| # | Name | Comments |
|---|
| 151 | Anonymous | |
| 152 | Andy Main | Fond memories of some of my first vs's would be a shame to lose a central belt venue we have to few already! |
| 153 | Alan Halewood | The quarry is an amenity for 100s of central Scotland climbers.
It has existed c;ose to housing with no safety issue for years.
It should be possible to manage its existance in the future. |
| 154 | Chris Craggs | |
| 155 | Martin Whittaker | Back-filling the quarry simply to prevent people from falling in to it seems unnecessarily drastic. Surely simply fencing off casual access routes from above, leaving a route available for people who want to gain access to the quarry floor, would be sufficient? If the access route left open was designed to be difficult to negotiate for any but pedestrian access, that might also help to reduce the incidence of unwelcome use being made of the quarry eg by illegal, unlicensed motorcycles or for dumping rubbish. |
| 156 | Katie Ward | |
| 157 | Roy Taylor | There are very few climbing venues in central Scotland. Rosyth quarry is an important resource, and as a local I would be saddened to see it lost. Please preserve the quarry. |
| 158 | Anonymous | |
| 159 | dan bailey | As one of the few places in the Edinburgh / Fife are where rock climbing can be enjoyed outdoors and for free, the amenity value of Rosyth Quarry to thousands of local climbers is extremely high. It is particularly suitable for beginners and youth groups, and as such should be considered a natural resource to be protected rather than destroyed. People need houses, but outdoor recreation and development can coexist, given the necessary vision in local government and the community. The quarry ought to be tidied up and turned into a park for local residents, and the excellent rock climbing preserved for future generations. It's not just a hole in the ground - back filling would be an act of vandalism. |
| 160 | Rod Dalitz | I have enjoyed many happy evenings climbing in Rosyth Quarry, and I hope future generations will continue to enjoy healthy outdoor sport in real-world situations. |
| 161 | Eric Christison | |
| 162 | Anonymous | the quarry is an important place for climbing. There's not much climbing about Edinburgh. Loss of recreational space affects the whole area. |
| 163 | John Donald | I would be very unhappy about the use of this quarry for dumping purposes. It has been a recreational climbing venue for many, many years and it is very important it is kept for this rectreational purpose. |
| 164 | Anonymous | |
| 165 | hebe carus | |
| 166 | Andrew Lindley | |
| 167 | Sean Bell | Id be sad to see this crag disappear, Ive spent many a good evening in there, some of the climbs are superb and very good for taking your first steps onto the rock.With its ease of access and its proximity to the Edinburgh International Climbing Arena at Ratho, It would be a valuable outdoor training ground lost if it were to go..
Save the quarry! |
| 168 | Mark Davison | Isn't the Scottish Govt. trying to encourage more people to take exercise? |
| 169 | Anonymous | |
| 170 | Stuart Mitchell | This quarry is a valuable and much loved local resource for Fife, Lothian and Central Belt rock climbers. It is also used by locals who would lose yet another part of scarce recreational ground close to home if the development went ahead. As climbers and some locals are committed to clearing up the quarry and making a more agreeable place for all, I would urge the council to reject this application on the grounds of the quarry being at least a recreational resource of significant regional importance. |
| 171 | James Hendry | Never been climbing there, so can't say how brilliant it is, but but would like the chance to find out. |
| 172 | Mark Lydon | Heathy & Cathy are central belt classic climbs! |
| 173 | Helen Peters | |
| 174 | Ernie Brewster | |
| 175 | Anonymous | As a novice climber I just recently discovered Rosyth quarry and have been fortunate to recent some tuition there from fellow climbers. I hope to continue to use the quarry to increase my climbing competence. |
| 176 | Graeme Walker | It would be an outrage if this important climbing venue was lost forever.
This can not be allowed to happen |
| 177 | Anonymous | Its a shame that The George Wimpey Group cant resolve this small problem for such a large organisiation. Keeping the use of the quarry and developing buildings in a safe environment is could a logistical dream project to a engineer with a bit of time given to the situation.
Its also worth thinking that the future workers of Wimpey Homes may be one of those kids who play or climb at Rosyth Quarry building up their self confidence through rock climbing and biking.
Is it so imposible to build new homes with out having to demolish popualar venues of gathering for recreation and education. |
| 178 | Dave Adams | |
| 179 | Shauna Clarke | A great place to climb and soak up the atmosphere of Roysth! |
| 180 | kenny alexander | make the developers use the money it would cost to back fill the quarry to develope parking and picnic facilities |
| 181 | dan | |
| 182 | Keith Newton | |
| 183 | Mark Hammonds | |
| 184 | Nicol strachan | |