Skip to main content

Status: Closed — this petition is no longer accepting signatures.

Trial period for the new CH Rov.

Trial period for the new CH Rov.

Closed — 28 supporters Verified

Final supporters

R
rsgkkldoto
S
Someone
S
Someone
S
Someone
Y
yankel t.
S
Someone
Y
Yosef E.
K
Kaker
S
Someone
A
axel h.
+18 more
Started by Anonymous 15 years, 11 months ago
Change we can believe in. Remember that slogan? Just two years later and we have no change. Nor is there much belief left either. BUT - we still have two years to go.

Now imagine we had elected our President for life. I'd have packed my bags and found a new nationality already. Yet that is exactly what we are about to do here in our shechunah; elect an unknown candidate running on a populist platform for a fresh leaf and a new tomorrow. As if we've already forgotten how that worked out last time. But this time, the outcome will be permanent.

I have no bias or preference for any candidate. But I am afraid. Terrified actually, because we are ready to elect an unknown candidate to a lifetime position. Why? What's the rush? Are we compulsive gamblers - we only play all or nothing? Why can't we have a tryout period? I think the rational thing to do is to elect a Rov for a three year trial period, at the end of which we can hold a referendum; whether to confirm the elected Rov for life, or to find another one who can deliver. When I got married I dated till I knew I was making the right choice. I didn't just go along with "change I could believe in." This is the same thing. It's a lifetime decision. And we only have one chance to do it right.

Usually, the custom by Jewish communities had been to elect permanent Rabbonim. But this not a usual case. Two of three candidates are neither well know, nor local. If we are going to elect them for life, we need a chance to know who they are.

I care. As Crown Heights residents, we have a right and responsibility to protect our future. Please sign our petition to Rabbi Rosenberg for the sake of our community.

Updates

September 2, 2010

I have been hearing from so many neighbors who are just as nervous about this lifetime appointment as I am because it feels like we are jumping off a cliff without checking the depth of the water first. People keep asking me why we are not demanding a trial period when that is obviously the only way to avoid a disaster if the candidate is not a good fit for us. I am drafting a letter to the board tonight to demand they pause and consider a referendum before we commit to something we cannot take back later.

September 2, 2010

I honestly did not think this would gain any traction at all when I started typing this out in a fit of frustration late at night. Seeing the momentum shift and realizing others are just as anxious about these lifetime appointments is honestly surreal. Maybe people are actually tired of the all or nothing approach after all.

3 Comments

A
Avi Schmidt
15 years ago Featured

This is so true. We need a trial period for something this big. It would stop so many headaches later on.

M
Mendel Lowe
15 years ago Featured

Whatever happened to common sense. 3 years is plenty of time to see if its a good fit. dont rush into a mistake.

S
Sarah Singh
15 years ago Featured

YES. No one hires an employee for life without knowing how they work. Why would we do this with a Rov?? Makes no sense.

Share Petition

Don't stop at signing, share the petition link with friends to multiply our impact

Copy link or share directly

Instagram
QR Code