Stop Binn Farm Incinerator

Signatures 114 total

Page: 1, 2, 3

1. 1
   Name: Michael Gallagher on Jul 28, 2007

   Address:

   Comments:

   Flag
2. 2
   Name: Michael Gallagher on Jul 30, 2007

   Address: 33 Precinct Street Coupar Angus Perth & Kinross PH13 9DG

   Comments:

   Flag
3. 3
   Name: Michael Gallagher on Jul 30, 2007

   Address: test

   Comments:

   Flag
4. 4
   Name: Anonymous on Aug 1, 2007

   Address: 40 Ragstone Road Slough

   Comments: There is no excuse for using incinerators anymore now we know just how damgerous small particulates are

   Flag
5. 5
   Name: Arthur Jarrett on Aug 10, 2007

   Address: 45 Naughton Road Wormit Newport-on-Tay DD6 8NG

   Comments:

   Flag
6. 6
   Name: Andrew Thompson on Aug 10, 2007

   Address: Dunning Perthshire

   Comments: This project is verging on the criminal and must be stopped. To burn 60,000 tonnes of recyclable waste a year is simply the lazy option, and amounts to 'landfill in the sky". To make matters worse the energy from waste claims being made by the company are a sick joke as all the waste heat which is not turned into electricity (up to 70%) will be wasted as there is no use for the heat at Binn Farm. Perth & Kinross council should be ashamed of themselves for risking the health of so many of their residents

   Flag
7. 7
   Name: Fiona Sinclair on Aug 11, 2007

   Address: 15 Arran View, Dunure, Ayrshire, KA7 4LP.

   Comments:

   Flag
8. 8
   Name: Anonymous on Aug 15, 2007

   Address: Meikle Cossans Farmhous, Glamis

   Comments: Yet again PKC are prepared to forge ahead no matter what. I find it beyond belief that they didn't consult with neighbouring authorities. That just spells out how competent they really are. If they can't take that common sense step how are they to be trusted to build an incinerator that won't poison us all

   Flag
9. 9
   Name: Angela Graham on Aug 15, 2007

   Address: 123 Braehead Road Cumbernauld G67 2BJ

   Comments:

   Flag
10. 10
    Name: Sandra Johnston on Aug 15, 2007

    Address: law view 1, heckler's wynd strathmiglo fife ky14 7pp

    Comments: knowing how the smell from the landfill at binn farm drifts down to strathmiglo when the wind is in a certain direction, i strongly object to having an incinerator which will produce toxic chemicals and gases into the atmosphere, to drift wherever the wind takes them.

    Flag
11. 11
    Name: Christopher Grave on Aug 15, 2007

    Address: Easterton Farm Glenfarg Perthshire PH2 9QJ

    Comments:

    Flag
12. 12
    Name: Peter McColl on Aug 16, 2007

    Address: 23a Bath Street Edinburgh EH15 1HB

    Comments:

    Flag
13. 13
    Name: Roger Humphry on Aug 16, 2007

    Address: Viewbank, High Street, Errol,PH2 7QE

    Comments: As the greens have said this will just generate a market for waste instead of focussing on reducing the waste production at source.

    Flag
14. 14
    Name: Erik Zoha on Aug 16, 2007

    Address: 46 Arthurstone terrace Stobswell Dundee DD4 6QT

    Comments:

    Flag
15. 15
    Name: Erik Zoha on Aug 16, 2007

    Address: 46 Arthurstone terrace Stobswell Dundee DD4 6QT

    Comments:

    Flag
16. 16
    Name: Ian C. Copland on Aug 17, 2007

    Address: 8 Kilmaron Crescent, Cupar, Fife, KY15 4DS

    Comments:

    Flag
17. 17
    Name: Valerie Cameron on Aug 17, 2007

    Address: The Bungalow Westpark Road Blairgowrie PH10 6EL

    Comments:

    Flag
18. 18
    Name: Ian Macrae on Aug 18, 2007

    Address: Johnston Farmhouse Newburgh Fife KY146JG

    Comments: Downwind and 9 miles away, we will be the most directly affected by any chemical discharge. With the pollution experienced by Abernethy , I do not trust the management of this company to effectively control the discharges

    Flag
19. 19
    Name: Ms Marj Bond on Aug 18, 2007

    Address: eden cottage old town gateside fife

    Comments: i totally reject the proposal to build an incinarator at binn farm which is not in accordance with the recommendations of sepa and independent professional advice i. e .combined heat and power plant in shores road where consent already exists.

