| # | Name | Comments |
|---|
| 351 | Anonymous | NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!! No people should die for ratings! Not l-like W-Wash...WAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! WAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! |
| 352 | Sasha Broderick | Dr. Carson Beckett is truly the heart of Atlantis, an every man's man, and a true hero. Atlantis cannot be the same without him. Please don't take him from us. |
| 353 | RDG | Bring back Carson!!! |
| 354 | Aaron | What the hec! You can't kill Carson! He's the only sane one there! Bring him back dangnabbit! |
| 355 | Anonymous | |
| 356 | Philip Driskill | What idiots in charge removed the most interesting character of the show??? Why watch it any more? |
| 357 | Konrad | |
| 358 | Anonymous | |
| 359 | Katie C. | I am outraged. Writers should pay more attention to the fans. Killing off a major character is never a good move... |
| 360 | Robert Wright | Bring back Dr. Beckett. Getting rid of the character was a bad decision. |
| 361 | Anonymous | |
| 362 | Anonymous | Please bring back Carson Beckett. He was the humanity on the show. Always the good guy. |
| 363 | Ashton | Please don't kill Dr. Beckett!! I lov-es him!!!!! >. |
| 364 | Gyoru louis | w |
| 365 | Anonymous | Bring back Carson Beckett! |
| 366 | Mark Bennett | This show is getting so bad. It seems like they just want to hire people for T&A to get raitings. After 7 years of SG1 i had no problem not watching it after they screwed around with that show. I hope the show's ratings and DVD sales go down. |
| 367 | Kesma O'Reilly | |
| 368 | Carrie Jourdan | We need to keep the good guys. It gives us a bright spot in the show. Good guys should finish first. |
| 369 | Anonymous | Bring him back. Vital for the show |
| 370 | Julie Martin | The fact is, everyone loves Beckett! |
| 371 | Joanne Martin | I love Dr. Beckett. The character evens out the show and just when the scripts for him start getting real good he's killed off. I cried for days. After having lost my son a few months before this came unexpectedly & now Dr. Weir seems destined to suffer the same fate!!! Most producers don't have the guts to kill off beloved characters, so I'm shocked at what has happened. I personally miss Carsons accent & can't watch the show without him. It just hurts too much. I can understand that there are times when a person has to follow their heart & do what is right. It is my hope that Mr. McGillion left of his own free will & wish him all the best. |
| 372 | Anonymous | Bring him back! The cast is perfect- keep them together. |
| 373 | Anonymous | Save Carson!!! |
| 374 | Anonymous | |
| 375 | Christei | |
| 376 | Anonymous | Beckett gone? Elizabeth gone? I'm gone. |
| 377 | Anonymous | |
| 378 | Corinna | It was a shock to me when Dr. Beckett died. I cried. He brought warmth to the cast. I honestly felt like there was no reason to watch the show anymore. (no offense to the other cast members intended)
I was not in the loop so I did not know that this was in the works. Please listen to the fans, bring him back!!! |
| 379 | Melanie | DAMMIT, he's already dead. Plus he exploded. What. The. Hell.
Bring Back Beckett! |
| 380 | Sarah Patrick | Please don't take Beckett away from us |
| 381 | Jerred | I want Carson back ASAP!!!! |
| 382 | Me | GO CARSON!!!!! |
| 383 | Kyra Kuijpers Leader Of The SGAngels | WE WANT CARSON BACK!!!!!!! That's all i have to say!!!! |
| 384 | Laura Povea | |
| 385 | Ezri Skardzius | Carson RULES!! |
| 386 | Stargate Fan | Bring Carson back! This sucks! |
| 387 | Miika Aitomaa | Only God can resurrect in real-lfe as in Sci-Fi, so please make Him do the resurection of Dr. Beckett. |
| 388 | Herve | |
| 389 | David Evans | |
| 390 | eb | I wasn't a regular viewer of the original Stargate series, but some talk on livejournal and the charms of Joe Flanigan finally convinced me to give Atlantis a chance.
