| # | First Name | Last Name | State | Country | Comments |
|---|
| 1351 | Jesse | Blue | | | |
| 1352 | Anonymous | Anonymous | MO | US | |
| 1353 | Edward | Stuart | AR | US | Willie was my favorite player ever and made me love watching the cardinals with his passion and love of the game. |
| 1354 | Jason | Lee | MO | US | |
| 1355 | Don | Horn | | | |
| 1356 | Shay | DeLarm | MO | US | You have to retire McGee before you retire Jim Edmonds number. |
| 1357 | william | divin | LA | US | Next to Stan the Man, Willie is the man. |
| 1358 | Mike | Beard | | | |
| 1359 | brett | stockmann | | | |
| 1360 | Alan | Dalman | | | |
| 1361 | Scott | Luckadoo | | | Should have been retired a long time ago. |
| 1362 | Zachariah | Kesterson | | | RETIRE #51. Willie deserves it |
| 1363 | Mike | Haynes | | US | |
| 1364 | ben | whetstone | | | |
| 1365 | Anonymous | Anonymous | | CA | I was always amazed at how Willie was able to hit the ball even when it looked like it was unhittable. I really enjoyed watching Willie McGee as a player in the Major Leagues |
| 1366 | Karen | Kosuge | IL | US | My all-time favorite Cardinal! |
| 1367 | Patrick | Wilkins | NM | US | Willie is very deserving of this honor. |
| 1368 | chris | hayden | | | |
| 1369 | Wes | Simpson | MO | US | |
| 1370 | steven | nixon | GA | US | great great player. very underrated. |
| 1371 | charles | delehey | NJ | US | |
| 1372 | Keith | Allen | GA | US |
| 1373 | Adam | Ham | | US | Willie McGee is the best. THE BEST! |
| 1374 | john | kopolow | MD | US | Willie is (or was) the last athlete with humility. For his character and his accomplishments, his number as a Cardinal should be retired. |
| 1375 | Demetra | Slak | | | |
| 1376 | Jeff | Breneman | | US | |
| 1377 | DAVID | DILLARD | MO | US | Willie McGee deserves to have his jersey retired! One of the greatest Cardinals outfielder of all time! |
| 1378 | Eric | Clark | NC | US | willie was the man.Should be in the hall of fame. |
| 1379 | Sam | Fels | | | |
| 1380 | mike | mcgee | MO | | i grew up watching willie and has always been my favorite |
| 1381 | daniel | ulmer | IL | US | a man who gave his best efforts always |
| 1382 | Anonymous | Anonymous | IL | US | he deserves to have his 51 retired but so does ted simmons 23 AND CURT FLOOD 21 |
| 1383 | Anonymous | | | | Anonymous |
| 1384 | Mark | Schwindeler | IL | US | |
| 1385 | Eric | Felker | | | |
| 1386 | R. Barry | Creech | MO | US | |
| 1387 | Jason | Pilarski | MO | US | Near 2,000 hits, .300 hitter, an MVP, two batting titles, three W/S appearances, one title, and three gold gloves as a Cardinal. What else does a man have to do to get a number retired for a team? |
| 1388 | Anonymous | Anonymous | | CA | |
| 1389 | Ken | Malubay | CA | US | As a big Cardinal Fan since 1962, Willie Magee
deserves to have his Jersey retired! |
| 1390 | Sonja | Foster | | US | I love Willie McGee. When he returned to St. Louis, I cried. He was a great player and deserves to have his number retired. |
| 1391 | chris | mcgee | MO | US | |
| 1392 | ronn | craig | | | willie was my favorite Cardinal of the 80s and my second favorite of all time |
