| # | First Name | Last Name | State | Country | Comments |
|---|
| 1 | Ali | Alamdari | MI | US | Butch is an ivory ticklin' madman. |
| 2 | Chris | Campbell | KY | US | Yeah! |
| 3 | Gary | Lubrat | NY | US | BUTCH IS GOD |
| 4 | Mike | Fitzsimmons | CT | US | Butch rules |
| 5 | michael | bradley | MA | US | Butch is the shit!
i miss tim too though... |
| 6 | Matt | Lopez | | | |
| 7 | Matt | Hollis | TN | US | He Rocks!! |
| 8 | Kevin | Cohn | NY | US | |
| 9 | Rob | Fishman | | | |
| 10 | AJ | Thind | CA | US | Two Step. |
| 11 | J | Mose | PA | US | GO PENETRATORS!!!!!!! |
| 12 | Jared | Riesel | NY | US | BUTCH IS THE SHIT! |
| 13 | Kevin | Estey | | | Make it so -
"#6, Butch Taylor, #6, Butch Taylor!"
-David J. Matthews, 7.29.00 |
| 14 | Amy | Farnsworth | IL | US | Butch is the shit! :) |
| 15 | Nick | Seiler | WV | US | Butch friggin rocks!! Considering he's been a stable on just about every song in '02 as well as '01, let him in already! |
| 16 | Jim | Scanlon | VA | US | BUTCH IS AWESOME!!!! |
| 17 | andrew | reynolds | MA | US | |
| 18 | Chris | Koerner | WI | US | Butch brings so much extra to the band. |
| 19 | Steve | Smith | | | |
| 20 | Brett | Warren | IL | | Butch is my hero! |
| 21 | Drew | Wiley | GA | | Butch is the man! |
| 22 | kerry | lambert | | | |
| 23 | Kathleen | Zeman | OH | US | |
| 24 | Eric | Miller | NY | US | Not only should he be the 6th man, he should be President! Butch rocks! |
| 25 | vinnie | manierre | | | |
| 26 | Chris | Powers | NY | US | Taylor > Greiser |
| 27 | Josh | Gray | NJ | US | |
| 28 | Mike | MacDonald | CT | US | MAKE BUTCH #6 |
| 29 | ben | iseman | | | |
| 30 | Sara | Ebel | WI | US | Butch should definetly be a member of the band!! |
| 31 | Joe | Shambro | LA | US | |
| 32 | Nakulan | Balasubramaniam | OH | US | Butch is the man, make him #6 DMB! |
| 33 | Brad | Coggins | SC | US | |
| 34 | daniel | white | IN | US | |
| 35 | Eric | Fausch | SD | US | Hell Yeah! |
| 36 | A. | Fan | | | Mr. Taylor adds a lot to the sound and character of the band! |
| 37 | Josh | Price | OH | US | I think butch should be a member he is awesome and very important to the live show vibe |
| 38 | Kevin | Wiley | | | |
| 39 | Zachary | Boyd | WA | US | |
| 40 | Anthony | Hayes | TX | US | To me, Butch is a part of the band with out the title. He is a moster musician,and has become my favorite member of the band! |
| 41 | Kristen | Radesi | NY | US | |
| 42 | Steve | Andrews | WA | US | he was awesome at the vancouver show May 25, 2002 |
| 43 | Josh | Coady | MD | US | hell yea butch!
|
| 44 | Eric | Purcell | | CA | Butch rocks. |
| 45 | brian | schemenski | NJ | US | let's do it. |
| 46 | Dennis J | Stafford | IL | US | I LOVE |
| 47 | Michelle | Cole | NC | US | i have been a dmb fan for only 5 years now. i have seen them only 13 times. i wish i could say that i have seen dmb more but i am only 19. butch is simply amazing. i cannot imagine a dmb show without butch now. i think that dmb probably consider butch as a part of the band however it has not been officially announced that butch is the 6th member. i agree that butch should become a part of dmb officially. good luck to all that are voting for this great addition! |
| 48 | John | S. | PA | US | Go Butch! |
| 49 | Tara | Macleod | | CA | Awesome idea! I love Butch! |
| 50 | Brian | Butterfield | OH | US | Better idea. How about making Tim Reynolds the sixth member instead? |
