| # | First Name | Last Name | State | Country | Comments |
|---|
| 1 | Anonymous | Anonymous | | US | For you Willie McGee... Thank you for the memories |
| 2 | Brad | Goodman | | | GO Willie! |
| 3 | cary | honea | | | |
| 4 | Randa | Keelin | IL | US | Willie's the best! |
| 5 | John | Helm | | | |
| 6 | Anonymous | Anonymous | | | |
| 7 | Robert | Colonder | MO | US | |
| 8 | steve | gardner | | | |
| 9 | Matthew | Bergfeld | | | |
| 10 | Bryan | Hug | MO | | |
| 11 | Katie | Bergfeld | MO | US | |
| 12 | Ryan | Reynolds | IL | | One of the most loved Cardinals ever. Played the game the right way. #51 shall forever be his! |
| 13 | kenneth | clark | KY | US | he was a great player he should be in the h.o.f. |
| 14 | Sarah | Johannigmeier | | | I am a die-hard Willie fan. There is nothing else I would like to see more in Busch III than a 51 flag with all the other Cardinal greats. |
| 15 | Amanda | Hettich | | US | Willie has always been my favorite Cardinal player, I would love to see him where he belongs |
| 16 | Kurt | Samuels | | US | |
| 17 | Ron | Williams | | | |
| 18 | Mary | Williams | | | |
| 19 | Darren | Scotti | MO | | His number, deservingly
belongs atop with the other Cardinal greats from the
past and remebered not only for the player but also
the person and what a St. Louis Cardinal should be.
Willie McGee No. 51 "RETIRED" |
| 20 | Anonymous | Anonymous | MO | US | |
| 21 | Anonymous | Anonymous | | | GO WILLIE! |
| 22 | Tara | Scotti | MO | US | |
| 23 | Tracy | Breck | | | |
| 24 | Mark | Warren | MO | US | Willie is one of the most beloved Cardinals of all time. He deserves to have his 51 retired. |
| 25 | Anonymous | Anonymous | MO | US | |
| 26 | Kimberly | Bishop | | | |
| 27 | Anonymous | Anonymous | | | |
| 28 | Mike | Carr | MO | | |
| 29 | Anonymous | Anonymous | MO | US | Go Cards. |
| 30 | Gwen | Roulx | | US | |
| 31 | Shay | Lewis | MO | US | |
| 32 | Anonymous | Anonymous | MO | US | |
| 33 | L. | Meyer | | US | |
| 34 | Anonymous | Anonymous | | | |
| 35 | Debbie | Droll | | | |
| 36 | Mary | Williams | | | We love you Willie! |
| 37 | Lynn | Weaver | MO | | willie is great! |
| 38 | Kari | McCann | | US | |
| 39 | gary | waqrd jr | | US | |
| 40 | Michele | Cygan-Fore | | | |
| 41 | Tim | Murphy | MO | US | |
| 42 | Karen | Berryman | | | |
| 43 | Anonymous | Anonymous | | | |
| 44 | John | Hartley | | | |
| 45 | Mike | Hart | MO | US | In a time of gambling, steroids and everything else wrong with sports, we need to look back at one of baseball's purest role models Wille McGee. His numbers speak for themselves as well as his impact on St. Louis Cardinals history and the community |
| 46 | JENNIFER | MARTIN | | | |
| 47 | Gretchen | Dolan | | | |
| 48 | dan | green | MO | US | |
| 49 | Paula | Jackson | MO | US | Willie's earned it!!!! |
| 50 | Anonymous | Anonymous | | | |
