| # | Name | Comments |
|---|
| 1501 | Anonymous | |
| 1502 | Rebekah Rivers | I haven't seen the show very much, but I still enjoy it. I'm not entirely sure who Carson Beckett is, but I DO know that all the characters make the show worth watching. |
| 1503 | Deborah Altenbeck | I know I'm a little late, but I just saw the episode in Germany.
I was so shocked when saw him die this rather unworthy way. I can't see why you want to blow him up into peaces, JUST AS HE ALMOST GOT AWAY! It's pathetic. This character deserves a better ending, if at all! He really balances the temperaments in the show. he is the calm nice optimistic guy, and he will be missing.
If you want to get rid of somebody don't kill them in such an ugly way, especially after you know that so many fans just love him. Now you also got rid of any chances to get him back in a logic way....
Thanks guys..... -.- |
| 1504 | Anonymous | |
| 1505 | Robert Syme | I think that Beckett is very much a core character for the show. I feel that Paul McGillion's humane portrayal of the character is a real reason for that. Please bring him back. |
| 1506 | Philippe Bourassa | It was "bloody insanity" to kill him in the first place !!! |
| 1507 | Anonymous | |
| 1508 | Sandra Rau | i love carson beckett. He is the best!! |
| 1509 | Iris Barkhuysen | Please have him back for good! |
| 1510 | Miy | there is no Stargate Atlantis with out Beckett (and his awesome accent) |
| 1511 | Diane B. | |
| 1512 | Anonymous | I am writing in regards to Dr. Carson Beckett’s character on Stargate Atlantis. I was a big Atlantis fan, until Dr. Carson Beckett was killed off. I believe that Carson Beckett’s role in the show was essential. While it may not have been intended in the beginning of the Atlantis series, I feel that the first three seasons really helped with the development of Carson’s character, and made him loved by everyone. I enjoyed how he was the opposite of Rodney McKay’s character and how the two characters always seem to balance each other out. The relationship between them reminds me of the relationship between Jack O’Neill & Daniel Jackson on Stargate SG-1. Further, Carson’s character reminds me of Dr. McCoy from Star Trek, with Scotty’s Accent, and neither of the two characters is expendable.
I feel that it was a huge mistake to kill off Dr. Carson Beckett. My family, friends and I haven’t been following the show much ever since Carson Beckett died, and we are anxiously awaiting the 2 episodes, where he will reappear (The Kindred Part I & II). Thanks to Sci-Fi dead does not necessarily mean dead forever (Daniel Jackson’s character is a perfect example of this). I respectfully request that Carson Beckett’s character be brought back for not just two episodes in season 5, but all episodes.
I know that your time is very valuable. Thank you very much for your time, and for allowing me to express my feelings towards a matter which is very important to me |
| 1513 | Anonymous | Bring Back Carson!!!!!!!!!!! |
| 1514 | Michele Lindauer | Please save Carson Beckett. |
| 1515 | Thomas Carlsson | Coolest scottsman since Scotty |
| 1516 | Nick Dionne | Carson is one, if not the best character in the show always happy and funny they must bring him back |
| 1517 | Patrick Fritzsche | Please bring him back...my Girlfriend is always crying when she remembers him. |
| 1518 | Morgane | I am a French Fan and Carson Beckett is the most lovely character on Stargate Atlantis ! I want him to acte on SGA forever ! |
| 1519 | xinrl | Please save him, somehow. |
| 1520 | Anonymous | |
| 1521 | Anonymous | Bring Carson back............ NOW!!!!! |
| 1522 | Josiah | Carson is far too good to kill, hell, refilm the show from the Sunday episode onwards for all i care! |
| 1523 | emma | i know its a bit late to sign this petition but i have only just found this site. Carson should come back he was great and i loved his accent :P he was and is the best character. BRING BACK CARSON! |
| 1524 | Stefanie Buder | |
| 1525 | Hauke Seyffarth | The episode was sent this wednesday in the german television and i was shocked that Carson was ripped off the show. I really - and I'm sure many other german fans too - want him back. |
| 1526 | Syrypy Ang | I am always disappointed when a tv show kills of main characters that they have expended many season developing. You lose alot fans when you do this. I am not sure why TV directors are like this. I am a Mechanical Engineer and we don't throw away things we have spent many years developing that cost time and money. But in the movie busssiness it seems this is more the rule. Most of your successful shows don't go off killing off there main characters. Because over the seasons tv show you general atttract a following group of fans for each character. I hope this will bring back Dr. Carson Beckett and Dr. Weir. Don't disappoint me. I have bought all your DVD seasons epsisode. So I a paying fan LOL! |
| 1527 | Anonymous | i love carson and when they killed carson off i cryed the whole time and when they refer to him now, i still cry, they really really need to bring him back. |
| 1528 | Markus | I think he is part of the series and has to play (if he wants) till the last one which will hopefully never been taken…
I would miss him. He does a great job.
From Austria (not Australia hi,hi) best wishes for all Stargatemembers and all the fans arround the globe,
Markus |
| 1529 | ginny | i know i`m a little late - i`m sorry - but better now than never :-) i also think that carson beckett is such a very lovely and friendly character of stargate atlantis. he is so popular by the fans and his fellow actors - it is a must-have to keep paul mcgillion on the show. we love & need him - please come back! |
| 1530 | Daryn McGarva | Carson was the best we need him bak!! AND Scottish!!! |
| 1531 | Anita | Bring Carson back! He's the funniest and the most adorable guy in Atlantis! |
| 1532 | kim kickbusch | Sg Atlantis had good character chemistry and the removal of Carson Bekkett is like removing a critical chemical compound. No wonder the show is blown to smitherines now. We loved Carson and don't know now if we want to watch the show unless he's reinstated permantly. Paul is a great actor with great heart and screen presence... please bring him back permantly.
From Kim from Australia |
| 1533 | Anonymous | Carson Beckett rocks! He has to return as a regular! |
| 1534 | john wong | PLEASE BRING HIM BACK!! |
| 1535 | Natasha | We love Carson, don't take him away! |
| 1536 | the fan | give us back carson beckett!! |
| 1537 | Anonymous | he should be back |
| 1538 | Anonymous | I loved his character, the sense of humor and the humility. He is a natural and I can't wait see him back where he belongs. |
| 1539 | KuC | |
| 1540 | Charlotte | Même en France nous pensons à toi Carson !
Please Save Carson Beckett !! |
| 1541 | Anonymous | Please, we need Carson back!! He was a big part of the reason I watched the show, and when he died a little bit of my love for SGA died with him. |
| 1542 | Anonymous | |
| 1543 | Mark Lago | Say it ain't so!!!!! Come back! |
| 1544 | Alison Lago | Please come back! No one can fill your shoes. |
| 1545 | Zak | so he's back for 5 episodes.............. I still want him as a REGULAR CHARACTER again!!!!!!! |
| 1546 | Stephen Hoogendijk | Carson Beckett is awesome! |
| 1547 | Anonymous | asdasd |
| 1548 | Anonymous | |
| 1549 | Alima Alimena | SAVE CARSON BECKETT NOT JUST FOR 5 EPISODES, THATS AN INSULT!!!!. WE WANT HIM PERMANENTLY!!!!!!! |
| 1550 | Anonymous | Carson Rocks |