| # | Name | Comments |
|---|
| 1 | Edward Feser | Pasadena City College, Pasadena, CA |
| 2 | Lydia McGrew | |
| 3 | Timothy McGrew | Western Michigan University |
| 4 | James G. Hanink | |
| 5 | Francis J. Beckwith | Baylor University |
| 6 | W. David Beck | |
| 7 | Christopher Anadale | Conception Seminary College |
| 8 | roger scruton | |
| 9 | Sarah Borden | Wheaton College |
| 10 | William Lane Craig | |
| 11 | Robert C. Koons | |
| 12 | Ann Hartle | |
| 13 | Jeffrey Koperski | |
| 14 | Christopher Kaczor, Ph.D. | |
| 15 | Daniel Bonevac | |
| 16 | John DePoe | University of Iowa |
| 17 | Paul Copan, Ph.D. | |
| 18 | Isaac D. True, Ph.D. | |
| 19 | James Stump | |
| 20 | C Stephen Evans | |
| 21 | Ronald K Tacelli | |
| 22 | Jim Spiegel | |
| 23 | Anonymous | The APA should reject the petition in question and maintain it current practice without alteration. |
| 24 | Michael Beaty | |
| 25 | Anthony McCarthy | |
| 26 | Victor Reppert | |
| 27 | David Bradshaw | |
| 28 | Michael P. Foley | |
| 29 | William A. Dembski | |
| 30 | Steven B. Cowan | |
| 31 | Michael L. Peterson | I wholeheartedly support the petition |
| 32 | Giuseppe Butera | |
| 33 | Anonymous | University of Iowa |
| 34 | Theodore P. Rebard | |
| 35 | Mary C. Sommers | University of St. Thomas (Houston) |
| 36 | Kevin Diller | University of Notre Dame (fellow) |
| 37 | Gregory Koukl | M.A. Philosophy, Talbot School of Theology 2006 |
| 38 | Alvin Plantinga | |
| 39 | Alasdair MacIntyre | |
| 40 | Anonymous | |
| 41 | Anonymous | |
| 42 | Anonymous | |
| 43 | J. Budziszewski | Affiliation: Departments of Government and Philosophy, University of Texas at Austin |
| 44 | Anonymous | Sex is identity and destiny? Two young homosexual committed Christians, Eve Tushnet and John Heard, with their understanding of love and sex, put those APA activists to shame. |
| 45 | Michael Garcia | |
| 46 | Anonymous | The APA is open and pluralist, the opposing view discriminatory. |
| 47 | Lukáš Novák | I am an assistant professor of philosophy at the Faculty of Arts and Philosophy, Charles University, Prague, and at the Faculty of Theology, University of Southern Bohemia, Budweis (Czech Republic). |
| 48 | Dr. Andrew Beards | Reader and Director of Philosophy Programmes,
Maryvale Institute, Birmingham UK |
| 49 | Tully Borland | Ouachita Baptist University |
| 50 | Bradley L. Sickler |