| # | Name | Comments |
|---|
| 1601 | Kim Ekberg | Carson Beckett was the best character to grace the screen in Atlantis!!! PLEASE bring him back!!! |
| 1602 | Kayla Baboolal | I still don't get why Carson was written off. Of the amazing actor who portrays this character made the decision, then I respect it and wish him well, but if he was written off for any other reason, it was a poor decision that needs to be reversed. He was the healing warrior who without a weapon put his life on the line for all, and the show needs a character with that kind of heart. |
| 1603 | Willianne Perik | Carson is the Heart of Atlantis. He shouldn't die. |
| 1604 | lara | |
| 1605 | Anonymous | we love Carson |
| 1606 | Luke Dodd | |
| 1607 | Jessica Watt | Bring Beckett back to SGA! He was awesome! Everyone misses him so much! we need him! |
| 1608 | Raz | I believe it is important to the integrity of the Stargate Atlantis team that Dr. Carson Beckett, portrayed by Paul McGillion to remain on the show as an active member of the team. Despite the fact that Jewel Staite is a good actress, she lacks the vibrant attribute that Dr. Beckett brings to the infirmary and the cast. I urge you to consider the feelings of your fans by refraining from such drastic changes in the cast, and by retaining the character of Dr. Beckett. Thank you. |
| 1609 | Brian W | When killing off a main character from a TV show, it is wise to consider exactly when and how. Unfortunately, with Carson Beckett, 'Sunday' was a poor vehicle to wrap Carson's death around. It's one thing for a character to die in battle, it's entirely another for Carson to die for such a petty reason. 'Sunday' is badly devised, the tone is wrong and it minimizes Carson's role in the show. The episode gave little respect to the character's death. For this reason, Carson should come back to at least have a more befitting character closer. |
| 1610 | Anonymous | Save our beloved Carson Beckett!!!! |
| 1611 | Anonymous | Please save Dr. Backett. There is no Atlantis without him.Please! |
| 1612 | Anonymous | Having to wait till the dvd releases of the episodes here to actually watch them, i was shocked and angry that my favorite character on the show was killed off. Im not sure of the backstage politics behind it, if any, but this character MUST be brought back to full time character status is some way. The episodes after 'Sunday' felt empty after this, and i hope this feeling goes when season 4 comes out here at the end of '08. |
| 1613 | Ulrike Görges | He is the good soul in Stargate Atlantis! In addition he is my favourite character and I don't want to miss him anymore. So bring him back!!! |
| 1614 | Christine C | Bring him back full time |
| 1615 | Stephanie Mullin | I love Carson and I love Paul, thank you for putting him in future episodes for season 5 and the 2 episodes of season 4. I'd love to see him upgraded to one of the main characters again though |
| 1616 | Anonymous | |
| 1617 | Michelle Rodgers | He's the ubiquitous father figure and stalwart anchor for all the other characters on the show. Killing him off was not a smart move. Bring him back. |
| 1618 | Marina Alves | Please don't kill off Carson's clone to.
Pleasssseee |
| 1619 | Joell Schedler | |
| 1620 | Marcia Ferris | Save our beloved Carson. We want him back. |
| 1621 | Anonymous | I loveeeee Carson, even though I just started watching the show he was immediately a favorite. I just watched Sunday a few nights ago, and I legitimately cried. I really think he was an asset to the show, and he should be back as a full time cast member |
| 1622 | R friedline | would love to have him come back... |
| 1623 | Anonymous | Save Carson Beckett! |
| 1624 | jason rundle | i need him back plaese! |
| 1625 | tina | carson rules so dont take him off of the show! that a reason some people watch the show! |
| 1626 | Sebastian Tinschert | from Germany |
| 1627 | Chris Pritchard | SAVE HIM! |
| 1628 | Rohaa | Carson, to me, made SGA into a living, breathing show rather than just an action packed shooting spiel. He was not just a medic, but a caring, compassionate man, and without him SGA would have been a cold place indeed. I was shocked to see him killed off so uselessly at the end of S3. Please, please bring back the voice of humanity, the only one who made sure the others would check their ethics and not become the very thing they're fighting, and, incidentally, the one who made atlantis a home to many people |
| 1629 | Ian Gazzotti | |
| 1630 | Ian Gazzotti | |
| 1631 | Amanda | We need our beloved Dr. Beckett back! Not just for 5 episodes, but for good! |
| 1632 | Anonymous | |
| 1633 | Anonymous | What else is there to say? SAVE CARSON!!! |
| 1634 | Ted Wenner | The show lost a great thing with the loss of Paul McGillion. I for one have stopped watching regularly because of this loss. Please write the character in more permanently. |
| 1635 | reuben | Yes...I absolutely agree that the role of Dr. Carson Beckett should be played by Paul McGillion. He is one of the best and my favourite character in all the series of stargate. WE WANT TO SEE HIM ACTING AGAIN IN THE COMING SEASON!!!!! |
| 1636 | Stargatelvr | |
| 1637 | Stargatelvr | |
| 1638 | Anonymous | |
| 1639 | Tay | |
| 1640 | Angela McKinley | Please bring the lovable, likable Beckett back!! |
| 1641 | J Porter | Bring him back!!!!! |
| 1642 | Britt Kirstine Faurholt | How could they do this???? I really really hope they (Every one behind this scandal) bring our Carson back. Or I have seen the last episode......... |
| 1643 | IceKat | Why do all the good characters get written out? Carson as a character added a humantiy to the show. Now he's gone and so is his humanity. Very sad. |
| 1644 | IceKat | PS- I should also mention that being an Aussie fan I'm dissapointed that I couldn't sign this earlier. Watching the episode on TV tonight was the first I'd heard of it. |
| 1645 | Ross Evans | Save Carson Beckett! He is one of the best! |
| 1646 | Belinda Downs | Why oh why did you get rid of the only UK member of the SGA team? Carson Beckett makes a refreshing change to the show from the mostly north American accents! Carson's character is also so caring & sensitive, had you ever thought that he is why lots of females watch the show! It's also nice to see a scottish man for it shows that the SGA mission is a lot more globally involved! Don't let him go! |
| 1647 | Tian Feng | I signed because I really liked his character and I thought there was good chemistry between him and the other crew members. I really was disappointed about his absence from the show. It really feels like something is lacking without him. |
| 1648 | Stephen Hudgins | |
| 1649 | Anna Campbell | Fantastic show!!! |
| 1650 | Tom Tromans | I Love Carson Beckett
Hes amazing
Long Live Scotland |