Skip to main content

Bring back Sugar Cookie Eggnog

1,462 Comments

C
Cadence

I've been trying to remember the name of this particular eggnog for years. I haven't seen it since I was a kid. So glad I'm not the only one who thinks about it constantly.

J
Jonathan

Bring Back Sugar Cookie Eggnog Please!!

A
Anonymous

Please bring it back. It’s the beat

T
Trudy Babb

❤

S
stacey williams

it's the best flavor! it was sold out every time we went to purchase it at our local grocery store. Why would you stop selling it???

A
Anonymous

Please bring this back to Shelton, CT. I know hundreds of people who loved this and raved about it at Christmas parties! we look for it every year!

A
Anonymous

This was the only eggnog I ever loved. Please bring it back! Best ever!

A
Anonymous

Please bring the Sugar Cookie Eggnog back to Atlanta, Ga.

J
Jane

Please bring it back

L
Liz Judy

Bring back sugar cookie eggnog please!

P
Paul J Watts

This was my favorite part of the holiday food. It was like liquid candy. Please consider bringing this delicious treat back. Thank you!

R
Rebecca E Lant

the best egg nog

L
Lisa Simpson

Please bring this flavor back. It was soo good!

J
Jante Langan

Christmas isn’t Christmas without Sugar Cookie Eggnog!

N
Nick

Bring it back!!!!!!!!

L
Luis Pinto

Please bring it back in Brooklyn, NY!

L
Lauren Brady

THIS WAS THE BEST FLAVOR AND I DONT EVEN DRINK EGGNOG!!!

L
Laura Quentin

Please bring back this egg nogg! It was seaming!

P
Princess Johnson

Please bring back sugar cookie eggnog

A
Alyssa Dehart

Please bring it back!!!!! It’s the only eggnog I like!