Dear Ms. Wade:
It is with much concern that we have come to learn of
actions taken by the administration of Harrison College deeming the twist-out
style often worn by girls and women with non-chemically treated hair as
inappropriate for school. As alumni/ae of Harrison College who are proud of the
institution, the role it has played in our development and the contribution it
continues to make to the growth and education of young people in the region, we
would like to share our thoughts with you on this matter. We hope you will be
open to transparent and democratic discussion, and that if we are at all
mistaken in the facts or our premise, you will kindly clarify.
We speak often of modernized curricula at the secondary
level, and the need to pay attention not just to academic/technical areas of
study, but to the sense of identity that young people develop as students. Part
of this identity is of course the history of their country and region, and
their place in this history. Not just in the Caribbean but wherever young,
Black women live, we are told that our hair is somehow inadequate: it is ‘hard’
or ‘knotty’. It is not straight ‘enough’, although enough for whom or what one
cannot be sure. And where we are kindly allowed to wear our hair naturally as
it grows from our heads, there are caveats: as long as it is pulled back or
braided tight or otherwise tamed. Now let us concede the expectation of a tidy
appearance to accompany a school uniform. But there is nothing inherently
untidy about a twist-out style. In fact, it helps keep strands of hair in
place, where otherwise they may have blown about. It is no different from a
simple afro, unless this too is considered too distracting for school. Among
our primary concerns is the message being sent to young women of African
heritage in this country that their natural selves are of necessity untidy, unsuitable
or otherwise inadequate.
A further concern relates to the overemphasis being placed on
appearance in general. How one wears one’s uniform is, or at least should be, a
minimum condition for entering school and participating in classes and other
activities: as long as one appears reasonably kempt, this should be sufficient
to proceed. It should not be so important as to overtake all other considerations,
such as academic achievement (for which attendance at class is a necessary
input), sporting success, socialization and social interaction, and personal
empowerment and development. That a student should agonize over his/her own
simple, natural hairstyle in order to satisfy some wholly artificial and
arbitrary notion of what is tidy or suitable is a miscarriage of educational
authority and a misunderstanding of the purpose of rules and discipline. The
latter are not meant to micromanage personal decisions and to stifle pride and
creativity, but to provide a framework within which students can make
intelligent choices, and can relate to their colleagues, faculty and other
staff.
The argument that “students can do whatever they like once
they enter the real world, but this is school” also misunderstands the role of formal
education and the process of young people’s development. School is the real
world. Young people are understanding themselves and their environment, and while
becoming who they will be, they also are. They are real, valid human beings
with thoughts and ideas to express. They are not drones, not soldiers, and
attempting to make them so suggests a lazy, outdated approach to discipline
which we are sure does not obtain at Harrison College.
In short, we feel that this needless condemnation of a style of
wearing one’s natural hair is harmful and communicates a dangerous message not
just to the students and parents of the school, but to the community and the
country’s young people. We encourage you to rethink this position, and remain
at your service to continue this discussion.
Signed
It's hard to see what is wrong with wearing hear in a natural style, and to avoid chemical treatment of hair should be an obvious good. I am therefore in sympathy with the respectful appeal to the Principal. (B.D. Hoyos, Barbados Scholar 1963)