Skip to main content

Status: Closed — this petition is no longer accepting signatures.

Stop the Democrat Filibusters of Judicial Nominees

Stop the Democrat Filibusters of Judicial Nominees

Closed — 30 supporters Verified

Final supporters

R
Randall S.
D
dmnv w.
E
ed P.
J
Justin M.
M
Mike M.
P
Paul C.
D
Debbie N.
R
ruth t.
K
Kerwin N.
M
Maria L.
+20 more
Started by Anonymous 23 years, 7 months ago
The Democrat members of the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee have staged unprecedented filibusters inorder to obstruct President Bush\'s Judicial Nominees. For example, Miguel Estrada earned a \"well qualified\" rating by the American Bar Association, its highest rating, he graduated magna cum laude from Columbia University and Harvard Law School, and he would be the first Hispanic to sit on this court. Democrat senators claim that Estrada refused to answer questions about his record and constitutional views, and that his attempts to evade scrutiny on these issues prevented the Senate from fulfilling its constitutional responsibility to \"advise and consent\" to this judicial nomination. But, only two of 10 Judiciary Committee Democrats exercised their right to submit written questions to Estrada. Almost no questions were asked, and none were answered. In fact, the true reasons for these specious Democrat filibusters are on the grounds of ideology. The Democrats choose to filibuster President Bush\'s judicial nominees because they are conservatives, not because they are unqualified or won\'t answers questions. Alexander Hamilton wrote in Federalist Paper 76 that the Senate\'s role is to refuse nominations only for \"special and strong reasons\" having to do with \"unfit characters.\" According to George Will (\"A judge well worth the fight\", 2/27/03), if the Senate rules, exploited by an anticonstitutional minority, are allowed to trump the Constitution\'s text and two centuries of practice, the Senate\'s power to consent to judicial nominations will have become a Senate right to require a 60-vote supermajority for confirmations. By thus nullifying the president\'s power to shape the judiciary, the Democrat Party will wield a presidential power without having won a presidential election. Please help stop the Democrat filibusters against President Bush\'s judicial nominees, who all deserve an up-and-down vote by the full Senate. Thank you. This signed petition will be sent to all the Democrats on the Senate Judiciary Committee: Sen. John Edwards (D-NC) Sen. Patrick Leahy (D-VT) Sen. Edward Kennedy (D-MA) Sen. Joseph Biden (D-DE) Sen. Herbert Kohl (D-WI) Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D-CA) Sen. Russ Feingold (D-WI) Sen. Charles Schumer (D-NY) Sen. Richard Durbin (D-IL) Please feel free to write your Senator and forward this ipetition to a friend. Thank you.

Updates

May 21, 2003

The current level of interest confirms the need for immediate procedural reform regarding judicial nominations. I am finalizing a packet of these concerns to be delivered directly to the Senate leadership office.

3 Comments

G
Gary Hart
23 years ago Featured

Just let the vote happen. Playing games with people who are clearly qualified is just wrong and a waste of everyone's time.

K
Kevin Ford
23 years ago Featured

obstruction at its finest. enough is enough. do your jobs.

L
Linda Mwangi
23 years ago Featured

RIDICULOUS. Why are they allowed to block someone so qualified? This is exactly why nobody trusts Washington anymore.