The request for additional original content has been fulfilled and the tracklist is being updated to reflect our requirements. We achieved this outcome because the collective pressure made the discrepancy in the package contents impossible to ignore. I will be monitoring the final distribution to ensure these tracks are delivered …
August 22, 2015
Requesting the Fanjoy edition of "Breathe In. Breathe Out." by Hilary Duff have 2 additional original songs added.
Final supporters
On May 27th of this year, Hilary Duff announced via Twitter that she was partnering with the Fanjoy company to release a new addition of her album "Breathe In. Breathe Out."
As advertised on HilaryDuff.com, the banner used to promote the package includes the words "Fanjoy Exclusive Bonus Tracks". The Fanjoy website uses
the verbiage "4 Bonus Tracks to Download". This mislead fans to believe
that the 50+ dollar package would be including 4 original songs that
have yet to be released.
On June 9th, Hilary Duff announced via Instagram that the additional tracks would be All About You, Chasing The Sun, Chasing The Sun (Dave Aude Remix) & Outlaw.
Chasing The Sun was released July 29, 2014 to iTunes. All About You was released on August 12, 2014 to iTunes. As both were iTunes releases that fans have had for nearly a year; they are in no way exclusive to Fanjoy.
The Federal Trade Commission states: "When
consumers see or hear an advertisement, whether it’s on the Internet,
radio or television, or anywhere else, federal law says that ad must be
truthful, not misleading, and, when appropriate, backed by scientific
evidence."
We call RCA Records &
FanjoyCo to add two additional bonus tracks to the download card for the
June 16th release of "Breathe In. Breathe out." due to the pretense of
false marketing.
Hilary Duff has recorded
the following songs in which 2 could be selected: 17, Before The Light
Changes, Better Days, Breathing Room, Carry On, Falling, Feel Alive,
Hurts, If I Fall, It All Starts Tonight, Northern Star, Snow Globe, Take
It For What It Is, Tearing Down Walls, This Heart, When We Were Young,
Whistling Dixie, Wherever We Go, Wild Night Out, & Where The Gods
Play.
Please add two additional songs to the Fanjoy edition of "Breathe In. Breathe Out." for its June 16th release. Thank you.
Updates
June 11, 2015
We have reached the two hundred fifty signature threshold. I am currently drafting a formal letter to the Fanjoy corporate office to address the discrepancy in their promotional verbiage.
Reached 250 supporters
June 10, 2015
June 10, 2015
The reach of this petition has shifted our position with Fanjoy representatives. I am now drafting a formal request to address the misleading promotional language regarding the bonus track content. We will leverage this momentum to insist on the inclusion of the two additional original tracks as originally implied.
Reached 100 supporters
June 10, 2015
June 7, 2015
We are currently preparing a formal letter to the Fanjoy team regarding their marketing claims. Reaching the milestone of 250 signatures will provide the necessary evidence to initiate a direct inquiry with their customer relations department.
138 Comments
I was expecting at least two new bonus tracks. The remix and Out law is fun, but the other two should be EXCLUSIVE tracks that you would not be able to get anywhere else. "Chasing the Sun" & "All About You" are already owned by most, if not all fans. We want new music! :)
I'm personally disappointed that FanJoy deceived the fans. Although I am excited about the additional items included - it's unfair that they falsely marketed the package to make them profit. Never buying from FanJoy again.
"Feel Alive" Needs to be added! seriously, was there really NO OTHER song choices to add "exclusive bonus tracks"? Shes been out of the music industry for 8 years...there HAS to be something else!
only the real fans are buying the boxset, and real fans have "chasing the sun" and "all about you" already, so what's the point of giving something we already have? If it was a psychical bonus CD I'd love it, but digital downloads of something I already have digitally does simply not worth it!
Please please please! I already own chasing the sun and all about you. This box set cost me $92 due to currency exchange and postage. I don't want to spend $92 for one extra song!!
I would love to hear more of Hilary's music <3 :)
4 promised songs to download. Where are they? Fanjoy should reimburse everyone who ordered the HD exclusive collection $5.
Share this petition
Share this petition to help it reach more people.
Your share link
The request for additional original content has been fulfilled and the tracklist is being updated to reflect our requirements. We achieved this outcome because the collective pressure made the discrepancy in the package contents impossible to ignore. I will be monitoring the final distribution to ensure these tracks are delivered …
August 22, 2015
Requesting the Fanjoy edition of "Breathe In. Breathe Out." by Hilary Duff have 2 additional original songs added.
