THIS PETITION IS CLOSED. Please go to the new petition.
310 Comments
L
Lynn Birli
12 years ago
Keep him in jail forever and that doesn't seem long enough!!!
N
Nick Hodges
12 years ago
I was down I fla. when his brother had a warrant out for molesting a young girl, next door to him, at the time he was like the New Port Richie police chief or something, he was married to a good friend of mine, she asked me to come down and watch over her, she knew what HE was capable of, the whole clan is nuts. Like in 93 or so.
A
Anonymous
12 years ago
Keep this monster behind bars. People like him cannot be rehabilitated. He will only repeat this terrible crime.
A
Anonymous
12 years ago
Brother wasn't any better, Seems if your a cop they think they can do anything
D
Deborah Clevenstine
12 years ago
Never let him out. He has done so much damage.
A
Anonymous
12 years ago
Done!
B
Barbara kennedy
12 years ago
Those of us who lived in smithtown will never forget how he needlessly took the life of a beautiful young woman while stealing the innocence of our safe little town. He's a perverted monster
J
Joyce Diehl
12 years ago
Carl hung with friends of ours in the early 70's and was SOOO good at hiding what was going on inside. Until he was convicted we had no idea that he had committed this heinous crime. He was one of those guys that could be approved of by your parents one minute and buy you some weed or pills the next. He is not sincere about anything but his own agenda.
S
Steven L Rost
12 years ago
The brutality of Carl is chilling. A rapist is one "thing" and a murderer, another. Reform has not affected Carl as his smug and indifferent attitude along with his statements of wanting women "when," not "if" parole is granted is unspeakable. Carl has not changed, not will he likely ever, Prison is his life and nothing more.
D
Dwanda Sircy Green
12 years ago
Keep him locked up for life.
J
Jennifer Mordini
12 years ago
Christine missed out on her life because of one person. That one person is Carl Macedonia. He deserves nothing...let alone parole. The public should be safe from predators. You must keep him imprisoned or give him the death penalty, which I believe is off the table.
R
Ray Bottenfield
12 years ago
The Parole Board should never release this sexually violent predator in the general public to offend again.
C
Cathy Peyton Shatka
12 years ago
May God comfort the Ferrara family and friends.
A
Anonymous
12 years ago
Done
C
Connie Pouncey
12 years ago
Donet
K
Kevin Kelly
12 years ago
Murder takes an innocent life away forever - FACT.
Life in prison should mean exactly that - the prisoner comes out in a coffin!!
L
Lisa Akita
12 years ago
It's so wrong that he could even have a second chance at life, let alone every 2 years! I guess that is why they call it "Criminal Justice" ~ if it was "Victim Justice" this petition would not be necessary! How disgusting and twisted our courts have become! My heart goes out to Christine's family. Keep fighting for our daughters!
E
Elle Dewyngaert
12 years ago
I
P
Peter Turner
12 years ago
As a recent past resident of Smithtown and a retired law enforcement officer. I oppose Parole for Carl A. Macedonio. Keep him where he is.
B
Barbara Caristo
12 years ago
Featured
I strongly oppose the release of Carl Macedonia back Into society. He showed no feelings for the young women he raped and murdered. He belongs behind bars permanently for such vicious crimes. I am a resident of Smithown who in my college days, lived through his "Smithtown reign of terror."
Keep him in jail forever and that doesn't seem long enough!!!
I was down I fla. when his brother had a warrant out for molesting a young girl, next door to him, at the time he was like the New Port Richie police chief or something, he was married to a good friend of mine, she asked me to come down and watch over her, she knew what HE was capable of, the whole clan is nuts. Like in 93 or so.
Keep this monster behind bars. People like him cannot be rehabilitated. He will only repeat this terrible crime.
Brother wasn't any better, Seems if your a cop they think they can do anything
Never let him out. He has done so much damage.
Done!
Those of us who lived in smithtown will never forget how he needlessly took the life of a beautiful young woman while stealing the innocence of our safe little town. He's a perverted monster
Carl hung with friends of ours in the early 70's and was SOOO good at hiding what was going on inside. Until he was convicted we had no idea that he had committed this heinous crime. He was one of those guys that could be approved of by your parents one minute and buy you some weed or pills the next. He is not sincere about anything but his own agenda.
The brutality of Carl is chilling. A rapist is one "thing" and a murderer, another. Reform has not affected Carl as his smug and indifferent attitude along with his statements of wanting women "when," not "if" parole is granted is unspeakable. Carl has not changed, not will he likely ever, Prison is his life and nothing more.
Keep him locked up for life.
Christine missed out on her life because of one person. That one person is Carl Macedonia. He deserves nothing...let alone parole. The public should be safe from predators. You must keep him imprisoned or give him the death penalty, which I believe is off the table.
The Parole Board should never release this sexually violent predator in the general public to offend again.
May God comfort the Ferrara family and friends.
Done
Donet
Murder takes an innocent life away forever - FACT. Life in prison should mean exactly that - the prisoner comes out in a coffin!!
It's so wrong that he could even have a second chance at life, let alone every 2 years! I guess that is why they call it "Criminal Justice" ~ if it was "Victim Justice" this petition would not be necessary! How disgusting and twisted our courts have become! My heart goes out to Christine's family. Keep fighting for our daughters!
I
As a recent past resident of Smithtown and a retired law enforcement officer. I oppose Parole for Carl A. Macedonio. Keep him where he is.
I strongly oppose the release of Carl Macedonia back Into society. He showed no feelings for the young women he raped and murdered. He belongs behind bars permanently for such vicious crimes. I am a resident of Smithown who in my college days, lived through his "Smithtown reign of terror."