| # | Name | Comments |
|---|
| 1 | David Cohen | |
| 2 | Shana Karp | |
| 3 | Aaron Wasserman | |
| 4 | Jennifer Ladd | |
| 5 | Julie Veroff | |
| 6 | Ian Bardenstein | |
| 7 | Jessica Galant | |
| 8 | Asya Karchemskaya | |
| 9 | Dean Schaffer | Calling Israel an apartheid state is not only an insult to Israel but a terrible trivialization of the horrors suffered by South African blacks under their apartheid government. |
| 10 | Jason Dunkel | I was appalled by the way SCAI ignored the issue of Palestinian terrorism. Not once in the speech by SCAI's president was the word terrorism mentioned. |
| 11 | Adam Sadovsky | SCAI can only convince the uniformed |
| 12 | Anonymous | |
| 13 | Peter Wroe | |
| 14 | Joshua Weinstein | |
| 15 | Anonymous | |
| 16 | Libby Greismann | |
| 17 | Rebecca Schindel | |
| 18 | Ryan Tracey | |
| 19 | Carl J. Kelm | |
| 20 | Molly Tartter | |
| 21 | Jonathan Laserson | |
| 22 | Chris Seck | |
| 23 | Jessica Blomgarden | |
| 24 | Greg Goldgof | |
| 25 | Arik Motskin | |
| 26 | Adam Kahn | |
| 27 | Elizabeth Burstein | Norman Finkelstein's speech completely ignored the UN Partition Plan of 1947 and the fact that it gave Arabs in Palestine the opportunity to have a state or the first time in history and they REJECTED it. Both the apartheid analogy and the analogy that compares the American occupation of the land of the Native Americans to Israel's creation in 1948 are inaccurate. The Jews are the Native Americans of the land of Israel, not the Palestinians. The Jewish state is a reparation for the millions of organized persecutions that Jews have suffere throughout time--from the pogroms to the Holocaust . Next, look at the countless negotiations that the Israelis have given to promote peace in the region. South African "apartheid" is unique and is only being used to appeal to the layperson's emotion. Without the state of Israel and crucial parts of it, Jews (like myself) will lose all sense of identity because the land was originally the land of the Jews. |
| 28 | Rachel Levy | |
| 29 | Sarah Fremerman Aptilon | |
| 30 | Lexi Shechtel | |
| 31 | Maya Wolpert | |
| 32 | Anonymous | |
| 33 | Amit Taylor | SCAI's arguments are biased and do not represent a reasonable analysis of the situtation in Israel. |
| 34 | Anonymous | |
| 35 | Austen Rosenfeld | |
| 36 | Nicole Demby | |
| 37 | Lisa Cohen | |
| 38 | Art Altman | |
| 39 | Nicholas Reid | |
| 40 | Nicholas Reid | |
| 41 | Aaron Zagory | |
| 42 | Gaby Kohan | |
| 43 | Luukas Ilves | |
| 44 | Emmanuelle B. | |
| 45 | Philip Narodick | |
| 46 | Sasha Buscho | |
| 47 | Anonymous | |
| 48 | Emily Gorbaty | |
| 49 | Jake Wachtel | |
| 50 | Joel Lewenstein | |