Final supporters
On May 27th of this year, Hilary Duff announced via Twitter that she was partnering with the Fanjoy company to release a new addition of her album "Breathe In. Breathe Out."
As advertised on HilaryDuff.com, the banner used to promote the package includes the words "Fanjoy Exclusive Bonus Tracks". The Fanjoy website uses
the verbiage "4 Bonus Tracks to Download". This mislead fans to believe
that the 50+ dollar package would be including 4 original songs that
have yet to be released.
On June 9th, Hilary Duff announced via Instagram that the additional tracks would be All About You, Chasing The Sun, Chasing The Sun (Dave Aude Remix) & Outlaw.
Chasing The Sun was released July 29, 2014 to iTunes. All About You was released on August 12, 2014 to iTunes. As both were iTunes releases that fans have had for nearly a year; they are in no way exclusive to Fanjoy.
The Federal Trade Commission states: "When
consumers see or hear an advertisement, whether it’s on the Internet,
radio or television, or anywhere else, federal law says that ad must be
truthful, not misleading, and, when appropriate, backed by scientific
evidence."
We call RCA Records &
FanjoyCo to add two additional bonus tracks to the download card for the
June 16th release of "Breathe In. Breathe out." due to the pretense of
false marketing.
Hilary Duff has recorded
the following songs in which 2 could be selected: 17, Before The Light
Changes, Better Days, Breathing Room, Carry On, Falling, Feel Alive,
Hurts, If I Fall, It All Starts Tonight, Northern Star, Snow Globe, Take
It For What It Is, Tearing Down Walls, This Heart, When We Were Young,
Whistling Dixie, Wherever We Go, Wild Night Out, & Where The Gods
Play.
Please add two additional songs to the Fanjoy edition of "Breathe In. Breathe Out." for its June 16th release. Thank you.
Updates
June 11, 2015
We have reached the two hundred fifty signature threshold. I am currently drafting a formal letter to the Fanjoy corporate office to address the discrepancy in their promotional verbiage.
Reached 250 supporters
June 10, 2015
June 10, 2015
The reach of this petition has shifted our position with Fanjoy representatives. I am now drafting a formal request to address the misleading promotional language regarding the bonus track content. We will leverage this momentum to insist on the inclusion of the two additional original tracks as originally implied.
Reached 100 supporters
June 10, 2015
June 7, 2015
We are currently preparing a formal letter to the Fanjoy team regarding their marketing claims. Reaching the milestone of 250 signatures will provide the necessary evidence to initiate a direct inquiry with their customer relations department.
138 Comments
While I am THRILLED to be finally getting a remix of Chasing the Sun, I do agree that All About You and Chasing the Sun in their original form are not new or exclusive. And as an overseas customer, I have paid $65 for these exclusives. So yeah, I agree we should have 4 EXCLUSIVE tracks, in the vein of Outlaw.
I was expecting at least two new bonus tracks. The remix and Out law is fun, but the other two should be EXCLUSIVE tracks that you would not be able to get anywhere else. "Chasing the Sun" & "All About You" are already owned by most, if not all fans. We want new music! :)
I'm personally disappointed that FanJoy deceived the fans. Although I am excited about the additional items included - it's unfair that they falsely marketed the package to make them profit. Never buying from FanJoy again.
"Feel Alive" Needs to be added! seriously, was there really NO OTHER song choices to add "exclusive bonus tracks"? Shes been out of the music industry for 8 years...there HAS to be something else!
only the real fans are buying the boxset, and real fans have "chasing the sun" and "all about you" already, so what's the point of giving something we already have? If it was a psychical bonus CD I'd love it, but digital downloads of something I already have digitally does simply not worth it!
Please please please! I already own chasing the sun and all about you. This box set cost me $92 due to currency exchange and postage. I don't want to spend $92 for one extra song!!
I would love to hear more of Hilary's music <3 :)
4 promised songs to download. Where are they? Fanjoy should reimburse everyone who ordered the HD exclusive collection $5.
Share this petition
Share this petition to help it reach more people.
Your share link
Petitions like this
Other petitions you might want to support
Scan to share
Anyone who scans this can sign the petition.
While I am THRILLED to be finally getting a remix of Chasing the Sun, I do agree that All About You and Chasing the Sun in their original form are not new or exclusive. And as an overseas customer, I have paid $65 for these exclusives. So yeah, I agree we should have 4 EXCLUSIVE tracks, in the vein of Outlaw.