| # | Name | Comments |
|---|
| 1 | Kelly Graves | Either she's real or she's not: let's find out! |
| 2 | Phil Plait | |
| 3 | Jay Graham | heard about it from BA |
| 4 | joedog | |
| 5 | John Armstrong | |
| 6 | Will Hustedde | |
| 7 | Charles Walker | If you say you're going to do something, you should do it. If you don't need the money, perhaps you could give it to me? (Or maybe charity). Of course, that assumes that you can truly do what you say, which is unlikely. |
| 8 | Mark Schnitzius | C'mon! Show him what you're made of! |
| 9 | Deja Gateward | |
| 10 | Jon Harmon | |
| 11 | Detlev Noll | |
| 12 | Max Fagin | |
| 13 | Steve Plegge | |
| 14 | C. Kew | |
| 15 | mike h | |
| 16 | Keith Barber | |
| 17 | George L Smyth | |
| 18 | Robert "trebob" Tallent | |
| 19 | Simon Walls | |
| 20 | Steven Novella | |
| 21 | Vernon Balbert | |
| 22 | Anonymous | Sylvia, you can stop all the doubters now by taking this test. Prove that you're for real!
Unless ... no, it couldn't be! Could it be that you're a charlatan who preys on the weak and grieving? |
| 23 | Rachael Acks | |
| 24 | Joshua Brader | If you really believe in yourself why wouldn't you take an easy million dollars? |
| 25 | Troy Heck | Take the test. Even after you are exposed you'll still have a career. You can whine about how it was unfair. |
| 26 | Shane Baxter | *expletives deleted* |
| 27 | Jane Shevtsov | |
| 28 | Jason Schwab | There was a time when a person's word was worth more than $1 million... |
| 29 | Anonymous | It's so obvious that she is fake. |
| 30 | Dr. John Keller | |
| 31 | Israel Wasserstein | |
| 32 | James Maehling | If, as you claim, are a psychic, what's another million dollars in your bank account? Just walking around money for you, I'm sure. Besides, it would make James Randi promote you as the genuine article. |
| 33 | Barry Jelbert | |
| 34 | Jim Penny | |
| 35 | Mike Tice | My own psychic powers foresee the outcome of this petition. I signed it anyway. |
| 36 | Dave | Take the test! |
| 37 | Michelle Rochon | |
| 38 | Lawrence | |
| 39 | Zebanya Rice | I wish they would once and for all prove that all psychic phenomenon were real so I can stop rolling my eyes and chuckling at people who say they are psychic. |
| 40 | Anonymous | |
| 41 | Ray Mansell | |
| 42 | Anonymous | |
| 43 | Barbara Dwyer | Her psychic powers allow her to see the outcome of the test... |
| 44 | Tristan Schwartz | Stop being a namsy-pansy and do what you promised to do. |
| 45 | Bob Allee | Hey Sylvia
Please prove us wrong or quit extorting from people. |
| 46 | Ryan Pulis | |
| 47 | Mike Baker | |
| 48 | Craig Rohloff | |
| 49 | David Fairweather | |
| 50 | Paul Hutchinson | We need to know! |