| # | Name | Comments |
|---|
| 1251 | Grainne Gillespie | If Peter Jackson isn't allowed to direct, what are the chances that Ian McKellen, Ian Holm and Hugo Weaving won't reprise their roles from LOTR? If they walk in protest there's no way in frell I'm watching The Hobbit in the cinema or buying the DVD, I'll just wait until it comes out on Channel 4 |
| 1252 | Grainne Gillespie | If Peter Jackson isn't allowed to direct, what are the chances that Ian McKellen, Ian Holm and Hugo Weaving won't reprise their roles from LOTR? If they walk in protest there's no way in frell I'm watching The Hobbit in the cinema or buying the DVD, I'll just wait until it comes out on Channel 4 |
| 1253 | Carol Cain | I think Peter Jackson and the same people who made LOTR should be the ONLY ones making The Hobbit, and any other films concerned with this. THey have the necessary passion for this project, and I don't think it will be NEARLY as good if you deny the chance to Peter. |
| 1254 | Anonymous | Peter Jackson is the only person that I would even consider for this project. I can't imagine this movie w/out him. |
| 1255 | Cailyn | AH! not cool, it won't make any sense to have a different director from the one who already did such a good job on the trilogy... |
| 1256 | Joshua McKnight | Here's to the internet preventing the dumbest mistake in movie history. |
| 1257 | Jonas Ruud | PJ MUST make this film |
| 1258 | Carlton | No P.J, no hobbit. |
| 1259 | Dylan | Let's face it-these stories are not the same with Mr. Jackson's incredible direction. |
| 1260 | Clinton Meade | |
| 1261 | Petri Ranta | |
| 1262 | Mary Curtis | |
| 1263 | Anonymous | I won't see it if Peter Jackson isn't involved. |
| 1264 | CryssieWillow | think again, people at New Line! |
| 1265 | Balrog1987 | Necesitamos a Peter Jackson para dirigir "El Hobbit" y la precuela porque como fan que soy estoy seguro de que es la persona adecuada para recoger toda la esencia de Tolkien necesaria pra realizar las peliculas. |
| 1266 | Abby Hersh | New Line will never receive another cent from me as long as I live if Peter Jackson and his team aren't allowed to make The Hobbit! They cannot be replaced! |
| 1267 | Ilde | Peter, lucha por cumplir otro de tus sueños, que es continuar viviendo por una de tus ilusiones: No abandonar a Tolkien, ni abandonarnos a todos nosotros, que te apoyamos, y apoyamos al Señor de los Anillos y la Tierra Media. Estamos contigo!! |
| 1268 | ashley harris | |
| 1269 | Lara Hays | The so-called "decision" of whether or not to involve Peter Jackson and his creative team in the creation of the prequels is obscenely ridiculous. It is a no-brainer, and a decision isn't necessary. He tamed the LOTR beast, and another master will not do it justice. |
| 1270 | Gabi C. | |
| 1271 | John | New Line Cinema, you should be ASHAMED of yourself! Blacklisting Peter Jackson like that!
You are all acting like a bunch of spoiled children that can't get his or her own way! Fine, don't hire Peter Jackson!! I'll just sit back and watch PJ successfully direct The Hobbit with another company while you guys stand penniless, weeping in the dark because of all the money you've lost from fans and you're foolish mistakes.
I am a proud supporter of Peter Jackson. |
| 1272 | Andy Northern | |
| 1273 | Anonymous | |
| 1274 | Anonymous | |
| 1275 | Darryl Baker | This is wrong. |
| 1276 | Darryl Baker | This is wrong. |
| 1277 | Darryl Baker | This is wrong. |
| 1278 | Polaja | Please reconsider what you are doing!!
Save the other arguments for later, don't let them get in the way of producing an awesome movie!
Pol |
| 1279 | Andrea | I am disgusted to know that New Line would even consider making 'The Hobbit' without Peter Jackson at the helm! With his wonderful interpretation of the 'Lord of the Rings', there should be no doubt as to who should direct the prequel. I can't believe New Line's arrogance. Are they completely deaf to the voice of the fans, who want to see PJ direct the Hobbit? |
| 1280 | Anonymous | STUPIDASS FAGGOT NEWLINE PRESIDENT PERSON SUCK DICK |
| 1281 | E. van Abeelen | |
| 1282 | Anonymous | |
| 1283 | Heather | Its not The Hobbit With out Pete! I hope he makes it!! |
| 1284 | Anonymous | |
| 1285 | Shawn | He should deffently make The Hobbit...He did a GREAT job on The Lord of the RIngs... |
| 1286 | Jenn | |
| 1287 | Seth Kellogg | No Peter. No money to new line. |
| 1288 | Kike | Quiero dar mi apoyo a Peter, sin él, "El Hobbit" nunca llegará al nivel que consiguió con "El Señor de los Anillos". Sólo deseo que el Sr. Shaye reconsidere su postura y se llegue a un acuerdo por el bien de todos. |
| 1289 | matthew heath | do it properly or don't bother |
| 1290 | Anonymous | Please Please |
| 1291 | Shawn Barner | Without PJ directing, The Hobbit will never truly get shown on the Big Screen as it should. He is the ONLY director for this job! |
| 1292 | Anonymous | |
| 1293 | Athena | |
| 1294 | Anonymous | If Peter does not direct -I will not spend any money on anything 'Hobbit'. |
| 1295 | Mr Thau | I think that the Hobbit should be made in CGI.
With CGI villains.
I can create CGI villains rule Middle Earth scene. In CGI. Please try to do it Mr Jackson. |
| 1296 | Ryan | No PJ, no LOTR cast, then no ticket purchase for me. |
| 1297 | Anonymous | Please, please, please let Peter Jackson finish the tale of our favorite (one of our favorite) hobbit's adventure. Ring fans long for Bilbo's tale to be paved by Peter Jackson. No one else will DO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! |
| 1298 | Anonymous | No one will be able to top Peter Jackson and his group. Reconsider! |
| 1299 | Anonymous | Whatever problems you guys have had, I think it'd be a shame to have THE HOBBIT directed by anyone other than Peter Jackson. |
| 1300 | Doug Springs | Hey dummies - it's the art that counts. Thinking anyone else could direct the Hobbit is like thinking anyone else could have painted the Mona Lisa. Dumb ass bottom liners! |