    Flag
20. 20
    Name: R Quartermaine on Aug 19, 2007

    Address: Sentosa Glenfarg PH2 9QQ

    Comments: The proposed waste incineration plant at Shore Road, Perth combining Heat and Power systems will show a greater benefit to the communities involved than the proposal at Binn Farm

    Flag
21. 21
    Name: R Quartermaine on Aug 19, 2007

    Address: Sentosa Glenfarg PH2 9QQ

    Comments: The proposed waste incineration plant at Shore Road, Perth combining Heat and Power systems will show a greater benefit to the communities involved than the proposal at Binn Farm

    Flag
22. 22
    Name: H Quartermaine on Aug 19, 2007

    Address: Sentosa Glenfarg PH2 9QQ

    Comments:

    Flag
23. 23
    Name: Peter Romilly on Aug 19, 2007

    Address: 4 Westwood Terrace Newport on Tay Fife DD6 8JF

    Comments:

    Flag
24. 24
    Name: Felicity Martin on Aug 19, 2007

    Address: Belvue, Thimble Row Dunning Perthshire

    Comments: Poisoning local communities is not the way to deal with waste, especially with a rather ineffiecient incinerator. The need to keep it fed will encourage PKC to send more material to it (and into our skies), rather than recycling or reducing waste.

    Flag
25. 25
    Name: Ms Marj Bond on Aug 20, 2007

    Address: eden cottage old town gateside fife

    Comments: scottish ministers should ban the binn farm incinerator from going ahead for breaching the scottish executive national waste plan-it is according to sepa only 23%efficient -seeping invisible toxic dioxins into the atmosphere

    Flag
26. 26
    Name: James Gray on Aug 21, 2007

    Address: eden cottage gateside fife

    Comments: I object to the proposal by perth cc not to proceed with the instalation of a state of the art incinerator but to proceed with the lower cost incinerator which will cause more polution I also question whether this is also about keeping am inadequate and unsatisfactory landfill site going which clearly would be embarassing to the county if discontinued Their decision would ignore independent advise and also the expansion of the sites potential for environmental damage due to wind borne pollution and increased trafic problems. Is it not the case that the larger incinerator requires a greater catchement area to be viable and the real problem is existing pollution, location of site for access and viability of a failing facility, better located in perth/and already approved

    Flag
27. 27
    Name: J M Dickson on Aug 21, 2007

    Address: 7 Kinellan Rd Edinburgh EH12 6ES

    Comments: Choose Health.

    Flag
28. 28
    Name: Jill Clark on Aug 23, 2007

    Address: Invernahaven Back Dykes Abernethy PH2 9JN

    Comments:

    Flag
29. 29
    Name: Anonymous on Aug 23, 2007

    Address: Balvaird Cottages Strathmiglo Cupar KY14 7SR

    Comments: This proposed incinerator will cause health hazards to the surrounding areas despite statements to the contrary. We live extremely near the proposed site i.e it is in the neighbouring field, but were told we would be less affected because of the prevailing wind. So what about the communities who are at the other side of the prevailing wind The fact that the incinerator would need a huge input of waste to make it efficient will make the roads even more hazardous than they already are. It is also more important to re-cycle than to burn. The toxic waste from the incinerator is another factor to be dealt with, yet not mentioned by SITA.

    Flag
30. 30
    Name: Anonymous on Aug 24, 2007

    Address: Balvaird Cottages Strathmiglo Cupar KY147SR

    Comments: I live right next door to the proposed development and will have to move away if it goes ahead. In no way do I want to live near those emissions and nor should anyone else.

    Flag
31. 31
    Name: David Mcelnea on Aug 24, 2007

    Address: 54 main st abernethy

    Comments: a more sensible approach to waste needed

    Flag
32. 32
    Name: Tara O' Leary on Aug 25, 2007

    Address: Chancefield Falkland Fife KY 157AE

    Comments: Perth and Kinross should adopt a precautionary approach in relation to incineration. The council should instead invest heavily in a strong waste reduction strategy which could easily replace the need for this new and potentially dangerous facility.

    Flag
33. 33
    Name: Louise Ramsay on Aug 26, 2007

    Address: Bamff Alyth Perthshire PH11 8LF

    Comments: Burning waste encourages the production of more waste and puts pollutants into the air. Waste should be reduced, reused and recycled, not incinerated.

