Signatures 765 total
-
1
Name: CS Prakash on Sep 23, 2012Comments: Please release the data so that the scientific community can independently evaluate the resultsFlag
-
2
Name: Biradar S S on Sep 23, 2012Comments: It's very unfortunate that such foolish studies are being accepted and published in reputed journals. It spreads wrong message to the public. Make every raw data accessible to public soonFlag
-
3
Name: Gyanendra Shukla on Sep 23, 2012Comments: Any scientist of repute with credbile work should not hesitatre sharing data.Flag
-
4
Name: David Tribe on Sep 23, 2012Comments: experimental design need to clarified and claims need objective test of statistical significanceFlag
-
5
Name: Prof. Dr. Klaus-Dieter Jany on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
6
Name: Lucia De Souza on Sep 23, 2012Comments: Transparency is a key element of sound scienceFlag
-
7
Name: Professor Malcolm Elliott on Sep 23, 2012Comments: These data must be released.Flag
-
8
Name: Piero Morandini on Sep 23, 2012Comments: Assistant prof. in Plant PhysiologyFlag
-
9
Name: Margit Laimer on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
10
Name: Thomas R. DeGregori on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
11
Name: Professor Maurice Moloney on Sep 23, 2012Comments: Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. It would help the entire community to have an ndependent assessment of these dataFlag
-
12
Name: Anonymous on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
13
Name: Dr Ian B. Edwards on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
14
Name: Prof Swapan Datta on Sep 23, 2012Comments: scientific truth is necessaryFlag
-
15
Name: Piet Van Der Meer on Sep 23, 2012Comments: The general principle of transparency is not only widely accepted in the scientific community, it is also galvanised in, for example, the Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety, which stipulates that risk assessment “should be carried out in a scientifically sound and transparent manner”. Key in such transparency is that the data and methods are sufficiently detailed and clear to allow independent verification and reproduction.Flag
-
16
Name: Dr. Shanthu Shantharam on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
17
Name: Dr. Felix M'mboyi on Sep 23, 2012Comments: Please release your data for scientific scrutiny. Your paper has generated significant interest in the biotech community. We in Africa are keen to have access to your data.Flag
-
18
Name: Alan McHughen on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
19
Name: Balasubramanian Ponnuswami on Sep 23, 2012Comments: Bad sience is disastrous.Flag
-
20
Name: Flavio Finardi on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
21
Name: A. M. Shelton, Ph.D. on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
22
Name: Winston Clive James on Sep 23, 2012Comments: I am in full agrrement with the petitionFlag
-
23
Name: Prof. Jonathan Gressel on Sep 23, 2012Comments: These data should be made available to EFSA, the most competent authority in Europe who an evaluate them.Flag
-
24
Name: Atanas Ivanov Atanassov on Sep 23, 2012Comments: Although less the control mice also died. It is too bad to be true.Flag
-
25
Name: Keith Goulding on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
26
Name: Jane Morris on Sep 23, 2012Comments: Coming from the developing world where not only food is in short supply but also ther is a shortage of scientists able to critically evaluate your work, you should consider the implications of your study I terms of food security in Africa.Flag
-
27
Name: Ernesto Bustamante, PhD on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
28
Name: Camille Ryan on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
29
Name: Erik Murchie on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
30
Name: L. Val Giddings, Ph.D. on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
31
Name: Klaus Ammann on Sep 23, 2012Comments: It should be scientific standard to release the original data. It is always possible to give supporting data on the web, It is ovvious that Mr. Seralini is afraid that the data are not consistent with his conclusions.Flag
-
32
Name: Robert Wager on Sep 23, 2012Comments: This is another example of pseudo-science that must be exposed to the world.Flag
-
33
Name: Bruce Chassy on Sep 23, 2012Comments: The code of scientific ethics requires that all scientists release all the data associated with a peer-reviewed scientific paper. When authors submit papers to journals they agree to this policy.Flag
-
34
Name: Prof Lin Field on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
35
Name: Professor C J Leaver FRS on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
36
Name: Wayne Parrott on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
37
Name: Francisco J. L. Aragão on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
38
Name: Anonymous on Sep 23, 2012Comments: Please release all the dataFlag
-
39
Name: Prof. Dr Andreas Graner on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
40
Name: Dr. Eitan Israeli on Sep 23, 2012Comments: Show your data! Are you Chiken?Flag
-
41
Name: Robert Paarlberg on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
42
Name: Jeroen Crappé on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
43
Name: Jonathon Harrington on Sep 23, 2012Comments: How can any serious scientist evaluate your studies without seeing the data? I simply do not understand why you will not publish it. Please release it for us to study immediately.Flag
-
44
Name:
Graham Strouts on Sep 23, 2012
Comments:Flag -
45
Name: Josef Glössl on Sep 23, 2012Comments: Dr. Séralini, I urgently ask you to release all data relevant to make a sound judgement of your paper:Flag
-
46
Name: Katrijn Van Huffel on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
47
Name: Dr Jing-Jiang Zhou on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
48
Name: Klaas Mensaert on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
49
Name: Klaas Mensaert on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag
-
50
Name: Leandro Astarita on Sep 23, 2012Comments:Flag