| # | Name | Comments |
|---|
| 2301 | David Shorthouse | I love Wier! Come back to us! |
| 2302 | alan | please, please, Torri come back....fire Sam...don't like her character...she does not fit in Atlantis....time for her to go..and keep Torri..I love her!!! |
| 2303 | morten olssen | |
| 2304 | Karine Jans | Torri is the best choice for the role as leader of Stargate Atlantis!! |
| 2305 | bridge lutz | OMG, ever since my FAVE charecter Elisabeth left, the show has hit rock bottom!!! Without her, there are no good eps. We love you Elisabth!! |
| 2306 | law | I stopped watching the show...don't understand what the producers have in mind...bring in Sam, which nobody likes, and get rid of the Goddess Torri, what are they thinking of? Torri, I am always behind you!!! |
| 2307 | nicola reid | we want you back ,you could see that there is still a great bond between the atlantis cast member when at pegasus 3 PLEASE don"t lose this |
| 2308 | elisabeth sheppard | please save weir she's the best commander of atlantis. And she's Sheppard's love. SAVE WEIR!!!!
without her stargate atlantis is not the same... |
| 2309 | Anonymous | What has gotten to them? Elizabeth was a huge reason I was watching, she knew how to lead all those characters. NOW you've stuck Samantha Carter in her place and that just pissed me off more. That girl can not lead, she doesn't even belong in SGA she had her film time in SG1 so leave her there.
Please don't ruin SGA, I can rarely find a good show this one I found to be amazing. . .but not anymore and from the sound of it I will even hate Season 5 more.
-Danyel |
| 2310 | Jess | I love Dr. Weir! I really would like to have her come back as a regular! |
| 2311 | harold medianero | I'm in full accord to having Torri Higginson as Dr. Elizabeth Weir back as a regular cast member of
Stargate Atlantis!!! It is paramount that she returns
for her vital and humanistic side in being a good leader and her presence makes her interractions with fellow cast members that much more captivating! She shows her ability to not only be a team leader, but has strength and judgement that
her peers felt more respect for than amanda tapping's charachter, Colonel Samantha Carter. No disrespect to Sam. |
| 2312 | ed mcCormick | the producers are the one that needed to be replaced. Bring back Torri, get rid of Sam. I have stopped watching the show...of course Torri turned down season 5, they offered her a symbol role in one show. Who is the idol that thought of bring Sam into this show. We don't need her..We need more of Torri. end of the story |
| 2313 | Raphaela | pleeease save Elizabet Weir!!! We all miss her soo much!!!
♥Liz and john♥ |
| 2314 | Rachel Rositano | |
| 2315 | Raphaela | I hope that she cames back!!!!!
Save Elizabeth Weir!!!!
the show will not be the same without her! |
| 2316 | MaxLoeser | I love LIZ! PLEASE brinh her back at season 5 or 6 ! The show is not the same without her :( |
| 2317 | Anonymous | |
| 2318 | Rebecca Forsyth | Dr Weir brings a unique aspect to the command of Atlantis she knows when the time for talking is over and when to fight she will be greatly missed |
| 2319 | Anonymous | SAVE WEIR |
| 2320 | Dirk Rose | When Torri was was case as Dr. Weir I was skeptical. Since SG-1 had used Jessica Steen in the role. After watching the first few episodes I realized that she indeed was the right choice for the role. I understand that Amanda Tapping was still under contract and the decision to use her based on that. Now that she has moved on to another project my opinion along with many others would be to have Torri return as a regular. I hope you will listen to the fans of the show and do the right thing! |
| 2321 | Nicholas Belis | Dr. Elizabeth Weir must come back for season 5. |
| 2322 | Mizuki Onno Kitsune | Save Lizzy !!!!
