Save Lalbagh: Explore Alternatives for Metro

Mr. B. S. Yeddyurappa Chief Minister of Karnataka Respected Sir, On the eve of General Elections, large numbers in Bangalore have come out in protest against the construction of an elevated track for the Metro through Lalbagh and Lakshman Rao Parks. I/We join these protests, initiated by Hasiru Usiru, and demand that the Government suspend all work on the southern reach of the Metro till such time it has duly consulted the wide public. All political candidates contesting the Bangalore South Constituency for the Lok Sabha have endorsed the position that Lalbagh should not be destroyed in any manner, considering its heritage status and unique features as a botanical garden. Again because of the mounting protests, Mr. R. Ashok, Karnataka Minister for Transport, has stated in the media that he has asked the Bangalore Metro authorities to suspend all work on the Southern Reach of the Metro, including tree felling. Despite such assurances at the highest levels of the Government, Bangalore Metro officials have categorically stated that they will not suspend work, and would continue with business as usual. Dr. Ramachandran, Secretary, Union Ministry of Urban Development and Chairman of the Metro has confirmed that there cannot be any change now in alignment as all approvals have been obtained from the State and Union Governments. He has also said that a zig-zag Metro is not feasible. There are many disturbing aspects to these statements: 1)Undemocratic approach to issue Ordinance: It is a fact that the Government of Karnataka took a very undemocratic step of issuing an ordinance on 22 November 2008 to amend the Karnataka Parks Act to allow a portion of the world famous Lalbagh gardens to be used for a Metro station. Such an issue should have been first debated in public and also in the Legislature. There have been four Legislative Sessions since June 2008, and not once was this issue tabled for discussion. To instead choose to issue an Ordinance on such a sensitive issue is nothing short of a betrayal of democratic traditions and the right of the people to know and participate in decision making. 2)If zig-zag alignment is not feasible, then why have a zig-zag alignment at all: Dr. Ramachandran's statement that a Metro line is not feasible if it goes zig-zag is contradictory to the defense of Zig-Zag alignment for the southern reach of the Metro. As now proposed, the southern reach from K. R. Road runs through Vani Vilas Road, Lalbagh/R. V. Road, Lakshman Rao boulevard and then Banashankari, all this within four kms and involving four zig-zag 90 deg turns. This will substantially slow down the Metro, increase wear and tear and make maintenance a costly affair. 3)Elevated Metro and its long term consequences: All things considered, an elevated Metro will remain for all time to come. There are many instances where Elevated Metros and transport corridors have been pulled down (Eg. Boston) and put underground as they have caused various negative impacts including depressed neighbourhoods and local economies, increase in crime rates, increase in noise pollution, decrease in availability of road space, etc. None of the Metro stations on this reach have any parking zones, and it is more than likely that in the near future more acquisition will take place to create parking areas with Lalbagh and Lakshman Rao Parks becoming easy targets. It is well known that the Metro also proposes to use its stations as Malls, so there is no guarantee that this will not happen to the Metro line proposed through Lalbagh and Lakshman Rao parks. It is also very much in the realm of possibility that in order road space lost to the Metro track to accomodate increased vehicular density, existing roads may be widened in time to come, and this could result in further displacement of communities and loss of parks and open spaces. 4)Alternatives not explored: Much against the claim of Namma Metro there has been no statutory public consultation whatsoever in consonance with applicable law (in particular the Karnataka Town and Country Planning Act). This has denied those directly affected with the right to Prior and Informed Consent and caused serious disruptions in their lives and livelihoods. Equally serious has been the impact on parks and open spaces, with the Bangalore Metro authorities arrogating to themselves the right to apportion such lands to the Metro without due public consultation or adopting a transparent approach. Keeping in view all of these concerns, I/we demand the following: 1.The Government of Karnataka must immediately instruct Namma Metro authorities to stop work on the southern reach. 2.Such a move is in order as all candidates contesting the Bangalore South consituency have supported the stand that Lalbagh should be protected as a sacred space for all time to come responding to popular sentiment.The Executive must bow down to the will of the people. Consequently, the Government must allow the Ordinance issued to acquire Lalbagh for the Namma Metro to lapse on 22 May 2009. 3.The possibility of taking the Metro underground or through alternate alignments without causing much loss of greenery and property must be publicly explored. This must be done with due dispatch and in total conformance with law and policy. Funds for this are easily available if only the Government stops investing in the elitist High Speed Rail Link project, which costs nearly Rs. 5,000 crores, and caters to the needs of only 30,000 air travellers. That money should instead be invested in the Metro to take it underground and thereby serve the interest of lakhs of people now and into the future. I/We hope that you support these progressive initiatives and immediately suspend the Metro authorities to stop work on the southern reach of Namma Metro. Not only would such action be popular now, but would also prove to be regarded by future generations.

Sponsor

This petition is initiated by Hasiru Usiru, a network of organisations and individuals focussed on conserving public commons, open spaces and greenery in Bangalore. Following several protests over the past two weeks, the Karnataka Transport Minister Ashok announced on the eve of General Elections that the Government would order a stop to the work on the Metro through Bangalore's landmark heritage Lalbagh and Lakshman Rao parks. Even so, work continues. This appeal is to ensure the Chief Minister keeps its Government's commitment and orders a fundamental redesign of the Metro work on its southern reach. For more information on this issue, please visit: www.esgindia.org and www.hasiruusiru.org

Links

http://www.esgindia.org http://www.hasiruusiru.org http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lal_Bagh

Discussion

No comments yet.

join the discussion

Recent signatures

  • username

    social bookmarking service, Russian Federation

    2 years ago Comments: RDJUce I am so grateful for your blog.Really thank you! Great.
  • username

    Buy Cheap OEM Software, Ukraine

    3 years ago Comments: leC4KE A round of applause for your blog.Much thanks again. Want more.
  • username

    lquydmwurv, France

    5 years ago Comments: -
See more

Petition highlights

There are no highlights yet.