| # | Name | Comments |
|---|
| 1 | mike simmons | Have been walking the area for the last 40 years and the mill deserves to be restored to its original and possibly made into a wildlife area for the whole community to enjoy |
| 2 | Diana LeCore | |
| 3 | Robert Sharp MBE | As a member of the Essex Mills Group and the Mills Section of the SPAB I am concerned about the possible loss of this very important mill. It has value as an educational asset and should be restored to a working condition and made available for visits by schools and other interested peresons and groups. |
| 4 | Irene Jones | Essential this hidden treasure is not destroyed. Better still if it could be restored.
Irene Jones |
| 5 | Jonathan Neville | This country needs its heritage.
Government targets should come second |
| 6 | Evelyn Carpenter | PLEASE do not convert this wonderful/beautiful Tilty Watermill into anything else but what it is.
Here in the USA there are very few things left as lovely as your Watermill. This is so sad.
On every trip to the UK that I have made I have walked by and admired this Watermill, knowing that my mother, grandparents, ancestors (before 1900) had probably touched the wall too, as I did.
I hope to return and press my hand against the wall once more, visualizing, and remembering how many people this lovely old mill affected.
Thanks for not destroying it!!
Evelyn Carpenter (81 years old) Lucerne Valley, California, USA |
| 7 | Susan Smith | |
| 8 | Denise Pallett | In a time when we could be losing so many beautiful and historically important, interesting and useful in terms of eduaction, buildings to ever expanding airport (for example) surely we should be fighting to save some? |
| 9 | Anonymous | We have restored our own Domesday site mill and have received thousands of complementary comments on the fact that it has been done. |
| 10 | Malvern Tipping | All too many fine buildings - often deliberately left to decline - are sacrificed so that greater short-term gains cam be made. Mills are very susceptible to such pressures. Tilty watermill is another such mill. The Planning Authority should not only prevent the re-development of this property, but moreover should take a pro-active role to save and conserve the mill. |
| 11 | Adam Marriott | DONT CONVERT THIS MILL
its a rare survivor and to do so would be sacrilage. |
| 12 | David Mann | |
| 13 | Anonymous | |
| 14 | david andrews | |
| 15 | Ian | Save our historical Buildings! |
| 16 | pamela Chlopas | |
| 17 | gary stone | |
| 18 | lesley Turner | |
| 19 | Mike Thurlow | How can this happen to a grade 2 star mill.
I am the miller of Letheringsett Watermill and these mills can be brought back to use with the onset of alternative energy i.e.water. We have just won the UKTV food Heroes award with the flour which we produce from localy grown wheat, not only does this support the local community but also your local economy. It is therefore very short sighted to lose to lose this valuebal asset it would also support your tourism , not forgeting this is your Heratige. |
| 20 | cari powell | tilty mill was the long term rented home of a famous canadian author elizabeth smart who wrote "by grand central station i sat down and wept". |
| 21 | Anonymous | |
| 22 | Anonymous | We need to keep and restore all Mills and their history for future generations - not lose them to developers, they can never be replaced. |
| 23 | Charles Groves | Tilty mill house was indeed the home to famous poet Elizabeth Smart and her husband George Barker.
Also the scottish painters Robrt Colquhoun and Robert MacBryde.
They lived in the mill house (not the mill), in the 1950's when the mill house was one big house, not divided into two as it is now. |
| 24 | Chris Tugby | TOO much of our national heritage has been converted to housing for too long and it's time that places such as Tilty watermill got the protection they deserve.
Many of our old mills are too far gone to be able to do anything but a change of use to residential dwelling, but Tilty mill is in a different position with much of it's machinery still there and needs little restoration compared to some to make it a valuable local historical and educational asset.
I'm sure there must be plenty of other places that could be used instead of converting this 800-year-old building of historical interest into just another home or second home.
