Skip to main content

Speak out to the Napa DA in support of just punishment for felons who steal grapes

672 Comments

J
Jason Yeager

This is something that cannot be tolerated and must have retribution. This man has not only taken from the Del Dotto family but has spread a path of destruction with his former employees. They are hard working people who were just trying to support their families. Shame on Mr. Hill.

D
DAVID J BIVOLCIC

Please don't set the wrong precedent for the wine industry by reducing the type of crime this was !

F
F. Richard Jordan, M.D.

How can a theft of over $100000 ever be construed as a misdemeanor?

J
Jennifer Chuang

Citizens should be able to trust in the justice system to provide justice when all proof is provided.

T
Tom Hill

He must do the time for the crime! Many other companies were also hurt financially by his actions including mine.

P
PAULETTE &RICHARD GRACE

Best of luck to you! Your business deserves the protection.

A
Anonymous

A felony conviction would prevent the defendant from obtaining an alcohol license.

T
Tom Fleszar

There is no excuse for not prosecuting and sentencing to the full extent of the law. Real costs are one thing, but opportunity costs must be added to fully grasp the impact of these felonious acts.

C
Charla Morgan

I oppose any reduction in sentencing from felony for stealing wine grapes.

H
Hendrik Kroon

Not sticking to your own terroir is a criminal offense. No question. Especially when considering viniculture. Terroir matters and Mr (down)Hill defrauded and misled customers as well as partners. Let the law prevail.

P
Paul Holzapfel

Dear Judge Boessenecker, Stealing $800,000 of anything is hardly a misdemeanor, and if the plea is accepted as such would set a terrible precedent. Thank you for your consideration.

J
Jennifer McCann

People who steal and attempt to benefit from other people's hard work and property need to be held accountable for their actions and to the rule of law! That's why we have a constitution!

A
Anonymous

Absolutely appalling behavior. This is a crime against all vintners and he should most certainly pay the consequences by serving time.

T
Tim Noble

Please don't reduce this crime to a misdemeanor. This wouldn't deter other criminals by setting this precedent.

P
pierre corin

I regret that this unacceptable behavior is not punished severely as this case might jurisprudence for the future.

H
Heather Driscoll

Anyone guilty of this level of theft should be held accountable. Felony is the right consequence.

C
Christopher Kling

This state of ours is hell bent on rewarding criminals! Enough is enough already!!

A
ami cheri hower

stealing grapes should be a felony

R
Ron Herzog

I agree with the petition!!

P
Per Rosdahl

It's simple, crime should never pay off!