| # | Name | Comments |
|---|
| 1401 | Anonymous | We want Peter Jackson |
| 1402 | Anna Stricker | |
| 1403 | Joey Holt | |
| 1404 | Anonymous | |
| 1405 | Anonymous | no one, i repeat, NO ONE could possibly make a decent version of the Hobbit without PJ, Fran, and all the rest.
there is a large army of fans who WILL NOT accept this decision, as i am sure this petition will illustrate.
Please remove your heads from your wallets and look into our eyes. We are the souls of Middle Earth, and we do not accept this decision. |
| 1406 | Sam Roth | |
| 1407 | Leon Lampret | For christs sake, are you nuts, there can be NO HOBBIT WITHOUT PJ. Bring the man back, he is THE man, the only one who can make it work.
Make the Hobbit happen for the sake of the fans (and it'll bring a lot of $$) and bring back Peter Jackson.
Leon |
| 1408 | Anonymous | Peter Jackson made Newline millions of dollars with the Lord of the Rings Trilogy and is the only reason vital actors like Ian McKellen, Ian Holm, and Hugo Weaving will return. Without these actors, the continuity(sp) of the Tolkien films will collapse. |
| 1409 | Anonymous | |
| 1410 | Anonymous | |
| 1411 | David | the Hobbit would truly suck if Peter Jackson didn't direct it. |
| 1412 | Leo Belisle | I though Peter Jackson did a wonderful job adapting the LOTR trilogy, and would do a wonderful job adapting The Hobbit to film given the chance. |
| 1413 | james joyce | they shouldnt make a hobbit film without pj . |
| 1414 | Virginia | |
| 1415 | freakinfrodo | i will kill you all with aids if peter jackson dosent get to do the hobbit. |
| 1416 | Anonymous | |
| 1417 | Anonymous | |
| 1418 | Monica Kirilenko | Mr. Peter Jackson did an excellent job of The Lord of the Rings films and I would very much like Peter Jackson to direct The Hobbit film. I am outraged that New Line is even considering about getting anyone else than Mr. Jackson. I firmly believe that without Mr. Jackson's visionary artistic nature that Hobbit film will fail. I for one will never lay eyes on the film if it is not done by Mr. Jackson. I hope to God that he directs the film along with everyone else that had a part in The Lord of the Rings such as Ian Holme, Ian McKellen, Andy Serkis and Howard Shore to name a few. I am a huge fan of Mr. Jackson and New Line for that matter and will never see a New Line film again. Mr. Jackson is the only man for the director and I, and every other Hobbit fan will be outraged if he is not directing it. Please get Mr. Jackson to direct the film. |
| 1419 | Monica Kirilenko | Mr. Peter Jackson did an excellent job of The Lord of the Rings films and I would very much like Peter Jackson to direct The Hobbit film. I am outraged that New Line is even considering about getting anyone else than Mr. Jackson. I firmly believe that without Mr. Jackson's visionary artistic nature that Hobbit film will fail. I for one will never lay eyes on the film if it is not done by Mr. Jackson. I hope to God that he directs the film along with everyone else that had a part in The Lord of the Rings such as Ian Holme, Ian McKellen, Andy Serkis and Howard Shore to name a few. I am a huge fan of Mr. Jackson and New Line for that matter and will never see a New Line film again. Mr. Jackson is the only man for the director and I, and every other Hobbit fan will be outraged if he is not directing it. Please get Mr. Jackson to direct the film. |
| 1420 | Monica Kirilenko | Mr. Peter Jackson did an excellent job of The Lord of the Rings films and I would very much like Peter Jackson to direct The Hobbit film. I am outraged that New Line is even considering about getting anyone else than Mr. Jackson. I firmly believe that without Mr. Jackson's visionary artistic nature that Hobbit film will fail. I for one will never lay eyes on the film if it is not done by Mr. Jackson. I hope to God that he directs the film along with everyone else that had a part in The Lord of the Rings such as Ian Holme, Ian McKellen, Andy Serkis and Howard Shore to name a few. I am a huge fan of Mr. Jackson and New Line for that matter and will never see a New Line film again. Mr. Jackson is the only man for the director and I, and every other Hobbit fan will be outraged if he is not directing it. Please get Mr. Jackson to direct the film. |
| 1421 | Lars | PJ did an excellent job with LotR, so why not have him continue and make a splendid film of The Hobbit? Anyone else will probably screw it up anyway. |
| 1422 | Anonymous | |
| 1423 | Mark | |
| 1424 | Gemma Butterworth | How can they even think of letting anybody other than PJ direct this?! |
| 1425 | Anonymous | |
| 1426 | Anonymous | Cmon guys - this is silly!