Chris Tugby
Mill Manager
Ford End Watermill Ivinghoe
Bucks |
| 25 | Sandra & David.Hutton | Sadly planning applications to convert water & windmills in to domestic dwellings has almost wiped out in this country an important part of our national heritage. It is imperative that Councils receiving such applications should turn down any application to convert what mills are left and should put their powers into getting those mills which are left with most of the machinery intact help with funding to restore these mills back to working order. The mills have played a very big part of our local structure and heritage and also helped to feed our nation. |
| 26 | Paul Palmer | |
| 27 | david jones | For gods sake, this is a grade 2 star listed building! Does that not count for anything with this council. What is the point of listing if they get planning permission?
Some questions really need to be asked here.... |
| 28 | S.B.Whiteley | Since this watermill retains so much of its machinery it would be vandalism to empty it to create dwelling. The leat and water could at least be used to provide electrical power with green credentials. |
| 29 | Anonymous | save one of the last mills left, dont let it become another large house. let all enjoy it as a working mill again. |
| 30 | L Devonish | |
| 31 | Anonymous | |
| 32 | Alexander Curtis | |
| 33 | Kate Harland | |
| 34 | D.James | Good luck in your fight, save our heritage, dont let it be sold.
Why hasnt it been restored by the council before now? |
| 35 | Andrew Findon | This mill should clearly be restored, not house converted, which would be a waste of an important historical resource. |
| 36 | Barry Carter | Save our history, it can never be replaced. |
| 37 | Ron Roper | I was involved with Stotfold mill in Bedfordshire. The mill has been rebuilt from a burnt out wreck to full working order, Showing that with local support anything is possible. See our website at www. stotfoldmill.org |
| 38 | RON ROBINSON | GOOD LUCK-SAVE THIS NATIONALLY IMPORTANT HERITAGE MILL |
| 39 | F Pack | |
| 40 | Mr. M. H. Edgeworth | As a grade 2* building we cannot afford to let another historic building get converted, let alone another mill complete with machinery. What will our descendants think of us for allowing the destruction of their history. It should be restored to working order and made to work as a demonstation centre. I speak as one who regulary demonstates a working water mill where the public show an increasing interest in its workings. |
| 41 | Anonymous | I moved into tilty mill with my mum and dad and 4 sisters and 3 brothers in 1953 and left in 1964 my dad was the stockman at the mill and used the mill to grind the corn for the cows for feed it would be a shame to see the mill turned into houses |
| 42 | Colin Bowden | It is astonishing that Uttlesford Council seems to have completely ignored all the objections to this planning application to convert this mill |
| 43 | Brian Shingler | I am writing to object to the conversion of Tilty watermill to residential, and would like to see efforts to restore it to working condition supported. At Gants Mill in Somerset (www.gantsmill.co.uk) we have restored the fabric of the building, maintained the corn grinding machinery, which is in regular use. We have also installed a hydropower plant to generate green electricity, landscaped the gardens, and are open two days a week to the general public. Yesterday afternoon, a Thursday, we had 72 people to visit the mill.
I am sure that a similar scheme at Tilty would help preserve the mill in working condition for future generations to enjoy.
Brian Shingler
Gants Mill, Bruton Somerset BA10 0DB
01749 812393 |
| 44 | dave bragg | Its priceless. Let it be as it is |
| 45 | Craig Taylor | This grade 2* mill is a rare and important building and should be preserved as a mill and not converted in any way to residental use. I would support a sympathetic residential scheme on the adjoining land or buildings which would enable the mill to be preserved and guarantee its repair. Any agreement would need to be a legally binding (eg Section 106). |
| 46 | Anita Thompson | |
| 47 | David | |
| 48 | a. smith | SAVE IT |
| 49 | Audrey Steeley | We at Heron Corn Mill in Beetham South Cumbria, wish to object to the conversion of the grade II* listed watermill known as Tilty Watermill. A significant historical building can be put to good use for the benefit and education of the public. |
| 50 | Anonymous | |