MBA application , Rejection Feedback Request

Signatures 52 total

Page: 1, 2

1. 1
   Name: Boni Gopalan on Feb 13, 2007

   Comments:

   Flag
2. 2
   Name: Anonymous on Feb 13, 2007

   Comments:

   Flag
3. 3
   Name: Anonymous on Feb 13, 2007

   Comments:

   Flag
4. 4
   Name: Anonymous on Feb 13, 2007

   Comments:

   Flag
5. 5
   Name: Anonymous on Feb 13, 2007

   Comments:

   Flag
6. 6
   Name: Anonymous on Feb 13, 2007

   Comments: I received a ding from Michigan without any explanation after being invited for an interview. Spending 400 dollars on my ride to Michigan and interviewing with an admissions committee student member, spending 200 dollars on my application fee, and more than month of working hard on my application which in the end left me quite less time to work on my CFA exam which I obviously failed for the lack of time, atleast demands a reasoning from the AdCom on my rejection.

   Flag
7. 7
   Name: Petra Romanowicz on Feb 13, 2007

   Comments:

   Flag
8. 8
   Name: Dirk Diggler on Feb 13, 2007

   Comments:

   Flag
9. 9
   Name: Anonymous on Feb 13, 2007

   Comments: Fantastic initiative. I got dinged by Kellogg. Waiting for their feedback session. The ding letter was very generic.

   Flag
10. 10
    Name: Anonymous on Feb 13, 2007

    Comments: Fantastic initiative. I got dinged by Kellogg. Waiting for their feedback session. The ding letter was very generic.

    Flag
11. 11
    Name: SC on Feb 14, 2007

    Comments: Was dinged at Yale without any information given. Just a two paragraph saying that they had dinged me. No information at all, quite unhappy. Yale seems to lack transparency

    Flag
12. 12
    Name: Siddhartha Gupta on Feb 14, 2007

    Comments:

    Flag
13. 13
    Name: Boni on Feb 14, 2007

    Comments:

    Flag
14. 14
    Name: Ratnaditya on Feb 14, 2007

    Comments:

    Flag
15. 15
    Name: Anonymous on Feb 14, 2007

    Comments: I was dinged at HBS without interview. I though I was a competitive applicant, but I guess I was wrong. I have spent nearly a year, analyzing and writing my essays. All I got is a one sentence rejection notification! I wonder why it costs $245.

    Flag
16. 16
    Name: Anonymous on Feb 14, 2007

    Comments:

    Flag
17. 17
    Name: Sachit Kamat on Feb 14, 2007

    Comments: I support this cause. Schools should be more accountable for denials than they currently are. They need to provide denied applicants with basic personalized feedback at the very least.

    Flag
18. 18
    Name: Ding Gul-Berry on Feb 14, 2007

    Comments:

    Flag
19. 19
    Name: Anonymous on Feb 14, 2007

    Comments: Dinged by Kellogg

    Flag
20. 20
    Name: Xinzhang Sha on Feb 15, 2007

    Comments: Dinged by Chicago, Columbia and wharton. Quite upset and desperate.

    Flag
21. 21
    Name: Anonymous on Feb 15, 2007

    Comments:

    Flag
22. 22
    Name: Anonymous on Feb 15, 2007

    Comments:

    Flag
23. 23
    Name: Vinisha on Feb 15, 2007

    Comments: I think we should at least be told why!

    Flag
24. 24
    Name: Rohit on Feb 16, 2007

    Comments: I think it makes sense to provide some reasoning in the ding letter.

    Flag
25. 25
    Name: Anonymous on Feb 16, 2007

    Comments: At the minimum they shd check the boxes with standard options with areas of improvement - Quality of essays, GMAT, WE, Leadership, Comm Service, etc

    Flag
26. 26
    Name: Anonymous on Feb 16, 2007

    Comments: This petition is poorly written. If you want adcoms to take you seriously rewrite this petition and avoid using words like "lame."

