Relocate NBN Infrastructure From Coles Creek Road Cooran
17 Comments
S
Suzanne Germain
12 years ago
It is very clear from your uninformed comments Mr. Goltzman that you are not familiar with the said area. I am puzzled as to why someone who obviously has no idea of where the proposed tower is going and where the possible alternative sites (as nominated by Noosa Council) are situated, feels the need to communicate in such a hostile manner and personally attack Melissa Town in a somewhat irrational manner.
W
william collins
12 years ago
Featured
this tower can be located to the east of cooran beside the existing towers owned by telstra
D
Daniel Goltsman
12 years ago
Oh also, Ms. Town (Ive been saying Mrs. this whole time, my apologies) knows that the tower will greatly benefit "some" residents (Not everyone, since radio signals discriminate apparently). I don't see how that lines up with the active effort to make it benefit LESS residents by moving it to a sub-optimal location further away from the community.
Also the claim that her proposed relocation is just as good as the current one. Does Ms. Town know exactly how the towers work and how they interface with each other? The towers are a network and require line of sight to each other due to Microwave backhaul. It is not a matter of being 'high enough'. This is not a satellite connection where you need a clear view of the sky. The higher and further away a tower is from an antenna the worse the connection will be.
Besides, I admit I'm not familiar with the area but if the tower is high up on forestry land... doesn't that mean it is more visible to more properties and is now 'destroying the semi-rural lifestyle' of more people? It has too, because if there is enough trees in the way then the tower signal will attenuate massively and become useless. This, plus will necessitate the bulldozing of trees and destruction of wildlife habitats both around the tower itself and the newly laid road towards it? Does Ms. Town not care about that?
D
Daniel Goltsman
12 years ago
I was going to post in the Noosa News website (http://www.noosanews.com.au/news/towering-battle-begins/2178986/#comments), but then i realized that through this petition I can talk to the people of Cooran directly, hopefully without being moderated too much and with a greater word allowance!
First, here is the research paper Mrs Town is likely referring too:
http://www.iarc.fr/en/media-centre/pr/2011/pdfs/pr208_E.pdf
"The evidence was reviewed critically, and overall evaluated as being limited among users of wireless telephones for glioma and acoustic neuroma, and inadequate to draw conclusions for other types of cancers."
As you can see here, the very organization and paper Melissa cites doesn't support her. Now that that is out of the way, lets look at her other 'concerns' stemming from mostly emotional and some financial issues:
"destroy their semi-rural lifestyle"
Wow. Talk about hyperbole. The tower is going to run around tearing up forests and killing livestock? Do these residents also complain about poor mobile coverage? She said she supports the NBN, so clearly internet access isn't destroying anything. If the service the tower provides 'destroys their lifestyle' then they're free to not connect to it.
"lower property values"
Unless the locals are immortal, someone else is going to live on their land eventually. What will the new, heavily tech-savvy GenX, Y and Milennial retirees think when the retirement home they're considering is blanketed by a sub-par internet connection that doesn't serve their needs?
interfere with locals' "peace of mind"
How exactly are you quantifying this Melissa? Is there a 'piece of mind' calculator that i'm unaware of? This is nothing but emotional reactionism. As stated before the ECM Radiation from the tower is not proven to be harmful and it actually took me a moment to find it on the mockup photograph shown on the NoosaNews page. Like mobile towers and other such constructions, eventually the tower will
E
Erin Gardner
12 years ago
Relocate elsewhere
N
Nina Williams
12 years ago
Wake up you public servant town planners????? Ruining the world and society for what reason????
J
Julie Young
12 years ago
Stop destroying the state forests, this is why our weather is so unbalanced.
H
Helen Foster
12 years ago
I agree that the tower should be located on government land
S
Sonya Dent
12 years ago
Featured
I wonder if Aurecon CEO, Paul Hardy would agree to the tower being built on his land...?
C
chris collins
12 years ago
disgusted with the lack of regard for residents
J
John Collins
12 years ago
Move the tower on to the governments land
S
Steven and Sarah Earl
12 years ago
BUILD THE TOWER SOMEWHERE ELSE!!!
J
Joy
12 years ago
Good Luck
C
Carly olzard
12 years ago
Hope you get it stopped Loo!
K
Karen Kennedy
12 years ago
Featured
Im so proud of you! Its so good to see that you are standing up for your rights! Im sure you would not have bought the your beautiful property if you knew there would have been a tower erected to spoil the uninterrupted views from your home.