To my utter surprise, as much as I love Flanigan and Hewlett and others, it was Paul McGillion's brilliant perfomance as Dr. Carson Beckett which totally enraptured me, even knowing plans were afoot to off his character. I found myself looking forward to any moment he would appear in an episode.
I feel betrayed by TPTB. Do I matter? Does the money I will spend on seasons with Carson/Paul matter ?
Paul has been wonderfully gracious about this whole mess....a big boy he might have said.
Well, I don't have to be a big girl about this. The people who made this decision have my earned my scorn. For being in the world of scifi, you would hope for some creative thinking. Instead, we get a recycled shock tactic to stir things up.
Everything I read about Paul suggests he is well-liked by cast and crew. Fans who have met him rave about how wonderful he is to them.
Way to treat Paul TPTB!
*disgusted* |
| 391 | Elizabeth Coleman | It’s sad that the producers are so shortsighted as to get rid of the character who not only created a unique and entertaining repartee with Beckett, but was the “middle-aged woman’s” sex symbol on the show. |
| 392 | Elizabeth Coleman | It’s sad that the producers are so shortsighted as to get rid of the character who not only created a unique and entertaining repartee with Beckett, but was the “middle-aged woman’s” sex symbol on the show. |
| 393 | Lucy | Bring back Carson, he's the best thing or Stargate and his smile is the most beautiful in the world. To the Stargate producers please stop killing off the fan favorite, fist Daniel now Carson, they know they will just have to bring him back. |
| 394 | Spacemonkey | Save Dr. Carson Beckett NOW! |
| 395 | Esther | Please bring back Dr Carson Beckett. It's fantastic he is back for two episodes in season 4 but lets have him back for good. :-) |
| 396 | Janet Hughes | Please let me know what I can do to ensure Dr. Beckett returns for every episode, whole and healthy.
I have several things that have to be done here at home, but will get to all of the Carson Beckett letters, Yahoo chat, and everything else.
Which letters are the most important to write? I was involved in bringing Jericho back, and that show and its actors/characters do not begin to remotely compare to Paul McGillion/Carson Beckett! |
| 397 | Anonymous | Looks like they pulled a Joss Whedon to me! When Angel started it's second season, he decided to shake things up by getting rid of Doyle only to later regret the decision. Yes, I still watched as other fans also did and it did'nt really hurt the show.
I have been busy with the Lost fandom and had not been up to date on Stargate news, so I didn't know anything about Carson dying until I saw it!
I broke down cying as soon as I realized it wasn't
a joke, right when Rodney was saying if he only had gone fishing...I want him back! If only for Rodney's sake! I don't like that they are getting rid of Wier, why are they doing that?! And bringing in
Carter will only make Rodney act stupid and I'm a Rodney girl and I just hate that! I don't mind if he gets a girlfriend but Sam, c'mon! Why Sam anyway? What about Daniel? He's a hottie and he was supposed to go there anyway when that stupid Vala kept him from going! And yeah, Danny came back from the dead SO much that it was pitiful! I love Danny but they wore that a bit thin!
In truth, I hated the last season of SG1 and only saw a few of the episodes this year and in my opinion the last episode stunk! I will state this only once people....DANIEL DOES NOT NOW NOR EVER WILL LOVE VALA! Ok, back to Carson, I became a fan of Dr. Beckett's when he first met up with Ronin and the way he handled his very angry
patient was so kind and gentle and honest! Before that he was just the doctor but now he was in my heart! I was upset by the news of Wier going and I
STILL don't know why?! But Carson dying was just plain wrong! I think they are gonna bring him back as a replicator and that may make him hard to swallow! Please bring him back as a clone, ascended
or alternate universe version! Actually I read someone's idea above to have Rodney go back in time to save him, a la Marty McFly saving Doc!
(Just don't mention that to Rodney cause he hates
BTTF!) BTW, the new doctor is stupid, period.
Nothing special about her! Enough said. BRING BACK CARSON, the other Dr. Beckett I care about!
Right Sam? ^_~ Peace be in the galaxy fools! |
| 398 | Anthony | |
| 399 | Peter | |
| 400 | James Shaw | Aye! Represent my brother! Save Beckett! |