All you need to do is check his previous lectures and see how ignorant and malicious his comments are.
I don't think a person who thinks Abu Bakr was good deserves any kind of respect from us
R
Rangilla Bandar
8 years ago
This scholar Arif is saying that large parts of Ziarat e Ashura that deal with the " victors" at Sakeefa are fabricated by Ulemas and were not authorised by Imam Sadiq(as). He says that not withstanding the killing of unborn baby of Lady Fatemah and expropriation of Fadak, the First Caliph was a very decent man and performed numerous good deeds. Therefore we should not be harsh on him and stop reciting the sections of Ziarat e Ashura that deal with cursing of 'actors' at Sakeefa and the killers of Imam Hussein(as) and his family as it serves no useful purpose and puts the life of Shias in danger.
If there are any serious Ulema reading these comments or if they have access to Marja, can they please advise if its OK to stop reciting sections dealing with cursing. Most of the Ziarat e Ashura deals with cursing of killers of Imam Hussein(as) and there is very little left if this is removed. Also, do I have to seek forgiveness for having cursed them and their conduct all my like. if so, do I also have to pay Kaffara or reparations for having cursed them in good faith. Please, serious feedback only. I believe it is Wajib or obligatory on Ulemas to give authoritative guidance to believers in such matter.
A
Ali rind
8 years ago
He is going against the shia by calling the enemies of Ahelybait as a nice and pious and seem to be wahabi rather than Shia .
S
Syed Zafar Abbas Jafri
8 years ago
Ban this man please.
R
Rizwana Tarer
8 years ago
Lanat beshumar.
S
syed kazmi
8 years ago
Don’t like nosheri and moqasar
F
Farrukh raza rizvi
8 years ago
This person should be banned
S
Syed Faisal Ali
8 years ago
Labbaik ya Hussain (a.s)
S
Syed jaffri
8 years ago
Ban him
W
Wasi
8 years ago
He is dividing the shias
B
Bashir Panju Kenya
8 years ago
Never mix your words with your moods because you will have many options to change your mood but you will never get any option to replace your spoken words.
A
Adeel
8 years ago
This guys a harami lamati
A
Akmal shah
8 years ago
Imam extrey concerned about how this man distorts the truth. Fuether he provides no evidence for his findings. Yes he is entitled to his opinion but he shoild.not be allowed to xo this pretending to be of the Twelve shia faith.
A
Ali
8 years ago
Is molvi pe lanat beshmaar
S
Saida Mohammed
8 years ago
Show u love for Imam Hussain walk&
May allah give rewards in this world and next world.
Come sign to reach target of 1000
R
Rangilla Bandar
8 years ago
40 Million Shias are defying Mr Arif Bata a self styled European Mujtahed and assembling in Karbala Iraq to pay homage to Imam Hussein on the occassion of Arbaeen. Bata has referred to the Arbaeen commemoration as an innovation and great walk to Karbala as a Carnival.
Amongst those marching are Haider (40 years old) and Aqeel (35 yesr old). They are both friends walking between Najaf and Karbala on the Arbaeen Walk. But whats remarkable about thrur journey is that they both blind. They are walking we thout a guide and say that the love of the Ahlulbayt is what is guiding them on their journey. They use a secondary road towards Karbala as they say they do not want to disturb other visitors with their slow pace. They are determined to walk every year to come to Karbala for Arbaeen despite being blind. #InspirationalArbaeenStory
B
Bashir Panju Kenya
8 years ago
Destroying any faith, belief or culture, does not require any outside element. It only requires one individual who can show a recipe to attract weak individuals. Surprisingly, we have an army of weak soldiers, who love his false recipe, and are ready to take on the marja for one individual’s sake. But time is not far, when TRUTH will prevail.
SORRY BROTHERS AND SISTERS, we miss the likes of the Late Mulla Asgher M. M. Jaffer (may Allah SWT be pleased with him) who passed away about two decades ago, when this man was not anywhere near a scholar.
Ma’assalaam
A
Anonymous
8 years ago
Spoiling the youths of today
M
M haji
8 years ago
Sarah Javad
If the word carnival was "too slight a word", why did arif seek forgiveness?
