| # | Name | Comments |
|---|
| 1 | Mick | Hell yeah man - Melvins ruuule!! |
| 2 | shayne arseneault | |
| 3 | Anonymous | That would be fanstatic. |
| 4 | Anonymous | That would be fanstatic. |
| 5 | Elva Torres-Estrella | YES! Please add THE MELVINS to Guitar Hero IV!!
Thank you! |
| 6 | Kate Wise | |
| 7 | Ben | Hell yeah, man! This needs to happen. |
| 8 | Brad L. | This song F'n rips! It must be added! |
| 9 | Tim Kindberg | DO IT |
| 10 | Stephen Streit | The Melvins inspired the rock of today and the rock of the future. They deserve a place in Guitar Hero history more than most bands involved! |
| 11 | Barry Monahan | SICK! |
| 12 | ted zebra | more melvins is always good. |
| 13 | mdc | guitar queero |
| 14 | James MacDonald | One of the heaviest songs ever recorded. |
| 15 | Eirik Kjøs Usterud | The Melvins aren't getting the respect they deserve. Guitar Hero should include them instead of shite bands like dragonforce. |
| 16 | Cassie Hunsucker | My comment is simpley quotted, "They F***ing Rock!" |
| 17 | chiba | i heart metal! |