Skip to main content

Status: Closed — this petition is no longer accepting signatures.

James Watson's Lewis Thomas Prize

James Watson's Lewis Thomas Prize

Closed — 1 supporters Verified

Final supporters

J
Joe O.
Started by Anonymous 18 years, 10 months ago
We recently became aware of news articles in the Sunday Times (October 14, 2007) detailing recent comments made by Dr. James Watson. To quote the Sunday Times directly: He (Watson) says that he is "inherently gloomy about the prospect of Africa" because "all our social policies are based on the fact that their intelligence is the same as ours - whereas all the testing says not really", and I (C. Hunt-Grubbe) know that this "hot potato" is going to be difficult to address. His hope is that everyone is equal, but he counters that "people who have to deal with black employees find this not true". Dr. Watson has a long history of sexist and homophobic remarks and these most recent comments are simply too outrageous to be ignored. Encouraging the participation of minorities, including women and African Americans, in science should be a top priority at a research institution such as ours. Furthermore, giving Dr. Watson not only a platform from which to speak but also a prestigious prize is a form of validation of his sexist, racist and homophobic comments. We respectfully ask that in light of these recent comments, Dr. Watson not speak at the Rockefeller University on October 31st and further that he not receive the 2007 Lewis Thomas Prize. While our institution should encourage free speech and exchange of ideas, as has been done with past controversial speakers including the last years Lewis Thomas Prize recipient Richard Dawkins and author Michael Crichton, inviting Dr. Watson to speak is not within the realm of taste and would reflect poorly on our institution as we would be implicitly endorsing his recent and past remarks. Dr. Watson has the right to free speech, but we also have the right to voice our opposition to his presence on our campus.

Updates

October 18, 2007

The silence from the administration is becoming deafening as they continue to ignore the harm these words cause our community. I am spending my hours drafting formal letters to the board because this prestige should not belong to someone who promotes such deep bigotry. We are not backing down until the university realizes that their validation of these views is a betrayal of its own values.

October 18, 2007

Seeing this level of support reminds me that we refuse to let these hateful ideas go unchallenged at our institution. I am deeply moved by the conviction everyone is showing to make sure our lab culture reflects real inclusivity rather than just empty words.

6 Comments

S
Sarah Webb
18 years ago Featured

Disgraceful. Science should be about discovery and progress not outdated bigotry. Keep this man away from the podium.

D
David Rivera
18 years ago Featured

Totally unacceptable. We need to be welcoming to all groups if we want real science to move forward.

J
Jessica Bryant
18 years ago Featured

he is a dinosaur and his comments are just plain wrong. why would you want to celebrate someone like him???

E
Elena Coleman
18 years ago Featured

racism and sexism arent just opinions they are just wrong. revoke the prize now!!

M
Mike Shepherd
18 years ago Featured

wow this is 2007 not 1950. get with the times already. no place for this nonsense in a university setting.

K
Kevin Obi
18 years ago Featured

Unbelievable that anyone would invite him after saying that garbage. Rockefeller needs to do way better.