Torri we love you ! = D |
| 2323 | Gatefan001 | Weir is too emotional. Carter is experienced in these things, and brings a scientific and logical mindset into leadership. Bring back Jackson and Tealc! |
| 2324 | Anonymous | BRING TORRI BACK TO SGA!!! |
| 2325 | Fiona | |
| 2326 | Pavel Kolář | |
| 2327 | Ryan Almquist | Dr. Weir is my FAVORITE character! I can't believe they would get rid of her. And why haven't I seen any of her since "Be All My Sins Remember'd"? PLEASE bring her back. |
| 2328 | Jordan Corei | I respectfully ask that you bring back the character of Dr. Elisabeth Weir to Stargate Atlantis. She was an invaluable character and I do not believe anyone can replace her. |
| 2329 | Christina | |
| 2330 | M hillery | I was going to be quiet..it is people like Gatefan001 that drive me crazy..we have a perfect address like Torri, beautiful, smart, and really attracts me to the show...then we have to bring in Sam, who appears like a dirtbag..to take over. I have given up the show, and see the producers have no inclination of reacting to the fans...they do whatever they want to do..ignoring the plea of the fans. Until Torri is back..I simply not going to support anything on Stargate. |
| 2331 | Anonymous | The show is not the same without Dr Weir. This is the beginning of the decline of Stargate Atlantis. I will eventually stop watching it. What do the producers of this program base their decisions on? I am extremely disappointed. What a way to ruin a good show. |
| 2332 | Craig Wright | SAVE ELIZABETH! |
| 2333 | jacob metzner | BRING HER BACK... SHE WAS MY FAVORITE!!!!!! |
| 2334 | Ashley Hamilton | |
| 2335 | Lis | It's not gonna be as good without her x |
| 2336 | Kylie Hughes | BRING BACK DR WEIR AND SAVE ATLANTIS! |
| 2337 | diddy47 | this is probably in retrospect ....elizabeth is not a leader...not a good one anyway...her decisions are based on petty power trips and she makes statements she cannot possibly back up & some really bad calls (e.g. believing that egomaniac mckay can do in a day what the greatest civalisation, the ancients, could not do in a 100 years ..ending up destroying a solar system & killing another scientist in the process)...and the arguments she makes to back up her decisions are mostly baseless and based on personal feeling like her interrogation for the bomb threat ...or when she tried to block caldwell's protocol changes. Or when she wanted to conduct the defense of atlantis though the is not a military strategist...because its "mine"...how childish can a charactor get? Or her lashing out at ronon when he said "i'm leaving"....going into a torrent like that when the guy had just simply finished eating...ergo...jumping to conclusions...not a very desirable leadership trait huh/
I can understand feminism drive or the need to see a dame strutting about ruffling the top brass but the character of dr wier is anything but realistic...she would have lost her position long before the siege in season one...as a matter of mention...the power struggles in bsg are more rooted in reality. |
| 2338 | diddy47 | this is probably in retrospect ....elizabeth is not a leader...not a good one anyway...her decisions are based on petty power trips and she makes statements she cannot possibly back up & some really bad calls (e.g. believing that egomaniac mckay can do in a day what the greatest civalisation, the ancients, could not do in a 100 years ..ending up destroying a solar system & killing another scientist in the process)...and the arguments she makes to back up her decisions are mostly baseless and based on personal feeling like her interrogation for the bomb threat ...or when she tried to block caldwell's protocol changes. Or when she wanted to conduct the defense of atlantis though the is not a military strategist...because its "mine"...how childish can a charactor get? Or her lashing out at ronon when he said "i'm leaving"....going into a torrent like that when the guy had just simply finished eating...ergo...jumping to conclusions...not a very desirable leadership trait huh/
I can understand feminism drive or the need to see a dame strutting about ruffling the top brass but the character of dr wier is anything but realistic...she would have lost her position long before the siege in season one...as a matter of mention...the power struggles in bsg are more rooted in reality. |
| 2339 | Kim | |
| 2340 | Holly | Bring Elizabeth Back =( |
| 2341 | Anonymous | she's a integrated part of the serie, without her we're nowwhere |
| 2342 | maureen | diddy47 is a dick...I think diddy47 is the producer of Atlantis, or the agent of Amanda (Sam)....we don't need Sam nor her agent to write a peititon. We want Torri!!! |
| 2343 | Mitchell | C,mon Brad Wright i'd make 100 emails and sign this 100 times aslong as weir comes back |
| 2344 | Phil & Maria | We dont want Weir replaced by what seems like a "part-time" Carter. |
| 2345 | Anonymous | |
| 2346 | Anonymous | |
| 2347 | Alice Kneen | BRING WIER BACK! Not that I don't like Carter but she does doesn't fit into that role as well as Torri and the chemistry on screen between the Elizabeth and John characters was amazing! |
| 2348 | Joy Polo | |
| 2349 | Adelinas | Elizabeth is the best. |
| 2350 | Anonymous | I haven't been watching it lately but i was shocked to hear that Dr. Weir was gone! She was the best for that role! I like Samantha Carter but not in Atlantis, at least not as a regular character.
Dr. Weir had such a good concenting with everyone there and she knew them all so well, the show will NOT be the same with out her. We need her back!!!!! |