    Flag
27. 27
    Name: Sumit on Feb 16, 2007

    Comments: After going through the gruelling admission process not to mention the time, money and mental agony, it is fair on the applicants side to get a feedback

    Flag
28. 28
    Name: Anonymous on Feb 16, 2007

    Comments: For all the effort, this seems well-earned and practical.

    Flag
29. 29
    Name: Anon on Feb 16, 2007

    Comments: Business Schools spend so much time assuring us that the admisison process is transparent..should 'walk the talk' .

    Flag
30. 30
    Name: Anonymous on Feb 17, 2007

    Comments:

    Flag
31. 31
    Name: Anonymous on Feb 17, 2007

    Comments: One of my friends applied... had excellent credentials was still rejected without an interview call. The b schools should definitely send out personalized mails informing why the application was rejected.

    Flag
32. 32
    Name: Anonymous on Feb 17, 2007

    Comments: The feedback will really help in answering lot of questions that one asks to himself/herself after a ding letter. Finding out wrong reasons by own's analysis is worst for anyone planning to re-apply.

    Flag
33. 33
    Name: Dinged_alien on Feb 18, 2007

    Comments: Cornell dinged me and refuses even to give feedback ! How am I supposed to improve my app for next year (if I decide to re-apply)

    Flag
34. 34
    Name: Mohnish on Feb 19, 2007

    Comments:

    Flag
35. 35
    Name: Ram Kumar on Feb 20, 2007

    Comments:

    Flag
36. 36
    Name: Anonymous on Feb 24, 2007

    Comments:

    Flag
37. 37
    Name: Anonymous on Mar 30, 2007

    Comments:

    Flag
38. 38
    Name: Anonymous on Apr 9, 2007

    Comments: Dinged at CBS an NYU

    Flag
39. 39
    Name: Anonymous on Jun 25, 2007

    Comments: Dinged but could not recieve feedback from cornell johnson, Michigan Ross, and UCLA Anderson

    Flag
40. 40
    Name: Anonymous on Jun 25, 2007

    Comments: Dinged but could not recieve feedback from cornell johnson, Michigan Ross, and UCLA Anderson

    Flag
41. 41
    Name: Anonymous on Oct 10, 2007

    Comments:

    Flag
42. 42
    Name: Rakesh Sharma on Nov 16, 2007

    Comments: Yes, I completed agree with your suggestion.

    Flag
43. 43
    Name: Maddunr on Feb 29, 2008

    Comments:

    Flag
44. 44
    Name: Anonymous on Mar 26, 2008

    Comments: I was dinged by HBS and Wharton. I don't feel the feedbacks provided by the B-schools are sufficient. This is a great initiative.

    Flag
45. 45
    Name: Sanik on Jul 7, 2008

    Comments:

    Flag
46. 46
    Name: Hfkwlcu on Mar 16, 2010

    Comments:

    Flag
47. 47
    Name: Anonymous on Mar 29, 2010

    Comments: Rejected from Darden school of business after on campus interview. No letter was sent, just an email stating my decision was rendered and an url to log into. The message at the top of the screen ( after going to the URL ) was the following: Your Application MBA: After careful consideration, the Admissions Committee regrets to inform you that you are not offered admission to the Darden School MBA program. If you are interested in receiving feedback on your application, please contact our office after June 1. We greatly appreciate your taking the time to apply to Darden. Thank you very much for your interest in the Darden School. We wish you great success in pursuing graduate management study and in your future career. nice

    Flag
48. 48
    Name: Anonymous on May 16, 2010

    Comments:

    Flag
49. 49
    Name: Anubhuti on Dec 30, 2010

    Comments: I completely agree with your point.

    Flag
50. 50
    Name: Anonymous on Feb 9, 2011

    Comments: I completely agree with the petition. We really put in a lot of effort on the application but are never told the reason of the rejection.

    Flag

Page: 1, 2