I'm not sure how you know that Ahlulbayt would be ashamed of petitioners' acts for they are bashing arif due to arif's deviant views.
I am not sure how you claim to act as lover of Ahlulbayt when you openly side with the supporter of killers of Ahlulbait.
Z
Zainab
8 years ago
Ok clarify then the name of the son is Sayed Ridha al Sistani
All you need to do is check his previous lectures and see how ignorant and malicious his comments are. I don't think a person who thinks Abu Bakr was good deserves any kind of respect from us
This scholar Arif is saying that large parts of Ziarat e Ashura that deal with the " victors" at Sakeefa are fabricated by Ulemas and were not authorised by Imam Sadiq(as). He says that not withstanding the killing of unborn baby of Lady Fatemah and expropriation of Fadak, the First Caliph was a very decent man and performed numerous good deeds. Therefore we should not be harsh on him and stop reciting the sections of Ziarat e Ashura that deal with cursing of 'actors' at Sakeefa and the killers of Imam Hussein(as) and his family as it serves no useful purpose and puts the life of Shias in danger. If there are any serious Ulema reading these comments or if they have access to Marja, can they please advise if its OK to stop reciting sections dealing with cursing. Most of the Ziarat e Ashura deals with cursing of killers of Imam Hussein(as) and there is very little left if this is removed. Also, do I have to seek forgiveness for having cursed them and their conduct all my like. if so, do I also have to pay Kaffara or reparations for having cursed them in good faith. Please, serious feedback only. I believe it is Wajib or obligatory on Ulemas to give authoritative guidance to believers in such matter.
He is going against the shia by calling the enemies of Ahelybait as a nice and pious and seem to be wahabi rather than Shia .
Ban this man please.
Lanat beshumar.
Don’t like nosheri and moqasar
This person should be banned
Labbaik ya Hussain (a.s)
Ban him
He is dividing the shias
Never mix your words with your moods because you will have many options to change your mood but you will never get any option to replace your spoken words.
This guys a harami lamati
Imam extrey concerned about how this man distorts the truth. Fuether he provides no evidence for his findings. Yes he is entitled to his opinion but he shoild.not be allowed to xo this pretending to be of the Twelve shia faith.
Is molvi pe lanat beshmaar
Show u love for Imam Hussain walk& May allah give rewards in this world and next world. Come sign to reach target of 1000
40 Million Shias are defying Mr Arif Bata a self styled European Mujtahed and assembling in Karbala Iraq to pay homage to Imam Hussein on the occassion of Arbaeen. Bata has referred to the Arbaeen commemoration as an innovation and great walk to Karbala as a Carnival. Amongst those marching are Haider (40 years old) and Aqeel (35 yesr old). They are both friends walking between Najaf and Karbala on the Arbaeen Walk. But whats remarkable about thrur journey is that they both blind. They are walking we thout a guide and say that the love of the Ahlulbayt is what is guiding them on their journey. They use a secondary road towards Karbala as they say they do not want to disturb other visitors with their slow pace. They are determined to walk every year to come to Karbala for Arbaeen despite being blind. #InspirationalArbaeenStory
Destroying any faith, belief or culture, does not require any outside element. It only requires one individual who can show a recipe to attract weak individuals. Surprisingly, we have an army of weak soldiers, who love his false recipe, and are ready to take on the marja for one individual’s sake. But time is not far, when TRUTH will prevail. SORRY BROTHERS AND SISTERS, we miss the likes of the Late Mulla Asgher M. M. Jaffer (may Allah SWT be pleased with him) who passed away about two decades ago, when this man was not anywhere near a scholar. Ma’assalaam
Spoiling the youths of today
Sarah Javad If the word carnival was "too slight a word", why did arif seek forgiveness? I'm not sure how you know that Ahlulbayt would be ashamed of petitioners' acts for they are bashing arif due to arif's deviant views. I am not sure how you claim to act as lover of Ahlulbayt when you openly side with the supporter of killers of Ahlulbait.
Ok clarify then the name of the son is Sayed Ridha al Sistani