Here is the thing : "Brian De Palma's initial cut ran at roughly three hours and was a faithful adaptation of the book, with more time dedicated to Bucky's psychological breakdown during the investigation and his obsession with avenging the Dahlia. James Ellroy was shown a print of this version and wrote an essay praising it; entitled "The Hillikers," it was published in re-issued prints of the novel which were released before the film premiered. In the interim between Ellroy's having seen the director's cut and the publication of his essay, the film was significantly edited. After seeing the theatrical cut, Ellroy refused to comment on it" I, along with many others, believe 'The Black Dahlia' to be a great film in its original form. The threatical cut has solid acting and great cinematography. But the storyline has a lot of flaws. So, please sign this petition if you also wish the makers of 'The Black Dahlia' to release the original director's cut of the film on DVD and Blu-ray.
To anyone who reads this comment:
The director's cut 3 hour version or whatever needs to be released. If the author of The Black Dahlia, James Ellroy, loved the 3 hour film adaptation praises it, and is so moved by it, that he writes an essay, that's the version that should be released.
Also, James Ellroy has very high standards, so if he loved the 3 hour version so much, it must be an amazing version, and that's the version I want to see.
It should have been as amazing as L.A. Confidential, another film adapted from James Ellroy's book. The film version of L.A. Confidential was highly praised, very good, was nominated for several Academy Awards/Oscars, was nominated for Best Picture, but lost, but won other Oscars.
That's the kind of quality I believe exists in the 3 hour version of The Black Dahlia.
Also,I want to sidetrack for a moment. Another reason for me wanting to see the 3 hour version is because I am a huge James Ellroy fan. My first novel I read by him was called White Jazz, and after that I became a huge fan of James Ellroy, kept reading his other works, and have gotten and read all his books to date. More importantly, though, because I loved White Jazz so much, I developed a love for reading, which I never had before. I love reading now, I'm proud of it, I thank James Ellroy for that, and if it wasn't for James Ellroy, I wouldn't have that trait or love.
So it is beneficial to everyone, meaning more money since people will see the good 3 hour version over the theatrical cut if it is good, which I believe the 3 hour version is very good.
Lastly, to anyone who reads this and is part of this petition, tell:
family, friends, fans of The Black Dahlia theatrical cut the people who liked it, people who were disappointed and/or didn't like disliked the theatrical cut, fans of the novel The Black Dahlia by James Ellroy, fans of James Ellroy in general, fans of other of James Ellroy's film adaptations, fans of Brian DePalma that either liked or didn't like the theatrical cut, fans/people interested in the real Black Dahlia/Elizabeth Short murder, try to tell inform James Ellroy himself
Just spread the word around to anyone and everyone you can.
give them the link
Tell them about this, and tell them about this petition, the 3 hour version. I really hope/prays this version gets released. Thank you.
De Palma is an artist and the film deserves a second chance. You can't butcher James Ellroy either. I understand theatrical limitations, but there is no reason why a release of De Palma's director's cut on DVD and Blu Ray shouldn't be released. Do the right thing...
Brian DePalma is a good director and most especially with thrillers. I am a fan of the version released and would be very interested to see the 3-hour version that I have been led to believe exists.
I am a film fan and appreciate directors who take their time to tell a story especially if it is a long movie. I understand that studios believe that audiences do not like long movies and that exhibitors feel that they lose money by not being able to have as many screenings per day as they would with a 90-minute to 2 hour film.
This is not the issue with a 3-hour version being released on DVD/BluRay. People who are fans or the people who did not understand the film complete;but thought it was still well made would be very interested in purchasing a 3-hour director's cut.
James Ellroy, the author of the book upon which this film is based saw the 3-hour version and was inspired to write and essay about the version of the movie that he saw. Later, after seeing the cut that was released to movie theatres, he refused to comment. This could be construed as disappointment, possibly anger.
I would pay again to own this new version. For marketing purposes, the studio could release a DVD/BluRay with both versions of the film. In addition, with the release of the "new" disc(s), supporting commentary could be extensive since there would so much new footage.
Please release the version that James Ellroy saw. I respect him as an author, enjoyed the essay he wrote and would love to see him in interviews included as extras with the new DVD/BluRay.
Belinda Palamara, Australia3 weeks ago Comments: -
Jeremy Nakache3 weeks ago Comments: -
Ed Parry2 months ago Comments: -
There are no highlights yet.