| # | Name | Comments |
|---|
| 401 | Malouf | |
| 402 | elisabethvf | carson-paul forever |
| 403 | Anonymous | Please bring Carson back, it wont be the same without him. |
| 404 | Jared Parkinson | |
| 405 | Julianne | Please make his return permanent ! I love his character. Save Carson !! |
| 406 | Robyn | When Michael left Stargate, that was his choice. But Stargate was rubbish without him. Now you're doing the same to Atlantis on purpose! Bring our gorgeous Scot back! |
| 407 | ellen amanda louise | I'm a devotional watcher of both SG1 and Atlantis. In a discussion I had long before Carson was written out i had proclaimed him to be my FAVORITE character. I really think that you should have researched your market a little better before writing out such a loved character. I am reminded of the blunder of the removal of Daniel Jackson in season 5 of SG1. It seem that the Stargate franchise is doomed to repeat the same mistakes over and over. |
| 408 | Martina | I love Carson's scottish accent. Without him, there's no hero in SGA |
| 409 | neil | bring carson back or im not watching or buying anymore dvds |
| 410 | lisa | we love beckett |
| 411 | BritPod | Beckett can't die! |
| 412 | renee | I love Carson. Hes my baby. |
| 413 | Susan Denney | I love Carson Beckett in which Paul McGillion made him great in the roll. The character is only as good as the actor and Paul is great. Atlantis is not going to be the same without him. I did not see Carson get killed off until today and I cried and cried. Paul has a great chemistry with the other actors and he caught my attention with continuing to watch the show. Please bring him back to the full cast status. I love how Beckett interacted with everyone. Don't kill the show by killing Beckett off and not bringing him back. I love you Paul, you are a great actor!!!! |
| 414 | Anonymous | please bring him back |
| 415 | Anonymous | please bring him back |
| 416 | Anonymous | Worst move the fellas at SGA have ever made...
What's your rationale?
Kill off one of the most popular characters and replace him with a bland, uni-dimentional nobody?
Then bring him back for an episode arc despite blaring evidence that the fans of SGA are wanting nothing more than for Carson to return.
Fucking morons. |
| 417 | Bernadett Ver | Save Carson Beckett |
| 418 | Daniel | Save Carson! |
| 419 | chris scholes | Bring back beckett permanently, he should not of bein killed of the show. It won't be the same with out him. |
| 420 | Anonymous | |
| 421 | Laura | |
| 422 | Anonymous | SAVE CARSON!!!!!! We love him!!!!!! |
| 423 | Anonymous | Can't write a letter because I don't want my personal info released, but I would like to say that Paul McGillion was the reason I watched Atlantis because his character is so compassionate and is really the one who holds everyone together in Atlantis. I can't even begin to imagine a Stargate Atlantis without him. If he isn't brought back I can imagine that this show will lose many viewers seeing as he's the heart and soul of it. It won't be Atlantis without him. |
| 424 | Sentinel | |
| 425 | aislin | hes down to earth, comedic, and the heart, unbelievable you dont know how valuable he is to the show |
| 426 | Anonymous | |
| 427 | Renee | Bring Carson back or I will stop watching the show, It really mean it! |
| 428 | Anonymous | Bring Carson back or I will stop watching the show, It really mean it! |
| 429 | Kiara | |
| 430 | nick moore | its 'bloody insanity' |
| 431 | Casey McKenzie | BRING HIM BAAAAAACK! |
| 432 | Anonymous | Stargate Atlantis just isn't the same with out him |
| 433 | Chris Fletcher | |
| 434 | Ari-chan | HAX. He's gonna die?? T_T MAI LYF IZ OVR. |
| 435 | Tabitha Mueller | Please bring Paul McGillion as Carson Beckett back to the Atlantis!
I love his accent and his is such a good actor!
Thank you for bringing im back for more than 4 episodes. |
| 436 | Robert | |
| 437 | Matt Woods | Please bring Paul McGillion and Rainbow Franks back full time to the show. |
| 438 | Lauren | Bring Beckett Back! |
| 439 | Anne | we love Carson Beckett. i just read on the site that he will be back. yay!. i am bit late here because i watch the episodes in french version. |
| 440 | Kerry Batty | You must bring Carson back. I read somwhere where Paul says you need to spice a show up or fans will get bored. I know he was being modest, but he's wrong (sorry Paul) fans like consistency, we fall in love with a character and we Love to see them over and over again. Take Stargate SG1 for example, 10 years people have been watching we love the show and I say if it ain't broken why fix try and fix it or change it. He's an integral part of the lightheartedness (love the word, lol) to the show and without him and David's comedic companionship something will be missing.
Hope it says what we all feel. We love Paul love what he's done with the character and we want it to continue. It's as simple as that! So bring him back. Gosh now I'm breaking out in song, you gotta bring him back. Oh and I mean for good not just here and there. |
| 441 | Anonymous | Please bring back Carson, not just for an episode, but every episode! |
| 442 | Jeannie Thiede | |
| 443 | mandy | i want him back. |
| 444 | Anonymous | bring him back !! |
| 445 | Mandi Storm | |
| 446 | Brandon Bru | Please bring carson back!!! Please!!!! |
| 447 | frederic | you morons, why did you kill him?! bring him back NOOOOOOOOOWWWWWW!!!!!!!!!! |
| 448 | Alison Mueller | Thank you for doing such a good show like Stargate Atlantis. I really enjoy watching it. But please, give Atlantis his heart back and bring Dr. Carson Beckett back to the show.
That would be great!
Thank you in advance. |
| 449 | Maud Leblanc-Lortie | bring him back **cries** |
| 450 | charlie | I held off from petitioning because I was so initially upset about Carson being killed off. I'm writing now because its months later and I'm still furious and disappointed. I mean can't MGM trim some of its executive fat in order to keep Carson, not to mention Dr. Elizabeth Weir portrayed by Tori Higginson. Let go of the exec who made these decisions. |