Brown University and PLoS ONE: Defend academic freedom and scientific inquiry
1,601 Comments
J
Jeremy Jensen
8 years ago
ROGD must be studied. Don't cave into pressure from self-serving activists!
L
Lily Maynard
8 years ago
My daughter was completely convinced she was a boy, suddenly, for a year when she was 15/16. She desisted 2 years ago and is a happy, confident, lesbian young woman who looks back on that time with embarrassment. ROGD is ‘a thing’ and researchers should not be silenced and bullied like this.
A
Anonymous
8 years ago
Open debate is what marks a democracy from dictatorship
A
Anonymous
8 years ago
Children and parents have the right to careful, prudent, scientific care.
A
Anonymous
8 years ago
Let the evidence speak for itself.
A
Anonymous
8 years ago
Academic freedom must be preserved
K
Kimberly Chambers
8 years ago
This is important work which has the potential to help many children and young adults. Lisa Littman has my full support. Suppressing research due to political pushback is the antithesis of what a university should represent.
M
Mary Lou Singleton MSN FNP
8 years ago
As a primary health care provider, I am shocked at the fast-track acceptance of experimental treatments on children with gender dysphoria. Children are receiving GNRH agonists, cross sex hormones, mastectomies, and hysterectomies. All of these treatments have life-long severe sequelae. With such serious issues at stake, we need as much scientific research as possible to ensure we are not inadvertently harming children. The silencing of research on the possible social contagion of transgenderism is troubling. Please do not capitulate to idealogues who want to shut down scientific discourse on this issue.
W
William Fluetsch
8 years ago
I am in full support of LGBTQ+ people and there right to equality without discrimination. I am in full support of this study and believe more studies should be done to fully understand what is happening. This is not a contradiction, it is too separate beliefs that I and others hold with respects to this issue. We must not let science and research be effected by politics, no matter where or who it comes from.
J
Jason
8 years ago
Publish the paper.
E
Evelina Vitter
8 years ago
This contagion has to be researched. The medical transitioning is a murder under the umbrella of “ anti discrimination “.
This outrageous outbreak of teenagers and young adults turning themselves into dependent on medical assistance to the rest of their lives is a social contagion! And the society that allows this commits crime against humanity!
G
Gloria Knotts
8 years ago
Do not stifle academic freedom!
S
Sheila Jeffreys
8 years ago
It is very important that research critical of the transphenomenon should be funded, conducted and reported upon. This is a crucial issue of academic freedom and concerns a huge harm to the health and possibilities of young people.
M
Michael Biggs
8 years ago
Associate Professor of Sociology, University of Oxford
T
Tatyana Belyayeva
8 years ago
This is a very important and timely study of a very serious contagion, mainly affecting females. As a concerned mother of a young female I give all my support to Dr. Lisa Littman f Brown University and her study on the topic of rapid onset gender dysphoria (ROGD).
A
Anonymous
8 years ago
Silencing studies that do not support your dogma is a symptom of fascism, IMO
A
Adria Prosser
8 years ago
Silencing researchers for political reasons is the exact opposite of what a university should be doing.
A
Anonymous
8 years ago
There should be no silencing in academic research!!! That is so dangerous!
S
Stephanie Davies-Arai
8 years ago
This study is essential as the first of its kind. Academic research should not be suppressed because of lobbying by political activists on Twitter. This is an unprecedented assault on academic freedom and it is scary that a university and a science journal will cave to social media vigilantism.
K
Kathryn Scarbrough
8 years ago
This is a scientific study, lets promote discussion and debate.
ROGD must be studied. Don't cave into pressure from self-serving activists!
My daughter was completely convinced she was a boy, suddenly, for a year when she was 15/16. She desisted 2 years ago and is a happy, confident, lesbian young woman who looks back on that time with embarrassment. ROGD is ‘a thing’ and researchers should not be silenced and bullied like this.
Open debate is what marks a democracy from dictatorship
Children and parents have the right to careful, prudent, scientific care.
Let the evidence speak for itself.
Academic freedom must be preserved
This is important work which has the potential to help many children and young adults. Lisa Littman has my full support. Suppressing research due to political pushback is the antithesis of what a university should represent.
As a primary health care provider, I am shocked at the fast-track acceptance of experimental treatments on children with gender dysphoria. Children are receiving GNRH agonists, cross sex hormones, mastectomies, and hysterectomies. All of these treatments have life-long severe sequelae. With such serious issues at stake, we need as much scientific research as possible to ensure we are not inadvertently harming children. The silencing of research on the possible social contagion of transgenderism is troubling. Please do not capitulate to idealogues who want to shut down scientific discourse on this issue.
I am in full support of LGBTQ+ people and there right to equality without discrimination. I am in full support of this study and believe more studies should be done to fully understand what is happening. This is not a contradiction, it is too separate beliefs that I and others hold with respects to this issue. We must not let science and research be effected by politics, no matter where or who it comes from.
Publish the paper.
This contagion has to be researched. The medical transitioning is a murder under the umbrella of “ anti discrimination “. This outrageous outbreak of teenagers and young adults turning themselves into dependent on medical assistance to the rest of their lives is a social contagion! And the society that allows this commits crime against humanity!
Do not stifle academic freedom!
It is very important that research critical of the transphenomenon should be funded, conducted and reported upon. This is a crucial issue of academic freedom and concerns a huge harm to the health and possibilities of young people.
Associate Professor of Sociology, University of Oxford
This is a very important and timely study of a very serious contagion, mainly affecting females. As a concerned mother of a young female I give all my support to Dr. Lisa Littman f Brown University and her study on the topic of rapid onset gender dysphoria (ROGD).
Silencing studies that do not support your dogma is a symptom of fascism, IMO
Silencing researchers for political reasons is the exact opposite of what a university should be doing.
There should be no silencing in academic research!!! That is so dangerous!
This study is essential as the first of its kind. Academic research should not be suppressed because of lobbying by political activists on Twitter. This is an unprecedented assault on academic freedom and it is scary that a university and a science journal will cave to social media vigilantism.
This is a scientific study, lets promote discussion and debate.