JUST DO IT RIGHT! And Right means WITH Peter Jackson!!! |
| 1427 | Tom | I have not read any of the LOTR books but I am a big movie fan and have seen the entire trilogy (extended version is the only way to go!) and I truly believe Peter Jackson's passion for his creations plus the production team's talent are the ONLY things that should be considered when making a movie from such an epic story. budgets and the amount of money made during the making of a movie shouldn't be in the minds of the people making said movie as they hinder real quality. |
| 1428 | David | How can they ditch Peter Jackson for christ sake look how well he did with the LOTR films a record breaking amount of oscars for ROTK and has Grossed billions worldwide and then they go get rid of him? i dont really want to see it if its directed by some one else! |
| 1429 | ravie | |
| 1430 | James Clancy | |
| 1431 | Anonymous | Peter Jackson is the only one who could make The Hobbit into an amazing film. He SHOULD be the one to do it. |
| 1432 | Anonymous | No PJ. No Hobbit |
| 1433 | Erin | LOTR has been out for 6 years or so. I just recently had the pleasure of watching all 3. With this in mind, I do not think The Hobbit should be directed by anyone except by Peter Jackson! Thank you, this is all. |
| 1434 | Scott Qualls | Won't see it unless Jackson does it! |
| 1435 | Anonymous | peter!!!!! |
| 1436 | Sergei Kolobashkin | No PJ - No Hobbit! |
| 1437 | Anonymous | Disgraceful. Without Peter Jackson there would be no sequel (The Hobbit) to make as the great LOTR Trilogy may never have been made. Surely they realise that without PJ and his tireless team of Tolkienists involvement in finishing the saga it could just become yet another pointless sequel made merely to cash in on the glories of the earlier LOTR films rather than giving proper justice to the magical novel that is "The Hobbit" and to Bilbo Baggins the orginal ring barer. |
| 1438 | Anonymous | |
| 1439 | GIna | Peter Jackson will make this movie the best! |
| 1440 | Jason Lopez | |
| 1441 | alexa smiley | PJ! PJ! PJ! PJ! PJ! PJ! PJ! PJ! PJ! PJ! PJ! PJ! PJ! PJ! PJ! PJ! PJ! PJ! PJ! PJ! PJ! PJ! PJ! PJ! |
| 1442 | Rodger Ashton-Smith | I would like to see Peter Jackson direct the movie of The Hobbit. He is a very good person and can make a great movie. |
| 1443 | Christian Chandler | Without PJ, well its just wrong, I will neither watch nor purchase a new line film till this mess is fixed. |
| 1444 | Rebecca Dawn Shupe | I'm sure it's a bit late, but I want my say in this, too. You NEW LINE-rs are really stupid if you think that "The Hobbit" or any other "Lord of the Rings" style movie will have any quality if it comes from the minds of anyone other than Peter Jackson, Fran Walsh or Wingnut films. |
| 1445 | Anonymous | |
| 1446 | Anonymous | |
| 1447 | Jonathon Spafford | Go Peter!!!!!!!!!!!!!! |
| 1448 | David Overlin | |
| 1449 | Anonymous | |
| 1450 | Charae | Peter Jackson did a wonderful job on the trilogy!! He did more than just direct the films, he put himself into them. The Hobbit would be a failure without his direction. |