    Flag
34. 34
    Name: Elaine Morrison on Aug 27, 2007

    Address: MacAtholl Cottage Caputh Perth PH1 4JJ

    Comments: This is the most unsustainable project I have seen in years and cannot be allowed to go ahead.

    Flag
35. 35
    Name: Marianne Thomas on Aug 27, 2007

    Address: 55a edinburgh road perth ph28du

    Comments: i used to live in abernethy for 8 years and the smells that eminated from the land fill when the rubbish was bing burnt was horrendous and the whole village would smell. No matter how much you complained nothing was done so now is our chance to do something about it. i also now have a 16 month old son and don't want him growing up breathing in the toxic fumes.

    Flag
36. 36
    Name: Alan Smeaton on Aug 27, 2007

    Address: 55a Edinburgh Road Perth Ph2 8du

    Comments:

    Flag
37. 37
    Name: ER Christie on Aug 27, 2007

    Address: Annsmuir Farm Ladybank Cupar

    Comments: Incineration is not acceptable, especially with a cheap, inefficient plant. 'Reduce, Reuse, Recycle' is what the Council should be promoting before we have squandered the entire resources of this planet.

    Flag
38. 38
    Name: Sue Whisler on Aug 27, 2007

    Address: Marley Cottage Old Town Gateside Fife

    Comments:

    Flag
39. 39
    Name: Dr Alasdair J Gray on Aug 28, 2007

    Address: annsmuir farm ladybank

    Comments: i have great concern about the potential health impact for local patients and the damaging environmental effects. please pursue more environmentally friendly methods of waste disposal

    Flag
40. 40
    Name: Dr Alasdair J Gray on Aug 28, 2007

    Address: annsmuir farm ladybank

    Comments: i have great concern about the potential health impact for local patients and the damaging environmental effects. please pursue more environmentally friendly methods of waste disposal

    Flag
41. 41
    Name: Karl Thomas on Aug 28, 2007

    Address: 19 Hall Park Abernethy Perthshire PH2 8HX

    Comments: I feel that this development will not only cause health issues for the local residents but will also harm the general environment of the area. I am sure this will also have an adverse effect on the local wildlife as well and rather not have such and incinerator on my doorstep.

    Flag
42. 42
    Name: C. Lyon on Sep 11, 2007

    Address: Larchknowe Tulloch Hill Perth PH1 2PN

    Comments:

    Flag
43. 43
    Name: Roger Thomas on Sep 12, 2007

    Address: 23 Moyness Park Drive Blairgowrie PH10 6LX

    Comments: The most effective way of waste management is to reduce through put in the system. This reduces need for incineration.

    Flag
44. 44
    Name: Peter Allison on Sep 26, 2007

    Address: Viewfield Cottage Ross Farm Glencarse Perthshire

    Comments: SITA were forced to pay £3 million to Brighton and Hove Council in 2001 to get out of the contract to provide waste management services after 250 council bin workers took unofficial strike action and occupied their depot in the face of impossible changes to their contracts. SITA can be beaten. ps anyone notice who was sponsoring this years Labour Party Conference....Thats right, SITA.

    Flag
45. 45
    Name: Anonymous on Nov 17, 2007

    Address: 65, ST CHRISTOPHER'S WHARF, LONDON, E14

    Comments: I'm all in favour of incinerators provided they are used to dispose of dangerous extremists such as the President of Iran or George Galloway MP. Bearing in mind the latter is Scottish but is currently polluting an East London consitutency his repatriation to a Scottish incinerator would seem appropriate.

    Flag
46. 46
    Name: Christine Nash on Nov 19, 2007

    Address: Invernahaven Abernethy

    Comments:

    Flag
47. 47
    Name: Helen Spear on Dec 18, 2007

    Address: Aberdraw Aberhosan Machynlleth Powys

    Comments:

    Flag
48. 48
    Name: Andrea Cardno on Jan 13, 2008

    Address: Rose Cottage Abernethy

    Comments:

    Flag
49. 49
    Name: E. Gebbett on Jan 22, 2008

    Address: Denbank Abernethy

    Comments:

    Flag
50. 50
    Name: Yvonne Cherrie on Jan 22, 2008

    Address: Abernethy

    Comments: I endorse previous eloquent sentiments.

    Flag

Page: 1, 2, 3