| # | Name | Comments |
|---|
| 51 | joshua price | |
| 52 | Tresa | |
| 53 | Ali | |
| 54 | Katherine |
| 55 | Anonymous | American girls should not be retired,Its absurd. |
| 56 | Cheri March |
| 57 | Savannah |
| 58 | Tracy Kilgore | |
| 59 | Ida Norwood |
| 60 | Anonymous | |
| 61 | Amanda | Sammy was my first AG doll. In fact I loved her so much that I got another doll, Felicity.
Getting rid of Samantha will deny future AG customers, collectors, and fans that same joy. If anything, Pleasant Company can only profit when little girls buy Samantha and keep coming back for more. |
| 62 | Mary Ann Whartenby |
| 63 | Sarah | i luv sam and nellie dont retire them!!!!! |
| 64 | jolie moira jessalyn dawson |
| 65 | jolie moira jessalyn dawson |
| 66 | Holly | Bad choice for sure! Why would you retire the most popular one? Bring back Samantha! |