Sign Petition

Routledge Pro Porn Studies Bias

1,006 Signatures Goal: 800

We understand that Routledge is scheduled to publish a new journal, Porn Studies. While we agree that pornography and porn culture demand and deserve more critical attention, as a group of academics, activists, anti-violence experts, health professionals, and educators, we are deeply concerned about the journal’s intention and focus and about its editorial board, which is uniformly pro-porn.


Routledge is in a position of authority, and framing the editorial "experts" on porn as pro-porn under the auspices of neutrality (which is what the journal title does) further fosters the normalization of porn and misrepresents the academic, political and ideological debates about the issue. The composition of the editorial board (at least thus far) risks marginalizing any critical or anti porn position.

Given this, we have three questions: 1) In what ways and to what extent, if any, will this journal feature essays which represent an array of perspectives on the complex and vexed issues concerning pornography and porn culture?; 2) How likely is it that diverse perspectives will be represented, given that the editorial board has a pro-porn academic record?’ and 3) What might Routledge do to address this bias?

In the interest of academic integrity and thorough critical inquiry, it is imperative that a journal titled Porn Studies creates space for critical analyses of porn from diverse and divergent perspectives. Our hope is that you will change the composition of the editorial board, confirm the journal’s commitment to a heterogeneous interrogation of the issues embedded in porn and porn culture, and ensure that diverse perspectives are represented – on the board and also in the essays published in the journal. Failing that, we ask that you change the name to reflect and make evident the bias of its editors (Pro-Porn Studies) and create another journal which will represent the position of anti-porn scholars and activists and the voices of mental health professionals, porn industry survivors, and feminist scholars whose analyses examine the replication and reification of misogyny, child abuse, and sexual exploitation in mainstream pornography (for instance, Critical Porn Studies).

PLEASE INCLUDE TITLE AND AFFILIATION IN SIGNATURE COMMENTS

Sponsor

Stop Porn Culture and concerned academics

Links

http://stoppornculture.org/
  • Vivien White
    Vivien White Ireland, Dublin
    Nov 25, 2014
    Nov 25, 2014
    I would like to add that journalist regularly and shamelessly promote sex abuse by way of BDSM and parrot only the opinions of abusers and their indoctrinated victims.
    All the time refusing to entertain any of the many genuine concerns about the horrible effects of BDSM on the physical and mental health of men, women and non-binary dominants, submissives, sadists and masochists.
    Clinging onto a single, highly limited and doubeous study as exaggerated evidence of BDSM and positive mental health.
    This anti-intellectual propaganda of contemporary sexual journalism actively promotes sexual abuse and covers it up with obnoxious assertions that anyone who disagrees is narrow-minded.
    The mainstream press, especially in Britian and the USA are warping sex into a vehicle of misogynist dystophia.
    This is what children and adults are being taught is healthy sex.
    These journalists have betrayed the public trust, and should reverse themselves or resign.
  • Zoya Sameen
    Zoya Sameen United States, Manassas
    Oct 03, 2014
    Oct 03, 2014
    Pornographic material merits assessment and study, but this must occur in a critical framework that does not shield or trivialize the very real role played by porn in dehumanizing both its users and participants, and reinforcing rape culture at large.
  • Casey Matter
    Casey Matter United States, Smyrna
    Jun 20, 2014
    Jun 20, 2014
    Porn is a very critical topic of study and discussion, but scientific study is not pure if presented with bias. If Porn is truly to be studied, all perspectives and studies should be included
  • Lane Miller
    Lane Miller United States, Bloomington
    May 10, 2014
    May 10, 2014
    In managing a graduate school bookstore, I have sold many Routledge publications. This journal and its lacking commitment to honest scholastic inquiry throws an entire publishing tradition into question.
See More
891

Signatures

  • 3 months ago
    Camilla Scaramanga
    3 months ago
  • 3 months ago
    Ali Luke
    3 months ago
  • 4 months ago
    Tim Hill
    4 months ago
  • 4 months ago
    A. McGowan
    4 months ago
  • 5 months ago
    Vivien White
    5 months ago
  • 6 months ago
    jim glennon
    6 months ago
  • 7 months ago
    Zoya Sameen
    7 months ago
  • 8 months ago
    Charlotte Mountain
    8 months ago
  • 11 months ago
    Casey Matter
    11 months ago
  • 12 months ago
    Lane Miller
    12 months ago
  • 1 year ago
    myriam forgeron
    1 year ago
  • 1 year ago
    Casey P
    1 year ago
  • 1 year ago
    Jessica Johnston
    1 year ago
  • 1 year ago
    Julie Beard
    1 year ago
  • 1 year ago
    Chiara Carpita
    1 year ago
See More