This petition is to state that we, the OETEF Group E, consisting of Ilkin Shahverdiyev, Emil Manchev, Kerri Maddock, Vladimir Recas, Stephen Wager, Bruno Vanpoucke, Michael Haus and Sam Akinkunmi; had no problems or issues working with Timofei Markov, and that he has fully contributed to the group. We see no reason why he would receive a 47% for the trading game, which is equivalent of a fail and indicates that his performance was unsatisfactory. We do not see why he would fail, and do not see a reason why he received an adjusted mark of 9, when the overall original syndicate mark was 14. Kind regards, signed, Ilkin Shahverdiyev, Emil Manchev, Kerri Maddock, Vladimir Recas, Stephen Wager, Bruno Vanpoucke, Michael Haus and Sam Akinkunmi