S
Sandra Perrett
12 years ago
Pls relocate NBN Infrastructure from Coles Creek Road.
A
Aimee Town
12 years ago
Mel you're doing a fantastic and tireless job with this lobby. I want your beautiful property to stay flawless and not encroached on by big business. I'm very proud to be your first online signature! Keep up the good work!
It is very clear from your uninformed comments Mr. Goltzman that you are not familiar with the said area. I am puzzled as to why someone who obviously has no idea of where the proposed tower is going and where the possible alternative sites (as nominated by Noosa Council) are situated, feels the need to communicate in such a hostile manner and personally attack Melissa Town in a somewhat irrational manner.
this tower can be located to the east of cooran beside the existing towers owned by telstra
Oh also, Ms. Town (Ive been saying Mrs. this whole time, my apologies) knows that the tower will greatly benefit "some" residents (Not everyone, since radio signals discriminate apparently). I don't see how that lines up with the active effort to make it benefit LESS residents by moving it to a sub-optimal location further away from the community. Also the claim that her proposed relocation is just as good as the current one. Does Ms. Town know exactly how the towers work and how they interface with each other? The towers are a network and require line of sight to each other due to Microwave backhaul. It is not a matter of being 'high enough'. This is not a satellite connection where you need a clear view of the sky. The higher and further away a tower is from an antenna the worse the connection will be. Besides, I admit I'm not familiar with the area but if the tower is high up on forestry land... doesn't that mean it is more visible to more properties and is now 'destroying the semi-rural lifestyle' of more people? It has too, because if there is enough trees in the way then the tower signal will attenuate massively and become useless. This, plus will necessitate the bulldozing of trees and destruction of wildlife habitats both around the tower itself and the newly laid road towards it? Does Ms. Town not care about that?
I was going to post in the Noosa News website (http://www.noosanews.com.au/news/towering-battle-begins/2178986/#comments), but then i realized that through this petition I can talk to the people of Cooran directly, hopefully without being moderated too much and with a greater word allowance! First, here is the research paper Mrs Town is likely referring too: http://www.iarc.fr/en/media-centre/pr/2011/pdfs/pr208_E.pdf "The evidence was reviewed critically, and overall evaluated as being limited among users of wireless telephones for glioma and acoustic neuroma, and inadequate to draw conclusions for other types of cancers." As you can see here, the very organization and paper Melissa cites doesn't support her. Now that that is out of the way, lets look at her other 'concerns' stemming from mostly emotional and some financial issues: "destroy their semi-rural lifestyle" Wow. Talk about hyperbole. The tower is going to run around tearing up forests and killing livestock? Do these residents also complain about poor mobile coverage? She said she supports the NBN, so clearly internet access isn't destroying anything. If the service the tower provides 'destroys their lifestyle' then they're free to not connect to it. "lower property values" Unless the locals are immortal, someone else is going to live on their land eventually. What will the new, heavily tech-savvy GenX, Y and Milennial retirees think when the retirement home they're considering is blanketed by a sub-par internet connection that doesn't serve their needs? interfere with locals' "peace of mind" How exactly are you quantifying this Melissa? Is there a 'piece of mind' calculator that i'm unaware of? This is nothing but emotional reactionism. As stated before the ECM Radiation from the tower is not proven to be harmful and it actually took me a moment to find it on the mockup photograph shown on the NoosaNews page. Like mobile towers and other such constructions, eventually the tower will
Relocate elsewhere
Wake up you public servant town planners????? Ruining the world and society for what reason????
Stop destroying the state forests, this is why our weather is so unbalanced.
I agree that the tower should be located on government land
I wonder if Aurecon CEO, Paul Hardy would agree to the tower being built on his land...?
disgusted with the lack of regard for residents
Move the tower on to the governments land
BUILD THE TOWER SOMEWHERE ELSE!!!
Good Luck
Hope you get it stopped Loo!
Im so proud of you! Its so good to see that you are standing up for your rights! Im sure you would not have bought the your beautiful property if you knew there would have been a tower erected to spoil the uninterrupted views from your home.
Pls relocate NBN Infrastructure from Coles Creek Road.
Mel you're doing a fantastic and tireless job with this lobby. I want your beautiful property to stay flawless and not encroached on by big business. I'm very proud to be your first online signature! Keep up the good work!