautiful and brilliant young women who compete in them. As former Miss Michigan Teen USA 2014, Iris Robare has always said "you not only need to be confidently beautiful, but confidently brilliant."
I agree Ashley. Stereotyping by definition is a standardized mental picture that is held in common by members of a group and that represents an oversimplified opinion, prejudiced attitude, or uncritical judgment. I can find no humor in this type of generalization
Share Petition
Don't stop at signing, share the petition link with friends to multiply our impact
Petitions like this
Other petitions you might want to support
Scan to share
Anyone who scans this can sign the petition.
Right on girl! I saw this commercial and I was so hurt and angry. Of all the girls I've met in pageantry I would not consider a single one of them dumb. Shame on Esurance.